Godfathers Pizza

Writing a review because the two tools that rated them should be pulled. One was whining about an order and the other straight up lied about some bs story that isn’t even possible to be true. i have ordered at least 200 pizza’s from Godfathers in the past 4 years and have never gotten anything but an exceptional pizza. I’ve been coming here for 20 years. It is, hands down, the best pizza in Fremont.
It’s the only place with fresh dough, fresh cheese and generous toppings and you can tell. The restaurant has been remodeled recently because it might have the nicest bathrooms I’ve ever seen in a non-​high dollar restaurant.
Godfathers is its own style of pizza and its a little thicker than New York Style. You have to order thin crust if you don’t like that. A tip, the Taco Pizza is simply delicious and I crave it ALL the time. The staff is mostly HS kids, but they seem like they are generally skilled and the management have been nothing but wonderful to my family when we’ve come in. They always say 45 for delivery, but I don’t think I’ve waited more than 30 except for when I’d expect it. (Snow, SB, etc.)

I had been here a couple years ago and it was great … but ordered from here a couple weeks ago and they got our order completely wrong plus there were parts that didnt even have toppings. I’ve been to many godfathers pizzas and never saw that until I went to this location. When I called back the lady wanted argue about how the mistake was made, I told her I just want my food can you just fix it and sent my husband in with an email copy of our order. She was still rude and never even apologized for thier mistake after we showed them how they were wrong. And the second pizza was even worse than the first. We will never go back there or recommend it again.

They used to be fantastic, now they are very hit and miss. I’ve heard that they will take pizza off the buffet and deliver it rather than prepare a fresh one for delivery. I tried them recently after a few years of staying away and it was a good meal, I may try them again.

Walked in and was greeted very well. Everything was clean and organized. Food was fresh and tasted great.