Andy’s Pub

Empty on a Monday night.
Haven’t been here in over 5 years!
Nice inside. They’ve expanded.
The wings were good. The Butter Garlic Parm is better than the Butter Garlic.
Service was okay. I would return.

Been coming to Andy’s for a while now and it definately is a place that I would recommend. The food is pretty good and the atmosphere is great. Upstairs is all smoke free and down stairs is smoking. Great place to meet friends and the crowd is always good. No problems…

Andys pub is a cool place to hang out and play pool … They have many tables and have smoke free sections … U can order papa johns pizza and they also have a menu to order from. They have a bar. U can drink and play pool at the same time. It is nice inside and the staff pretty much leave u alone

Andy’s downstairs is smoking. Bullfrog upstairs is nonsmoking. Nice atmosphere, generally a pretty professional, somewhat older crowd. The service can be kind of questionable at times, but just like any bar, if you’re friendly to the staff, they’ll remember you. Pretty expansive menu as far as bar food goes, but nothing too fancy. Just a comfortable place to sit and have a few drinks!

Great food. Wide selection of drinks. Plenty of pool tables. Nice area. Polite staff.

Bartender didn’t know what the beers on tap were called, just stated «they’re $ 6» every time I would ask. Lit a smoke to see how long it would take to get an ash tray (there was one about four feet away, unmanned, and ready to be filled with my cigs poop.) She walked passed me twice and looked in my direction, even cleaned out an ash tray in front of me and placed it next to the aforementioned tray. I got about halfway through my cigarette before I just grabbed one myself. Poor service, food sucks, beer is over priced, but the atmosphere is nice.

I am writing a review today of Andys Pub and Bullfrog bar. Bullfrog is the bar that is located upstairs from the Billiards section of Andys Pub that has been operating at 3866 Peach for a couple decades. Bullfrog bar was built on a couple years ago. While I was not here when it first opened, having been a regular customer since November of last year, I can say that for the past six months, it seems the younger crowd is upstairs. When I first came in I was served by a very nice, cheerful girl who gave me lots of great info about the new city I had just moved to.
After several weeks of great service from Mila, I always made sure to go in when she was working, that way I definitely got the best service. Some of the other bartenders are nice, but Mila always seemed to go above and beyond most and do a superior job. Even in times when the bar was very packed, Mila was able to provide personal service to each and every customer. I was quite shocked when I went in last weekend and found from one of the employees she is no longer there due to not having on the correct color of tank top. Of course, that is ridiculous. She is a hard worker and it is quite obvious that businesses such as Andy’s/Bullfrog Bar are more interested in the things outside their business instead of keeping and rewarding valued employees who develop their own customer base and signature drinks. To that end, I decided to call the owner that saw fit to fire Mila and called numerous times, only to be told there was not a member of management available. Finally, after about six tries, I talked to a gentleman named Paul. Gentleman might be quite a stretch, but it was Paul, nonetheless. I shortly and diplomatically explained my concern that the most professional, coutreous and hardworking bartender that had greeted me to Erie was no longer in Andy’s employ. Paul rudely cut me off and muttered something about not discussing employee issues and hung up. Did he ask any questions? No. Did he ask if I had a bad experience? No. He didnt even listen, just hung up. I am quite certain the future revenue on Mila’s regular nights will be exponentially lower now that she is no longer there. I can’t wait to find out where she will be bartending next so that I can get her signature drinks and outstanding customer service. A bartender who has her own customer base will be a great addition to some lucky Erie bar.

Pool, beer, and food. This is a great place to get together with some friends for a laid back night of all of the previously mentioned — and you can head upstairs to the Bullfrog afterwards for some more brews. Yes, it allows smoking, but there is a very nice outside balcony to chill on during the summer if it bothers you that much.

Chicken wings are great. Try the Cajun BBQ. I tried the chipotle (I think)…didn’t care for the cinnamon though I’m sure many do. Prefer the Cajun BBQ. Great service, great for watching the game.

Great location, Plenty of parking and tables to play on. Nonsmokers be warn. Its a heavily smoked bar. I mean I had to shower twice to remove the stench that I left with. I could just imagine my lungs. PA is so behind the clean air act its not even funny. They try to clean it up, BY NOT ALLOWING CIGARS. really what the heck. They have rules like don’t wear your hat backwards but smoke all you want and kill one another with second hand smoke. You are not allowed to wear another type of hat that’s not a cap (no skullies). I am surprise they can even notice that with all the smoke in the air. This location is a three business location. there is a upstairs called bull frogs and then the billiards and then the pub. Suggestion to the owner. make the upstairs a second hand smoke pub where you can enjoy killing your self.
make the billiards area a non smoking area and only allow smokers by the bar not near the tables. Add a heavy extractor to remove the smoke. Maybe then I will give you a five star.