Cheeburger Cheeburger

I hadn’t had Cheeburger Cheeburger in years so I was very happy to find one not too far from work. A bunch of us ordered lunch from there and aside from 2 missing drinks (Samantha was very nice and will upgrade the drinks on the next order) and a glitch on the ordering site that allows you to upgrade your fries to sweet potato for $ 1 more but didn’t register it (nor were we charged though so no harm no foul) it was a delightful experience. Our food tasted great and I can’t wait to order from them again!

I had the pleasure of eating at Cheeburger, Cheeburger the other day, and I was treated to a wonderful restaurant, which was a throwback to a time when you went to your local neighborhood eatery, and had a good old fashioned meal! The place looked like a restaurant right out of the fifties, and they were playing oldies but goodies as well. The food was delicious, hot and nicely served as well. The staff was friendly, and attentive to all our requests.
If you are in the Farmingdale area, check this place out, you will not be sorry!
Jan

Long time customer but first review. I d loved their combinations if milkshakes. Ive even done the challenge. Gets 5 stars for variations and taste of burger

I took my family here for lunch and we loved the place the moment we walked in. There was a friendly atmosphere and we were seated immediately. There were so many delicious choices and we ended the dinner with an awesome shake. The burgers were fresh and the fries were soooo tasty.
I highly recommend Cheeburger Cheeburger!!!

Oh dearie dearie me. First the positives. The staff where lovely and friendly. Simple take away burger was my order and it tasted so bad I took one bite and it went into the bin. Bland and under seasoned. The fries were cold and oily. I just cannot deal with this quality here which has plummeted in the last few years

Came is for my dad, got him a BLT which was a huge sandwich and loaded with bacon and my son got a cheeseburger which he ate in 2.5 seconds sooo… I had fries which were decent. Not much of a selection for non meat eaters but can’t be surprised it is called «cheeseburger cheeseburger» lol

The only reason I went was because I had a Groupon. The food was terrible. There was absolutely no seasoning whatsoever. On top of it all, I went in and the guy who appeared to be the host or waiter completely ignored me. He even took the order of a guy who came in AFTER me, first, even though he saw me standing there waiting for him. I should have just walked out. It would’ve saved from bad service and horrible food. Never again, no matter what deal I have.

We used a groupon for our visit and since I was in the mood for a burger we decided to try the place out… we have gone to other cheeburger’s so we knew what we were getting. If you want a variety of topping this is your place. They have tons of milkshakes which is always a plus. They offer high chairs for kids and a kids menu.

Let’s begin with the service was great. Our waitress was friendly and very helpful. We were seated right away. The atmosphere is cute and colorful. Reminds me of Johnny Rockets in a way… However, the food was not good at all. It was edible. The burger was unseasoned and dry (I asked for some sauces as toppings and it was still dry!) The fries were brown as if they had been cooked in old oil. It was not good. I did not try the milk shakes but honesty I don’t think I would ever come back here. This was the first and last time… McDonald’s is probably a better choice.

If you’re looking for a quick bite, this place will do. But if you’re looking for a quick bite and a decent burger, maybe consider Smashburger…
I wasn’t blown away by the burger and our fries looked like they were the end of the basket and was all burnt. Our onion rings were alright. The only thing that I loved was the milkshake. If you’re in the mood for a shake, definitely come here, but if you’re looking for decent food, you might want to go somewhere else.
Aside from the food, our service was outstanding. I’ve actually never received such service at a smaller, «fast food» restaurant like this. If only the food was just as good…

They forgot my sauces, the burger was not cooked well, and it was underwhelming food in general.
The location in Forest Hills is much better by my recollection. Also I had diarrhea the next day, not good.

Cheeseburger Cheeseburger was a pleasant surprised but somewhat annoying since I couldn’t order my c’burger medium-​rare. I had the basic burger and stacked it with a whole bunch of stuff. The fries were good to. Staff was friendly. The entire experience was reminiscent of a ‘50s era type drive-​up. Will definetly be back soon…

Although, I expected a bit more of the place, and hated the pink walls, and the service wasn’t… «the most normal?»
I liked the place simply because it’s better than fast food; and when you want a burger, you can create your own, which I love. Good seasoning on the table and shakes aren’t bad either.

