I got different pizzas at two different times. They deep fried the veggies and then the veggies tasted sweet. I don’t know why the pizza tasted weird also. Dissatisfaction both times i went there
Pamela K.
Évaluation du lieu : 2 East Orange, NJ
First time ordering through internet for takeout food. First time ordering from Pizza Mania. The food was not to my liking on my first order. The boss contacted me and tried make things right with me by delivering a small pizza and lentil soup. I retried the pizza and I didn’t find it any better than the first time it was hotter but it was still not to my liking. The soup was still tasteless and very watery. I know the boss did his best but I guess the food just isn’t to my liking. I will be going elsewhere for my pizza. Sorry I tried but I don’t like it.
Arben H.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Lodi, NJ
very good pizza, specialty pies are amazing, italian dishes are great, stay away from there philly cheese steak and french fries, best italian food, gelato is expensive, but its the best ice cream iv ever had.
John G.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Wayne, NJ
Fantastic place with fantastic food at a fantastic price. After lunch /dinner, have some fantastic gelato. Great for the whole family. Go often.
Terri L.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Bergen County, NJ
Ordered two small grilled chicken fresh mozzarella and roasted pepper sandwiches over the weekend as well as a side order of meatballs for delivery. When the delivery guy came and gave me the bill i was shocked. It was 35 dollars. They gave me large sandwiches which i never asked for and had to pay the extra money. When i opened the sandwiches, the chicken was chopped into pieces and the fresh mozzarella was melted. When you get a sandwich like that it shouldn’t be melted. I want fresh mozzarella slices, not the shredded mozzarella melted. The sandwiches were also completely soggy from the juices of the chicken and the bread just fell apart. As for the meatballs, they tasted like frozen meatballs and not homemade meatballs. Will not be ordered from them again. So disappointed and angry at wasting $ 35.00 on crap
Tom C.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Hackettstown, NJ
Best pizza in Garfield. Orders are always prepared quickly and estimates are accurate. Try the rice ball parmigiano! Overall no complaints
Danny G.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Garfield, NJ
Come here often to pickup. Ordered a delivery. Wait time was estimated at 45 mins. Sausage pie delivered in 20 mins! Always good and never have been disappointed. Stromboli w steak is fantastic, salads are great, pizza is outstanding.
Caitlin D.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Elmwood Park, NJ
Simply amazing vodka pizza!!! Highly recommend to anyone passing by.
Michelle P.
Évaluation du lieu : 2 Wallington, NJ
I just ordered a pizza from here and it was terrible. Paper thin crust and no taste. It’s just impossible to get a good pizza pie in Northern New Jersey these days.
Jessica M.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Fair Lawn, NJ
My job recently opened an office in Garfield, and we ordered six varieties of pizza for a meeting. The pizzas came quickly and were all delicious. I was especially impressed with their vegetable pizza, which included, tomatoes, peppers, onions, olives, spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, and eggplant! We will order from here regularly.
Karen G.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Garfield, NJ
I do have to say that they are very rude. I asked for a special request and they did not do it and I called t o question them what had happened they very were nasty about it. I’ve been a customer for a while and I will no longer go back
Antonio B.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Fairfield, NJ
This is the first time the Unilocal community has let me down. I have no idea what some of these reviews are talking about, this place is terrible. Trust me, I have eaten a lot of very good pizza… This isn’t it. This place is designed for high volume big profit margins, not quality. Low quality ingredients are the norm. I ordered the mussels based on the reviews here, they were horrible. They were so fishy I had to throw them out. Don’t even get me started on the delivery guy. I wish I could give zero stars.
Christine B.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Randolph, NJ
Pizza Mania never disappoints! Best arugula pizza ever, every sandwich, panini, pizza and salad has been excellent. We order lunch often, delivery is reliable and timely. I ordered a couple of large salads(chicken Cesar and antipasto) for a party, both were excellent.
Gary G.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Westwood, NJ
I called this place several time for them to remove me from their Fax list but I keep getting their Fax ads anyhow. They can’t take instructions over the phone so do you think they can get your order right? I doubt it. I wouldn’t do business with them since they don’t care.
Ken W.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Elmwood Park, NJ
We get delivery here all the time. They are always fast(usually at least 10 min sooner than the quoted time), accurate, and the food is always good. We usually order with a lot of modifications(my wife is a picky eater) and they always get our order right. I would def recommend this place for delivery in the saddle brook area.
Matt S.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Maywood, NJ
I wish this place was closer to me. Very good slice and nice selection in the restaurant. Try the buffalo calamari pizza.
Jessica G.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Saddle Brook, NJ
Decided to try this place on a whim and very happy that we did! I’ve never had a go to pizza place in Saddle Brook so I’m always looking for a good one that delivers. We got a Vodka Sauce pie and the Rice Balls Parmigiana– OMG, both out of this world! Will definitely order from here again.
Paola C.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Bergen County, NJ
Today we went out for dinner and seeing as we enjoyed a quick weather break, I’m feeling ice cream! My husband let me know pizza mania will deliver Italian icy or gelato at a $ 10 minimum, I had check this out! I fell for the italian icy in the spring! Last night we had Pizza Mania for dinner and really snacked out with mozz sticks, pizza, wings, and cheese fries. It was all good. I do rate Pizza Mania with 4 stars because it does fall on the pricier side, and they tend to have a longer wait then other local pizzerias.
A M.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 New York, NY
This place is located close to where I live so I can’t help but stop by sometimes to indulge my pizza cravings(which happen more than Id like to admit!) their slices are a bit more on the expensive side, but large and great quality. They have an awesome selection of pizza by the slice and it seems to change daily which is good and bad. Their slice with the salad on it is amazing. MUSTTRY! They don’t always have it though. Which makes me very sad. Oh and also try the gelato next door. Not much different than what I had while I was visiting Sicily this summer :)
Fransisca M.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Elmwood Park, NJ
Everyone I’ve spoken to in the Elmwood Park-Saddle Brook-Garfield area love PizzaMania. I’m pretty sure they are the unofficial official pizza supplier for all pizza parties in the building I work with. But don’t settle for just delivery. To really experience it in its fullness, you gotta visit the store and see for yourself. So many toppings that I didn’t know even existed. I kept on asking what is this, what is that, and they just are so patient answering. The crust is so different, I don’t know what it is, and plenty of healthy options too. They serve gluten free items, just in case anyone is on this diet