SilverLake Romio’s Pizza

They may have closed Romios but that doesn’t mean you can’t get their food, this is Romios pizza, manga!

New to the area… this was a pizza place I wanted to try, not being a chain. I ordered a large pepperoni pizza and Caesar salad for delivery. After 45 minutes, the driver called and we discovered that he was at the wrong hotel. By the time he arrived, the pizza was cold and was nothing to rave about. Caesar salad was good. $ 31.00 total for salad and pizza. Way too overpriced for quality and taste.

Hefty pizza that will fill you up!

We love this place and eat here quite often. Excellent pizza with fresh, high quality ingredients. The pizza crust and sauce is really yummy and there are a lot of toppings and cheese on every slice. The Staff is very friendly.

Romio’s was one of my favorites and I was so bummed to see it go. was so excited when I found out they were opening back up under another name! my favorite has always been baked spaghetti and cheese bread. enough calories for the entire week but totally worth blowing your diet for. I’ve had baked spaghetti elsewhere and no others ever come close. also love the 4 cheese pizza, add garlic and black olives!

I have nothing but great things to say about this pizza place. I’m not gonna lie, I’ve been looking for good, greasy, East Coast style pizza here in Washington for about 6 months. This place was my diamond in the rough!
I was a bit skeptical due to the negative reviews and the fact that it’s connected to a gas station, but I took a chance on a rainy Saturday night and I’m glad I did.
Upon entering, my party received the best hospitality I’ve had in a restaurant since moving here. The restaurant was full besides a squished bar area at the back of the restaurant. We said we wanted to dine in if there were tables available when our pizza was ready but we’d take it boxed just in case there were no seats. Our waitress cleaned off the back area we were waiting in and brought us all water.
A table left and she sat us there as soon as the party left. It was a warm, welcoming experience and the staff was all attentive.
The pizza itself was hearty, with an abundance of cheese. You can tell the workers really care about the quality of the food and the dining experience here. I’d absolutely recommend this pizza restaurant!

Terrible experience there, first place to start, the lady brought us a cup of us however she was holding it so her fingers were touching the rim. Second the guy who was making the pizza was not wearing gloves when touching the food, when he came back from a delivery, he went right in to making more pizzas without washing his hands. Girlfriend and I both have food poisoning from here, definitely will not be coming back.

**Update**
I have read a few good reviews so I wanted to try the food again. I got a regular pepperoni pizza with a caesar salad; can’t really mess that up and I live less than 5 minutes away so instead of delivery I went in. First, the girl who got my order on the phone was rude. I asked if the salad could be dressed after the pizza was made so that the lettuce remained crisp and fresh. She told me that I would get it the way the guys in back make it. This was after I had paid and I heard her ring my card so, while I should have cancelled, I went with the order. I went down there to get the phone, arrived 5 minutes before it was supposed to be ready. I was stoked! Fresh hot pizza and crisp salad right?! Wrong. They must have given me a pizza someone ordered hours prior that was left under the warmer. It was rubber and soggy all in one box. The salad was also warm and looked absolutely disgusting. I pointed it out to the staff and they just looked at it like possums staring into a headlight. No one offered to remake either item and instead just stood there. I was not taking this garbage home so I demanded my money back and left that crap there. They must get this a lot because the girl refunded my money faster than she originally took it. This place is a waste when there are so many good pizza places nearby.

The food I ordered for delivery was pretty much inedible. Especially the pizza. I ordered from here once and that will be all.

My family and I have been eating here since it was Romio’s Pizza and since they switched over to Silverlake pizza, the quality of the food had declined for a little bit but I was craving their house special pizza and I ordered it and their food is back where it used to be, very yummy and delicious. The downfall is, it’s very expensive! You can order three things and that can easily become $ 50. But it’s better than fast food pizza like Pizza Hut. And their pizzas are NEVER greasy which is a huge plus.
If you’re looking for high quality pizza, I would check this little shop out. Just a head’s up, you can’t eat in the store, you can only take out or have it delivered.

Pretty expensive pizza but it’s reliable if you’re feeling lazy. I don’t have any real complaints nor praise for it, its pizza and you know what you’re getting when you order from them.
My friends tend to complain about it, especially if we don’t use coupons to make it more reasonable, so I’m leaving a mediocre review. Give them a try and see if you like them.

We order from here when we’re too lazy to cook and when we’re too lazy to pick up food. We usually get Penne Pesto Alfredo w/​Chicken and a medium Neema or Romio’s Special Pizza. Their salad and soup of the day is nothing to be thrilled about. The Penne Pesto Alfredo is very good if you like your pasta with a lot of sauce. The toasted bread that comes with it is also good. Their Neema & Romio’s Special Pizza is delicious! It comes with a lot of cheese and the traditional crust is perfect. The delivery man is always polite and on time. We’ll continue to order from the place as long as their service & food is this good.

Delivery time was good. Pizza was not. Crust was stale, hard, and dry. There seemed to be no pizza sauce on it at all, it was overcooked, and was getting cold when it arrived. I love pizza and I don’t like writing bad reviews, but wow. Tasteless cardboard. Inedible. We threw it out and ate peanut butter sandwiches.

Great pizza. I prefer a NY style crust, but their crust was really good. Crisp on the bottom and browned perfectly but also nice and soft on the inside and not too thick. Really good sauce and a good amount of toppings and cheese. I would give it 4.5 stars if I could.

We ordered delivery. I got a CalZone and bf got the Penne Pesto Fettuccini with chicken a salad and extra garlic bread with marinara sauce.
The delivery got here in an hour, which was exactly when the online ordering thing said I would receive my order. The food was hot and smelled good when it arrived.
This was my first CalZone and will be my last. It was a hot greasy mess. The best part was the crust that wasn’t covered in toppings and the terrible ppizza sauce.
The marinara sauce was terrible! I had to spit it out it was so gross. The Penne was gross… it had way too much pesto in it. At least the chicken was OK.
The ranch dressing for the salad was flavor-​less and far from impressive.
The whole dinner was less than satisfying and way over priced for what you get. I don’t plan on ordering from here again. Which is disappointing because of all the good reviews on here. Hopefully they’re not «paid off» reviews by the shop owner calling and guilt tripping consumers for posting bad reviews.

Anyone who lives in the silver lake area knows how good this food is! In the old days it was Romios now thanks to Geri it’s silver lake pizza. Everything on the menu is great. From the pizza to the pasta. Portions are large and the they have inside dining or delivery. I love the pastas pizza awesome too. For Italian food this is the place. If you are new to the area or a out of towner this is the place to eat

Not impressed, pizza was cold by the time it finally showed up. New girl answered the phone and got our address wrong. Quality was less than satisfactory. Will not be ordering from them again in the future. Gave them a 2 star since my order was correct.

We love this place! It is always our go-​to place when we want really good Italian or pizza take out.
The delivery is always fast and our food gets to us while it is still hot.
I was even going to use them to cater my wedding except now the wedding location is too far away and it’s just not feasible anymore.
But come Sunday night when neither of us wants to cook or get off the couch, we will give them a call.

Their wonderful owner, Geri, has very graciously agreed to donate several pizzas a month for the tenants of Everett Transitional Housing Services. We are a non-​profit organization dedicated to providing clean and sober living/​assistance to those in need. We are so thankful for Silver Lake Pizza and Pasta’s consideration, absolutely amazing food, and extremely generous donation! What an incredible company!!!

3−21−14. The location is new but the big menu is full of many specialities both American and Greek in origin. The place is clean and bright with Lindsey at the helm. Pleasant and informative.