Seafood City

This is one of our top seafood shacks!
We stopped in for the 5^th time last night, en route south. It was our 5^th visit in a year: on our first visit to Killens Pond camp grounds, we went twice, then twice again during our last visit – yes, it’s that good.
It’s a local hang out with a bar separated by a wooden divider. Mostly pick up trucks in the lot. 2 rooms for diners. Apparently there’s a buffet/​all you can eat option.
The main room has large tables w/​towel rolls. After you order, a giant sheet of butcher paper is brought over w/​wooden mallets, knives, & buckets. It’s the first place my kids had whole crabs, & they (and we) think their giant (6″ body) blue crabs are fantastic.
Service is sweet – we’ve had at least 3 of their servers. Crayons are brought for the kids, lots of smiles. Bathrooms clean, but no changing table.
Biggest clam strips we’ve ever had & giant, tender, sweet, juicy, fresh scallops. The crab cake was a little weird – was it the thyme or did they add cheese? I liked it anyway. The cornbread had apple pie spice. The shrimp – wow. Butterflied & I ate my share instead of handing it over to the family. The hush puppies are round – I prefer the tubular ones from that place in VA, but my kids liked them with the real butter provided. Onion rings are home made, crispy, ½″ thick – which to me is perfect. Their cocktail sauce isn’t too sweet. You can get butter, old bay, tartar sauce, cocktail sauce on the side.
The seafood platter is $ 24.95 (fish, crab cake, 5 scallops, 5 – 6 shrimp, onion rings, hush puppies), $ 8.95 for the clam strips, $ 4/​blue crab.
Great place, open 7 days/​week. If we time things well, we will be back Sunday night for dinner.
Edit:
I just remembered that we pigged out on oysters during our first dinner (in addition to the fry fry & crabs), then timed our departure to have a very early lunch before the drive home.

My family and I eat here a lot. No matter if you order the seafood or just a basket of chicken and fries it’s always delicious.

My family drove from NYC to DE for some great seafood. Man, this place did not disappoint!
It wasn’t that busy so we were told to seat ourselves. Waitress came to the table fairly quickly with menus and took our drink orders, set up the table with paper for the crabs and took our food order.
Food came out at a good time, and it was delicious! I absolutely loved the shrimp, I could eat those for days! The crab was amazing (drooling now as I write this review). We also ordered hush puppies, wings, jalapeño poppers, calamari and some other stuff.
All seafood was fresh and delicious!
Please come here when you have the chance! It’s great and you wont regret it!

After driving four and a half hours from New York, I’m happy to report it was worth it. We have come to Delaware for crabs before, but we usually get the steamed crabs and take them home.
The crabs were fresh and delicious and reasonably priced. Service was attentive and friendly. I will gladly go back and recommend it to my friends.

What a great find! They had all you can eat crab legs and it was amazing! The service was unbeatable and you can’t beat the price for the quality of the crabs. The snow crab legs came out perfectly — no water from the steamer and an amazingly sweet consistency. The blue crab was equally good and seasoned just so.
The crab balls were awesome too!

Great local spot! Whenever i visit Rehoboth from NY… I make it a must to have the all you can eat crabs. Crabs are meaty and well seasoned. They never rush you and the server knew exactly when to replenish the crabs… Whenever i travel, i try to stay away from the tourist restaurants… This place is my favorite for Crabs. Enjoy!

Loved this place! Fantastic fried oysters and clam strips. My husband didn’t care for his chowder but that was a personal preference on his part. It’s all about the oysters for me, and I have no complaints about the wasters here. Absolutely delicious!

Just went there and we left… they had a line of people waiting to be seating and they would not open the second dining room. we were told we would have the next table and after waiting 15 mins they seated people behind us. lost our business..

This was the worst seafood restaurant I’ve ever been to. Friendly service, great atmosphere, but all the food tasted like it came from a box, can or frozen aisle.

We ordered the $ 24 half dozen medium steamed crabs. They seemed alright at the time but one of them was slightly mushier than the rest. Less than four hours later, i started getting stomach cramps. Paying them no heed, i got into the car and started on the 40 minute drive back to my hotel from the beach. We were on the highway when i got excruciating stomach pains. Turns out, i had a bad case of diarrhea. After doing some research on the restaurant online, found out that the crabs werent necessarily fresh. $ 24 for 6 crabs in exchange for diarrhea? No thanks. Never going back again.

This place was a bit out of the way but well worth our trip. Crabs were great and the bucket of clams was outstanding.

I have only had the crabs, shrimp and hot crab dip. These choices are always so good I never think to order anything else! I highly recommend!

Had the all you can eat crab. All I have to say is OMG. Amazingly delicate and absolutely yummy. We made a huge mess at the table and loved every minute of it. Will definitely come back when in the area. Oh and the service is fast and friendly.

My first time there in January and they had full body crabs they were small but meaty and seasoned good. Everything I ordered was hot, delicious and fresh it was so good I am going back with more people and I live by the Philadelphia Airport. I was in the neighborhood at tractor supply and I Google seafood restaurants and Seafood City was one the ones that came up I am glad I tried it and my waitress Jen was great and very clean place.

Steamed shrimp, crabs, cold beer! Yum! Dine in or take out. Glad they’re not far from my home!

We wanted to have some crabs for lunch on our way home from VA beach. Service was quick and very nice, restaurant clean and a good menu. Crab soup was okay, soft shells too, but the crab cakes were fantastic. If we’d had more time, I’d have had the steamed crab instead — they looked very good and fresh! Yum!

Loved this place, was in Milford for Firefly Festival and looking to try Crabs for the first time, staff was friendly, being foreign i did get a few stares from the other patrons but nothing bad, prices were affordable and beer was very cheap! had 1lb Dungeness Crab Legs and it was delicious, girlfriend had Crab Balls and fries she said they rocked too, overall very happy with my visit would come again if it wasn’t that I will be moving west soon, but maybe will be back for the next Firefly Festival !

Yay, blue crabs are back. NOW I love them again. Seriously, get AYCE crabs, and don’t ever bother getting anything else off the menu other than the hush puppies.

This is the best place to sit down and have all-​u-​can eat blue crabs. I could drive down to the beach and get crabs half as good as these. I just wish draft beer choices had something other than lite and mass produced domestics.

IF you happen to ever be in this neck of the woods… they’ve got the biggest, most freshest, and tastiest Blue Crabs I’ve ever had! After volunteering to participate in a company merger, a couple of colleagues and I decided we need to try these east coast favorites. We certainly were not let down. I’ve never had blue crabs the size of Dungeness crabs until this day and boy do I crave them. Too bad its allllll the way out there or else I’d be over at least once a week!