Cala Lily Restaurant And Bar

I’m legitimately shocked that there are negative reviews on here for this restaurant. I’ve been a huge fan of Cala Lily since the beginning. Their new location is lovely — the interior is as classy as it gets — and the food is, unsurprisingly, fantastic. Rick, the chef, pours his heart into his creations, and his passion manifests in every bite. We’re lucky to have him in Pittsburgh — Cala Lily is easily one of the best restaurants in the entire city.
I find the reviews regarding preservatives utterly preposterous. I have been here tens of times, and ingredients are ALWAYS fresh. You honestly can’t go wrong here. Everything is delicious, however, my personal favorite is the Pumpkin Tortellini with jumbo crab, julienne leeks, and roasted tomatoes. The Steak Diane is also an amazing choice — the meat just melts in your mouth. To start, I recommend the Portabello & Crab Florentine.
Don’t forget to save room for dessert! Do yourself a favor and try the Cala Lily Rose (chocolate covered ice cream, served with fresh raspberries in Chambord). I guarantee you’ll thank me afterwards.

Came tonight for the first time. The atmosphere was great, the service was perfect, and everyone’s food looked amazing. I got the lobster and crab bisque. It had a great flavor, though a bit too think and over-​salted. I also got an appetizer special which was a portobello with crab stuffing, spinach, and fontinella cheese. It was fantastic. I would love to come back and try some of the other dishes.

Simply Excellent!
Five Stars!
Pricey but if you go early they have specials.
Diverse menu, friendly people and a great owner!

I agree with a previous reviewer re: preservatives. At least, I’m hoping it was the preservatives and not spoiled food. After ordering the chicken salad, I was immediately sick to my stomach. Like, bad. They do not have a kids menu, which is kind of bullocks, considering it isn’t a fancy restaurant. Even Ruth’s Chris has a kid’s menu…
I won’t return. Not recommended.

Despite living in the area for 17 years I never went here. The façade of the old site was unappealing.
My loss if it was anything like I enjoyed on my first visit recently.
Three couples enjoyed the food and drink and staff. Outstanding. We will be back

Awsome. As good as their last location with a better atmosphere. The Beans and greens are always good.

I’m not sure what they preserve their food with but hope you don’t live too far from home. So uncomfortable.

Fabulous food so worth the price! Missed them when they closed in May 2014. So happy they are back and better than ever. Happy hour menu is worth checking them out.