Marcys Automotive

Been here off and on every couple of years for minor work. Have no complaints about the quality of the work done, but every time I leave, I always feel like I’ve paid way more $ than I should. I could not give them a strong recommendation unless you couldn’t make it to another shop in the evergreen area. Call it a wash… 2.5 stars…

This is the worst shop I have ever had the misfortune of taking a car to. Not only are they completely incompetent, but they will lie to your face. They caused more damage to my car than it had when I brought it in. I have photographs of the car on their lift showing where they needlessly disconnected all of my brake lines. Bent the lines, cut a pulley in half and caused other damage to my car. When I picked the car up to take it to a different shop, to have it repaired correctly. I saw that they had not hooked some of the lines back up. (Again I have photos of it in their lot) When I told them about it they said «we didn’t disconnect any brake lines» These people are the most dishonest people I have ever had to work with. RUN, DON’T WALK FORM THIS PLACE! If I would have driven the car to the other shop, I would have been in a major accident. They don’t care if you or anyone else gets killed by their negligence.

I’m not from the area but had an experience with this garage a few weeks ago on my travels from the east coast to the west coast. While in CO I noticed my vehicle was over heating and took it here first place I stumbled across. Thy were kind enough to take my car in same day for diagnostics and determined I needed a head gasket at the cost of $ 1800 and a few days minimum to fix. They basically told me my 2005 was not worth fixing and they could sell me another car cheap. I decided to take the vehicle to a dealer for a second opinion against my judgement of going there but I needed to know for sure. I’m glad I did in the end what I was told was a $ 1800 head gasket by This garage ended up being a less then $ 300 and only one day fix of a thermostat housing and thermostat. I don’t like to bash anyone or leave a negative review either bit just can only offer 2 stars here after a nearly $ 2 k false repair diagnosis.

The folks at Marcy’s are pretty nice, but they fail to deliver, especially when it comes to vital fluids. I went for an oil-​change special a couple of years ago and later that week my oil pressure light came on. The vehicle was nearly 2 quarts low! That was no special deal.
Going years back, They rebuilt the engine on my Volkswagen Bug. I took a test drive and yes, my oil sender light was going crazy. I coasted downhill as much as possible and bought a few quarts and it was just enough to get me back to the shop. The oil screen was not tightened properly and I was blowing oil all over the road. Marcy’s corrected it, but you’d thing a little test drive would be in order after a re-​build. Service seems to have gaps and when it comes to oil, it really not negotiable. If it runs out, the engine is gone. I was glad the rebuilt engine was not ruined and I’m glad my young self had the presence of mind to coast it down the pass to save that engine.

Went in based on the positive reviews and was blown away by the great service! Outstanding experience from a great mechanic whom I instantly trusted. It was even cheaper than i expected! What’s not to love here? A++

First timer and went based upon reco’s on Unilocal!Was very pleased with how friendly and personable the staff was and that they really cared about the business. Brian provided an upfront quote for the installation of a reciever hitch for a sports plow and advised how long it would take to get it done. Reasonable and accomodating as I could not get up from Denver before they closed… took my CC over the phone for the payment and locked the truck up so I could pick it up after hours. Great team at this location demonstrating Christian values of Honesty!
Will be back…

I cannot say enough about the great, friendly, accommodating service I’ve experienced here. As a single woman, I’m pretty clueless about things automotive until they’ve reached the critical stage. Several months ago they rescued me when my transmission was showing all the signs of imminent failure. I was frantic. They took me in immediately, made the diagnosis and found that a bracket that was recently installed had failed. Today they rescued me again when I checked my oil to find there was none. I live about ¼ mile away and went right to Marcys because I didn’t know if my car would make it any farther. Again they rescued me. Two quarts of oil, and they sent me on my way. Love these guys.

I was driving across country from WI to AZ. Around Bailey CO while descending the rockies my car started to shake and felt as if my brakes were shot. I had no idea what to do– 3 girls on a roadtrip with little car experience– went right to typical auto mechanic is going to run right over us and charge us for lots of things– but Marcys did the exact opposite. He was caring, pushed us ahead of the cars there to get it fixed as soon as possible. Gave us a AAA discount and allowed us to use his wireless while we waited. Quick, professional, friendly and caring. Come to find out the last mechanic put the wrong size breaks on my car! Marcy’s gave the faulty brakes back packed them up for even! Marcy’s saved the road trip for sure! I would recommend them to anyone in the area!

Marcey’s had the transmission rebuilt on our ’76 Scout II that we use as a plow truck. Turn around was about a week, and their pricing was fair. Ed and his staff were a pleasure to deal with. I will use them again in the future.

Our beloved 4Runner failed emissions! The testing center gave us a booklet listing all qualified emissions repair specialists. In Colorado your mechanic must sign off on the repair and they keep track of their success rate. Marcy’s has a perfect record! Anyway, I was expecting to pay $ 500 – 700 for a new catalytic converter but i ended up paying $ 320 out the door. :-) Very friendly staff. Ed was very nice to us and explained everything clearly. Within 2 hours we were out the door and off to the testing center. Our 4Runner passed with flying colors. Very Happy with the garage. Highly recommend it.