Geraldi’s Restaurant

Hi kenny. I need you to contact me immediately regarding my visit on Labor Day weekend. I have left you several messages and even spoke with you. I thought we had resolved our issue.

The smell of this place brought us in. We had the pizza bread appetizer, which was pretty yummy. The pizza was decent, but also greasy. The crust was really thin in the middle and not cooked all the way. You can’t really pick up your slice to eat it. The staff was nice and the pizza did have good taste. There are only six tables so I could see it being a little wait if they were busy.

If you like flavorful NY style pizza go here! If you like Chicago style pizza go try the Thai food place. Lol.

My girlfriend and I really enjoyed our time in Eureka Springs. We stopped here because the pizza smelled delicious, although there are many different pizza options throughout town Geraldis seemed to be one of the more reasonably priced. We ordered the calzone. The only issue we had was it was a little under cooked and the dough was soft in places, other than that it was one of the best calzones that I personally have ever had. Geraldis sits in downtown eureka and when we went it was very quite, the staff was quite friendly and overall we enjoyed our time here in town and at Geraldis.

Very good Pizza Bread and the Chicago beef sandwich was excellent, too. Parmisagn Chicken was ok. I wish we’d had the pizza — it looked really good. The service was friendly and prompt. I would eat here again.

Short answer: The spaghetti and meatballs are as good as I’ve.EVER.Had.
Don’t know how they do it, but I’d put their pizza and pasta up against anyone’s anywhere.
The garlic bread is good enough to get crazy stupid over all by itself.
The place is small, the wait is fairly long, but the staff is wonderful, and the aroma while you’re waiting is just wonderful.
Definitely on my list of places to go back to next time we’re in Eureka Springs.

While window shopping down Main, a wonderful aroma of Pizza filled the atmosphere. About 3 shops up was Geraldi’s. Me and my boyfriend wandered up to the front door, next to it a window featuring their menu. Seeing their personal pan was only $ 6.99, (one topping, of course) we gladly agreed that this was our lunch spot.
Our wait after ordering was a good 15 – 20 minutes, which isn’t all bad. I got a cheese, he got a pepperoni with jalapeños. The smells were beyond glorious, much better than we smelled from the street. My cheese pizza was the perfect balance of greasy-​ness and cheesy-​ness. He said his jalapeños were weak, but he didn’t leave a single crumb, (neither did I ;))
Long story short, this place has excellent pizza. Not being from Eureka Springs, or Arkansas for that matter, we probably won’t make it down for a second visit to try something else on the menu. Disappointing that we won’t, but that pizza… Mmmhmm!

My wife, son, and I went into this pizza place just yesterday. I can honestly say it was the best pizza I’ve had in a long, long time. You won’t be disappointed.

Great food. Sweet tea was pretty good. Not a long wait. It wasn’t 80+ degrees as one review had stated.

The wait time was a bit long but the food was amazing. The meatballs are fantastic. As is the pizza. Will be coming back.

Depending on what style of pizza you prefer, this could be your new favorite. It was one of our favorite meals during our stay, and we were so disappointed when we’d planned to go back for lunch on Monday and it was closed. It’s the perfect thin, super cheesy, foldable pizza. I’m pretty sure they add some sort of seasoning to their sauce, or in the cheese, and it adds so much flavor. We tried Chelsea’s Pizzeria after numerous suggestions, but Geraldi’s had just set the bar too high. You can’t miss this place!

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. We got the special on a Saturday night and the price was $ 14 for a 16-​inch two topping. My whole family left very satisfied.

The pizza is as good as the smell as you walk by. Stop in and have a pie, you won’t be disappointed!

Good pizza exists in the MidWest, it only took me a year to find it. Good service too, and good music playing. Can’t really ask for more.

Memorial Day weekend, only 2 staff working. Normally food to die for, but was less than desirable today. Had to send some back and have taken off my bill.

Excellent food. I had a meatball sub, my wife had chicken parm, my boy had a side of spaghetti and garlic toast. I thought the sauce was a little sweet, but the bread was amazing.

Great food and great price. Went to Luigi’s up the street, paid and left. It was some of the worst food I have ever had
This place was a very pleasant surprise. Will go again.

Not bad. Nice people working here. Crust a little thin and pizza is juicy/​greasy.

Geraldis… where to begin…
As yes… the lines… expect to wait… there is very few seats here… but its worth every bit of the wait. It has to be one of the smallest… if not the smallest. Pizzeria’s I’ve ever been to.
Once you get in… the smell alone makes you want the pizza here.
I always start with the classic Pepperoni pizza to test out a place…
I saw while waiting one of the staff making mozzarella balls. So, they make their own cheese! mmmmmm…
Hand tossed crust… chewy and great flavor. Pepperoni has a nice spice.
Sauce was probably the best Ive had. Of course the cheese is good!
Doesn’t take too long to get your pizza here.
This is my favorite pizza place. I make a point to always come by here when we are in town.
I do find it hard to believe there is a better one out there. I know there is… but I haven’t had it yet. So come try the best pizza in Eureka Springs.

Good pizza and pasta. Ravioli was a little cool, though. Service could have been more on top of it. Overall good value.