I was hopeful ! Got seated right away. The place has weird lighting and dingy decorations. Our waitress was very nice and patient while we tried to decipher the menu.
Fried mac and cheese were the frozen ones from restaurant depot. Fried pickles weren’t coated that well and the artichokes were eh. Everything was soooo greasy! They most not have their fryer hot enough.
The burger itself was cooked well! Nice and pink in the center. However it had absolutely no flavor and was surprisingly dry. Pepperjack cheese, no flavor. Didn’t even taste like cheese was on it. Kaiser roll was dry and bready. (Overwhelmed the burger) I probably ate about half the burger maybe less before calling it quits because it just wasn’t worth eating. Even a shake of salt didn’t help it.
All of our orders came out correct, our waitress checked up on us and even a supervisor/​manager checked on us. So they have good service going for them, but quality of food not so much. You can get a much tastier burger at smashburger and five guys for much less $$$. (Heck Wendy’s is better) sorry cheeburger cheeburger :(. You have cute cups though !

I like coming here. The burgers and rings are always very good. The staff is very friendly and it’s kept clean. My son loves coming here and getting his little car full of food.

Pretty tasty burgers. If you have a huge appetite then this is the place to go. They have different ounces to satisfy any craving.
There’s a monster burger that will get your photo on the wall. The place is decked out old school.
A ton of different shake flavors made old school and taste great. The burgers you can tell by shape and taste are fresh meat. And the topping range anywhere from bacon to peanut butter. Def get creative w your burger. They are all served on kaiser rolls which are hot or miss. Sometimes the rolls a little hard. Sometimes there’s too much bread but most of the time they’re pretty on point.
There are other options and salads. Upon entering the fresh roast beef Sammy really looked great but at 2 pm they were out of it which was a real bummer.
The kids meals have a good selection. This bases whether I try a place on how they’re kids meal is.
The service was great we were well taken care of.
I fed recommend everyone try this place.

Was here yesterday with a Groupon after shopping in the area.
Pros:Fabulous, sweet, attentive waitress. Burgers cooked the way we asked.
Horseradish dipping sauce.
Pickles.
Manager/​owner? came around asking if people were happy.
Cons: bun way too big for classic burger.
French fries soggy.
Ladies room was a mess.

I have to echo the sentiment of previous reviews and say that this place is just meh. The décor is ultra cheesy. The burgers are disappointing and way overcooked. The fries are just horrendous and bland, and for me to not eat fries is a big deal. I actually enjoyed the onion rings, they were perfectly crispy and flavorful. The only redeeming thing about this burger joint is the milkshakes. Since you can customize your flavors, the ones I’ve tried were fantastic! It’s a great place to start your kids on the road to obesity. There are just so many other burger places on Long Island that Cheeburger Cheeburger is just quite forgettable.

I have not been here for a while, and this trip confirmed my earlier impressions. The burger is good, but it still doesn’t rise to the great burgers on Long Island such as Smashburger. I had mine with a jack/​cheddar cheese mix, banana peppers, onion rings and lettuce. The endless toppings are nice too.
The fries are a problem. They are hand cut with skins on the end, but they are just too greasy and mushy, and not crispy and dry.
One place where Cheeburger Cheeburger excels is the variety and flavor of their milkshakes. I had Chocolate Marshmallow which was really very good. But $ 43 for two burgers, one fry and two shakes just seems like a lot for food that doesn’t rise to the price.

This place is great as long as you appreciate it for what it is– don’t expect a gourmet angus burger. It is pretty sophisticated for its genre though. As a kitchy 50’s themed burger joint, you wouldn’t expect so many burger choices such as salmon, veggie, portabello, or apps such as fried artichoke hearts. The meats are organic and they even offer gluten free buns. The fries are as good as the milk shakes, which you can create your own combination from a ton of flavors. It’s not about the atmosphere, unless maybe for children, but its a good place for a quick bite and a beer, so take a seat and go build your burger.