Heady Hollow Brewing Company

I really liked this small brewery. It was adorably decorated and was quite quaint.
We normally don’t venture up north this far, and I was slightly surprised to see this in a strip mall. Walking in, you’d never imagine it looking the way it does from the outside.
The walls were covered in rustic barn wood as were the tables and there were metal stools to seal the aesthetic. There is seating for around 30−40ish and it was pretty quiet for a Friday night. This was appreciated as I prefer conversation over a beer rather than yelling over music. Although I’m not a sports fan, they did have one large tv at the bar with the Pacers game playing.
We started with a flight, all of which were really good. I decided on a Scotch Ale (which is completely out of the norm for me) as my pint of choice. Accompanying my pint was a Turkey Rueben. It was really very good, and not at all greasy or messy like Ruebens typically are. They also serve a side of Broad Ripple Chips which are super delish.
The service was great and the bar tender was attentive and very nice.
I really enjoyed this small brewery and will certainly return.

My husband and I are huge fans of this new brewery. It’s got a great atmosphere and is good for groups big and small. They did a fantastic job utilizing the space. They have a good starting collection of beers with other great local options on tap. Their menu is simple and at first you think it’s too small but their sandwiches will surprise you. Delicious options and reasonably priced. We love this place for lunch but late night drinks and apps would be fantastic here too! You have to try their homemade spinach and onion dip for the chips! All and all we love this new addition to Fishers. Come support a new local brewery! They are starting small but doing things right!

So excited to have a new brewery in walking distance from my house. I could sit and eat those chips all day, so good!

They are doing it right. Four of their own beers; the wheat was my favorite. Love, love, love the décor! Clean and invting. Bartender was knowledgeable and friendly without being invasive. Definitely worth a stop, and we will return!

Great beer. I had the 1802 pale and Hoosier Hops’pitality IPA. Both were very clean and tasted the way they were described on the menu. No food on this visit, as we had just been to the festival at St. George’s. Can’t wait to come back and try either the One Hot Turkey panini or the pulled pork sandwich. The cheese and charcuterie options look tasty also.

Atmosphere, excellent craft brews, menu supporting local vendors along with friendly service make an outstanding experience at Heady Hollow! Inside enjoy some Fishers history with old photographs and a beautiful bar top. Comfortable outside seating is available too. Looking forward to my next visit for their spicy bacon cheddar carmel popcorn mix along with the Scotch Ale brew!

60 Horses was hands down my favorite followed by 1802 Pale Ale in a close second. The staff is fantastic too!

Nice little break tonight, popped in for some great brews. I had the scotch ale and wasn’t disappointed :-) we also ordered the meat and cheese plate. Pleasantly surprised with the fantastic local meats. Our waitress was outstanding. Everything tonight was on point for a local brewery and I will most defiantly be returning.

New Brewpub is Fishers’ first hometown ale house pouring 4 in-​house beers. Scotch ale is very tasty and representative of the style. Others enjoyed the ‘90’ and the Pale ale. Each ordered a 2^nd (or a 3^rd). The Hot Turkey panini is just spicy enough and quite satisfying. The Cheese panini was not ‘special’. Sides of chips were okay. One couple ordered the cheese and meat board. Smoking goose meats were a great choice and 4 y/​o cheddar a hit. Modern open ceiling (exposed metal rafters), while trendy, makes it a bit noisy. Only 8 days old and soliciting suggestions/​feedback. I’ll be back — early and often. Welcome HH to ‘West’ Fishers.

My wife and I had a wonderful time at this new establishment. We sampled the flight of beers that are offered and thoroughly enjoyed all four brews. The meat and cheese appetizer was a nice complement. The pulled pork and turkey reuben sandwiches with homemade potato chips were quite tasty. The staff is truly friendly and with a nice local touch with the décor, Heady Hollow Brewing Company is a pleasant addition to the area.

Awesome place, great beers. Good to have a local based craft beer brewery in Fishers. I’ll be back… frequently!

Not only is the beer fantastic, but the food was superb. Very classy inside with a friendly staff. I Will definitely be back !