Jonny’s Pizza and Pasta

I love this place so much. When I first went, I got the chicken tortellini. It was seriously this gigantic bowl full of food and awesomeness. I couldn’t even finish it. The deep dish pizza is to die for and I do mean to die for. I would die for that pizza. It’s literally that good. I don’t even eat red sauce but that’s the one exception that I’ve always made. It has a sweetness to it and not overly tomato-​y. So, I love it. It’s delicious. All of their food is good, it’s fresh, and they’re not expensive. The outside kind of makes it look like a hole in the wall, but that’s part of its charm. If I want good quality Italian-​American cuisine, I come here. And if you’re reading this and are debating to try it or not, so should you. Give it a try. Don’t mind the negative reviews on here because I personally have been coming here for years and not once have I ever had an issue.

Ordered the thin crust pizza. It is our first time eating from there. The pizza sauce was smokey kind of toward bbq. Crust was chewy instead of crispy. Also pizza was almost cold when delivered and we do not live that far from the place. Being from Chicago I am still on the hunt for a decent pizza. Had hoped I had found it but was disappointed once again.

Brittany was our server today and she was attentive, the pizza was mediocre and the mozzarella stuffed breadsticks were pretty good. The sauce is sweet as other reviewers stated so if you like that then this may be the place for you, I just prefer more savory.

Very good Chicago style pizza. Great, fast service. Their family deal was a ton of food for only $ 24.99. Our family of six couldn’t even finish it all! Fabulous pizza place!

Pretty good chicago style pizza, quick delivery. Was skeptical at first but was blown away by the robust flavor of their sauce. Dont let the size fool you, youll be full of tastiness soon enough
They offer delivery which makes it even better so you can a taste of chicago in your own home.

Absolutely horrible! Only reason I’m giving this a star is because the garlic bread was half decent. Chicken and philly subs were by far the worst I’ve ever had and don’t get me started on their sauce for the pasta. Will not be going here again.
To top it, my poor daughter was running to the bathroom all night. This is my first time leaving a review on Unilocal.I felt compelled to leave one to spare others their time, money and digestive systems

I love this place! Their delivery is always quick and their food is always hot and fresh.

Can’t get past the way to sweet red sauce! They put it on almost everything too. Other than that the service and food were good. Recommend trying taco pizza and salad. Wish they offered a different sauce because the lasagna and pastas were good just far too sweet!

Excellent!!! I have been ordering pizza to go from jonnys for 3 – 4 years. I have a specialty pizza that I order with different toppings not a standard order and they have NEVER messed it up. I love that they listen and take the time to make sure it is right. The food is delicious, and the people are friendly and professional. I encourage trying them out you will not regret it!

Love when our boss gets us this for lunch! So good and doesn’t feel as rushed and thrown together like those chain pizza places.

I’ve been here a hand full of times, and it’s always good. Decent Chicago — style pizza for Southern Illinois, but IMHO the sauce is too sweet for a regular crust pizza. We’ve had several different appetizers and salads and all were good, but the deep dish pizza keeps us going back, at least until we can get to Chicago again.

We frequent Jonny’s on a regular basis for lunch and dinner. They have a family special that is unmatched and lunch specials are great too. Yes they have a sweeter sauce, but some people like that. I love the sweetness. Quality is consistent and I never have to worry about wasting my hard earned money on a subpar meal. They have one of best pizzas around and plenty of options for those of us who love to try different sauces on the pie. The wings are awesome and their Alfredo rivals any high end joint I have ever eaten at. On eve you try Jonny’s you will be a regular.

The first time we ate at Johnny’s we weren’t terribly impressed, especially considering there is a Pasta House next door. The pasta sauce was a bit sweet for our tastes and the pizza was to bready. However, we found ourselves returning time after time for their pasta specials given their prices. The bottom line is that for not being terribly impressed, we actually now prefer it over Pasta House! Now if they can only improve their way too generic salads…

I’ve had Johnny’s pizza on several occastions and the food is consistent and good. Never had a bad meal and the service is very good. The sauce on the pizza is what makes it so good.

I love sweet and they have a nice sweet sauce that really gets me excited when someone wants to go to Johnnys and invites this guy!!!
I like the crust, I like the sauce, I like the fresh toppings, I like the atmosphere, I like the service, they are very friendly, down to earth, helpful, quick, all this would pretty much have to put Johnnys on top of my list for pizza in Fairview Heights area.
the bread sticks with pizza sauce and nacho cheese sauce mix, oh how did i almost forget about you! I get them every time and I love them every bite!
If your looking for good pizza hit up Johnnys, you wont be disappointed… if you are, bring me those leftovers!!!

This place is awesome great pizza and you have to try the hot ham and cheese it is amazing! Ordered a Philly Chicken sandwich the other day it was absolutely great!

The pizza here is delicious but the service is absolutely terrible. We sat down and were not waited on or offered drinks for about 15 minutes. I thought it was just a busy night so we tried again and decided we would do carry out. We were on hold for over 10 minutes. This place seems short staffed and needs to hire another waitress if they want to have repeat customers. Again, the pizza was great but because of the service, I will take my business elsewhere.

It’s great to have a true Chicago-​style deep dish pizza offering in the Metro East. The deep dish is here is very similar to Giordano’s of the Chicago area, a sweet sauce and a dense crust. I would like the crust to be a bit crisper, but no big complaints here.
Meat sauce is also excellent.
If you’re looking for a Lou Malnati’s style, Pi Pizzeria in St. Louis offers a similar style. Stick to Jonny’s, though.

I’ve had pasta and pizza here and have thoroughly enjoyed it every time. The pizza is yummy and the sauce is pleasantly different than most. It’s delicious!
If I’m ever in the mood for a pizza that doesn’t taste like every other bland pie in town I call Jonnys!

4.5 Stars! Best Chicago style pizza in area!!! Wish the dining area was a bit larger. It gets packed on the weekends. But if u want delish pizza, this is the place… love it!