Stefano’s Pizza & Restaurant

I’ve had the regular cheese slice, the Sicilian cheese slice, and a cheesesteak. All were excellent. The service was friendly, too.

One of my all time favorites, this place does it all.
I highly recommend the rice balls, Sicilian style pizza, and Italian subs. The chicken parm is amazing, and makes a great pizza topping!
If there’s any downside at all, the delivery is sometimes on the slow side, but I have mostly only positive experiences at this wonderful place!!!

Found this place purely by accident. Arrived in Colts Neck late after moving from New England. We had to feed a pile of kids and they delivered pizzas after 11! I was so grateful. I have to say, their pizza was absolutely fantastic! prices were reasonable. Delivery was fast and friendly. I am just settled into our new home, and yes, I will be ordering from them. If you are a true foodie, you will absolutely appreciate this pizza!

This is the cream of the crop when it comes to pizza joints. My grandparents live in freehold and frequent here often with their pack of seniors. The large portion sizes are a plus with that crowd, but what keeps them coming back is the service. Really genuine, kind people work there that are incredibly accommodating. This year my grandma is going into surgery before Christmas so could not cook the tradition Italian fish dinner we usually have on Christmas Eve. Stefano’s worked with her to prepare everything how she does and brought out all 7 courses flawlessly. Bonus: they’re BYOB!

I’ve gone to Stefano’s since I was a kid. Growing up in Freehold, I always thought they had the best pizza in the area and I still do. Most of their sandwiches and entrees are pretty good too, and the people inside are usually quite nice.

LOVE LOVE LOVE Stefano’s! Everything is ALWAYS good there — especially the cheese pizza! I prefer delivery, I’m not a fan of the eat-​in … everyone seems kind of rude.

I moved to the area at the same time Anthony and Gary did– soonafter their restaurant opened. Although I haven’t been there often over the past few years, whenever I go, the food is consistently as great. We always ordered Pasta Primavera and Rigatoni in Marinara Sauce. Eat in or delivery, always great. Not a fancy dine in place, good for familia.

3.5 stars
Good classic pizza. Decent subs, mediocre wraps. They’re pretty cheap & they quickly deliver food which is a plus.

I came across Stefano’s lately and wow am I glad I tried them. I am usually a frequent patron of Du Sal’s further down the street but Stefano’s now gives it some serious competition in my book.
I ordered a plain pie, garlic knots, and two entrees and everything was absolutely delicious. I’m not really sure what they do differently than others but this is the real deal for Monmouth county. I will still go to Du Sal’s because they are excellent too, but I am definitely looking forward to coming back here.
The inside of the pizzeria is quite nice as well, with a flat screen HDTV and ample seating areas. The staff is what you’d expect for a pizzeria but very attentive to your order.
Big plus in my book for also carrying a very wide selection of Boylan’s drinks. I absolutely love their root beer and it’s quite hard to find. I was definitely upset Houlihan’s dropped Boylan’s from their menu and replaced them with Stewart’s…both are great but Boylan’s takes the crown in my book.

A great little local spot for some sicilian (square) pies. Its actually one of the best sicilian pies ive tasted in Jersey. Since im an italian from NY I take my pizza real seriously. As for the rest of the menu… eehhhh…regular pie is ok… garlic knots arent bad since they are wrapped in pepperoni. ive also tried the calamari and was not at all impressed. But if your going there its solely for the sicilian pie… u wont regret it

The best square pie in Freehold! Reminds me of Brooklyn! Garlic knots, calzones, a pie they call the old fashioned topped with garlic and bread crumbs! An amazing rigatoni and vodka sauce!
They deliver too! Forget about that thin crust nonsense across the street from them. This is what pizza is all about.

Great artisan pizza. Their regular pizza’s are NY/​NJ style and they have neopolitan style pizza also (margarita, etc.). Love their tomato sauce and fresh mozzerella! If you order a calzone, they charge you for marinara, thus the cause of 4 stars instead of 5.