Siino’s

Ordered a pie to go. Pizza was above average but I wouldn’t say they’re the best. Crust is just a tad chewy and the sauce was a little sweet but overly. I’m chalking chewy crust to travel time.
Will order a slice or two and eat there and will update.
They run specials Mondays and Tuesdays for a large plain at $ 8.99

Try the best eh? Definitely not for the pizza they make, one of the thinnest crusts I’ve ever had. Number of toppings wouldn’t suffice the big void the crust has made. Went with a lot of expectations and came out disappointed. I ate a humble and sorry pizza. Well, pizza comes for the price which is cheap at both.

Very good. Had ½ an Italian based on feedback and staff recommendation. It was very good and filling. Reasonably priced and staff is friendly would stop by again.

I’ve been going to Siino’s for almost 8 years. There is no better Chicken Parm. Everyone is very friendly, and always attentive. Honestly, it’s my favorite place to just get food to go and settle down at home with a movie. Love it

Siiano’s probably makes the best Italian hot dog in the state, and that says a lot! Had gone there for many years when I worked in the local area, and have never had anything but the best hot dog. I am a huge Jimmy Buff’s fan, and went to him in Neward (14^th Ave @ So. 9^th St.) and later when he moved to Rt. 22W in Springfield (by Bow Craft). But I would rate Siiano’s at the top of the list.

Phenomenal Italian Hot Dogs!!! Try them with hot peppers. YUM!

Their motto is «You’ve tried the rest, now try the best.» I’ve certainly tried plenty of pizza places in the area, but I wouldn’t agree with the 2^nd part of that statement. I wouldn’t say it’s a bad pizza, but it’s just a little sub-​par compared to the other places.
The one thing that bothered me was the fact that I got it «to-​go» and they threw it onto the same paper plate (as you would get when you order it dine-​in), but threw that into the bag. No box, nothing else. Really? If I order a chicken parm, would you just throw it into the bag too?
I’ll just go to Federico’s down the street.

I went here on Saturday based on a referral from my Aunt, with my dad and boyfriend. After much discussion my boyfriend and I got a whole Italian sub with everything, because it was cheaper than getting two half subs ($ 9.75) and the small side salad ($ 3.25) and some drinks. When they brought out the sub (which was delicious) we double checked the menu to see if it told you anywhere how big the sub was, and nope it didn’t. The sub was easily 24 inches long by god knows what wide. I laughed; it came on four paper plates. I managed to eat half of my half. I couldn’t touch the side salad which came in a huge bowl, which would easily be considered a full size salad anywhere else. The sub was awesome, the bread was freshly baked and held up to the mayo, mustard, and vinegar/​oil without getting soggy. So much so that when I had half of the half I saved hours later it still tasted fresh and nonsoggy. The meat and cheese I think is cut on order, the veggies were fresh too. If you are Eatontown this place is a must.