Sal’s Pizzeria II

I love this place. The food is always good, the staff is friendly. I usually just get take out, but I’ve never had a bad experience. Try the calzone!

This is a place we often order pies from at work. Their extra-​large pie is enough to feed a small army by itself, and a single slice (which is the size of a catcher’s mitt) is plenty filling. Delivery times vary, which is no different than any other pizza parlor in the area. All in all, they’re a good place to eat from.

Just beware. Look at the your bill then look at the menu prices. So we went to Sal’s with a group to have pizza and some appetizers. I had my reservations about this place since we had a bad experience once before. We ordered off their menu that was on the counter. When we got the bill, all the prices were wrong, they were higher. I asked the person that waited on us why the prices were different. She said that the menu was from their Beacon store and that they ran out of menus for the Fishkill location. The difference in pricing didn’t seem to bother her. Nope, no concern, no «let me get my manager», no bother in trying to adjust the bill, nothing. Her demeanor was as if this is something they knowingly do all the time. I told her that if the prices on the menu was different then they have an obligation to inform their customers, hinting that this was deceptive business practices. What was her response? She raised her voice and rudely told me «There was about 30 people (the group we came with) in here all at once, I guess it must have slipped my mind!» and just walked away. Well since we were with a group, I didn’t want to pursue this issue and ruin a good evening out with friends. However the difference in price added almost 15% to the bill. Will I go back? No way! We tried this place once before and they overcharged back then when we ordered a simple pizza with toppings. Although they stated a price, when the bill came it was higher. (Do we see a trend here?) Hey I know business is tough, especially the restaurant business. Who needs to have the NYS Attorney General’s office contacting you about deceptive pricing? Oh how was the food? How about buffalo wings that was so hard because they are so overcooked, so overly fried that when you bite into them you have to be careful not to break your teeth.

Best Pizza in Fishkill! Large slices, friendly staff. Will stop here whenever I’m even remotely near the place.

This place used to be my favorite pizza spot, but has worked it’s way to the bottom of the barrel for me. The last few visits I’ve encountered a few of the female employees to be rude and I don’t know how other to put this… lost. they just looked spaced out.
This time, I stood at the counter for a good 10 minutes before they took my order to eat in, but they ended up boxing it up as a to go order. No biggie, I reminded them I was eating in, & they gave me an attitude about it. Then as I sat there and ate, everyone in the dining area could here the 2 girls that work behind the counter making fun and complaining about previous customers and people that were calling. I find it unprofessional to b**** about customers in front of your customers. Get it together Sals.

Quick stop here on the way home. The pizza was ok and the sandwiches were good. Staff was nice and the place was clean. They have a little tv in front of the counter playing news (at least thats what was on when I went).

Pizza doesn’t taste like it used to.

No gluten free

This place recently changed it’s name to Sal’s Pizza 2, and I think there might be new owners. Anyway, as Pizza Phil, it was a pretty good place for pizza. I’ve tried it since the name change and the pizza is not as great, for some reason. The slices are a good size, at least. Might be worth keeping an eye on.

Nothing great, decent place. Have had their baked ziti, lasagna and chicken marsala, all very average. Portions are pretty large though, so if you’re going for quantity over quality then this is ok.

On our personal «top 10 decent Pizza places» list in the area. Recommended. Try their freshly made regular pizza if you are into authentic regular pizza taste and like nice thin crust.