Sweet Tooth

Absolutely love this store! They have everything you need here when the other stores like acmoore, cannons and Michaels don’t have something. They will also order items for you if you ask them too!
Yes it does seem a bit cluttered in the store, but thats because they have everything you need!

This place is amazing. Yes there is a lot of stuff in a little store but like kait said, they always have what u are looking for! I never go anywhere else when u need my supplies.

I decided to give Sweet Tooth the review they deserve because the last one just wasn’t fair…
I’m a baking student in culinary school so from the perspective of someone who wants to make baking a career, this place is the best! Yes, it’s cluttered but its a baking supply store… boxes, cake circles, molds, tools… what do you expect? I dare any serious baker to go in there and NOT find what you’re looking for. Whenever, I have an order for something, Sweet Tooth is always my first stop.

Holy hoarding! If there was a «businesses» edition of Hoarders, this place could be on it!
With a name like «Sweet Tooth,» I was expecting/​hoping for some kind of bakery. I was sadly mistaken. I’ve passed this place literally hundreds of times, and thought I’d possibly found a new (and closer) location for some red velvet.
As soon as I walked in… BAM, stuff EVERYWHERE! It literally looked like my Grandmom’s attic. Pans, cookie cutters, decorations, baking supplies, in no discernible order, with no discernible flow, all over the place. I wish I had taken a picture; I thought I was being sucked into Charybdis. There were aisles, but good luck walking down them if you weigh over 100lbs. I really didn’t even bother walking through that part of the store. I hate baking and I ran the risk of potentially getting lost.
After making a beeline for the only actual food in the store, I took some time to survey the selections. A small case of chocolate goodies, a hodge-​podge of Easter candies, and bins of what appeared to be home-​made confections.
I stood at the chocolate case for a while, but the woman at the checkout counter (which was diagonal from the chocolate) barely looked at me, let alone asked if I wanted something. Nothing looked that enticing anyway. There was a paltry selection of sugar free candy/​chocolate. No red velvet anything, anywhere. I picked up an Asher’s chocolate-​coated crisped rice square. I don’t even like «crisped rice,» but claustrophobia makes me do weird things. I also picked up some of the home-​made white chocolate covered pretzels, which were very pretty, and a pouch of chocolates clearly labeled «Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter.» Can’t go wrong with that, right?
I thought the price was a little steep; $ 15 for my 3 items. I’ve had much better and less expensive sweets from the Sweet Shoppe at Smithville (dark chocolate covered red velvet cake pops for $ 1!!!)
So I get home and decide to try the dark chocolate peanut butter cups, but when I take a bite… marshmallow. I HATE marshmallow. The bin I took them from was clearly labeled «chocolate covered peanut butter.» The chocolate was good quality but, yuck. That was a waste of $ 5!
I don’t really know how this place stays open. I’ve never seen any cars here, the outside of the building is very shabby (with an interior to match,) and the selection of goods to remedy your Sweet Tooth (that is their name, is it not?) is sad. I saw they offer a cake decorating class, but I’m not really sure where they’d fit the people.
If I really need a fix that badly, I’ll just go to Wawa.