Batter Up Cakes

This place is amazing. The owner is amazing and will get you exactly what you need and SO MUCH MORE. Amazing people willing to do anything to make the customer happy. Got my daughters cake there last year when we were new and they were more than helpful! Helped me with food and life!

Really good customer service, awesome cupcakes, I tried the eclaires and they are pretty tasty. Can’t wait to go back

Batter up cakes is amazing!!! They have made my cakes for 2 years now. The staff is wonderful to work with, and friendly. I live in Englewood and I drive the distance to get their cakes for my events. Thank you guys for going above and beyond.

Batter Up Cakes made our cake for our wedding on October 31^st. We showed them a couple of Halloween themed pictures of cakes we liked that were quite different from each other and gave them complete artistic control after that. The cake turned out amazing, somehow they managed to combine the cakes we liked into one cake and still added a nice wedding touch. Everyone commented on how awesome the cake turned out. Then they tasted it-​the compliments kept coming. Would definitely recommend them!

Great bakery with a good variety. The peanut butter and jelly cupcake was my favorite. Coconut macaroon was delicious. Service was great as well and priced fair.

Batter up cakes just did my wedding cake and it was absolutely beautiful. Jerri was amazing to work with and I couldn’t be happier with how my cake turned out.

I’m a believer that a bakery should put a smile on your face no matter how bad your mood is. Batter Up Cakes is that bakery. The location is adorable, and walking down the stairs to the storefront prepares you for the oasis of baked goods that will greet you inside.
Stepping up to the case, where the treats are displayed like jewels, it’s hard to narrow down what should go home with you. The sticky bun was the first thing that caught my eye. It was mounded with carmel covered pecans, and I knew that I couldn’t leave without one. The sticky bun did not disappoint. I can safely say that it was the best sticky bun I’ve ever tasted (infinitely better than the «famous» rolls at a certain popular Fort Collins breakfast joint). The dough was flavorful and tender, but it still had substance that stood up the the nutty topping. While I’m talking about the topping, the sugar was perfectly caramelized and bound the pecans to the roll with just the right amount of stick. I would not be disappointed if my last meal consisted of one of these pecan rolls.
Also, the costumer service was fantastic. I needed advice, otherwise I would have taken one of everything, so I asked the woman behind the country what she would take home. She recommended a cream puff and a carrot cake cupcake. Both were divine. The cream puff was huge and overflowing with the perfect ratio of slightly sweetened cream. The carrot cupcake also didn’t disappoint. My final purchase was a grasshopper brownie for my boyfriend, who is not a big sweet person. He was very pleased with the dark chocolate flavor of the topping and compared it to an Andes Mint. I was surprised that he finished the whole brownie without my help, because it was huge and super rich.
As I mentioned before, the customer service was helpful, friendly, and prompt, which is always appreciated. Also, I walked away with three gigantic pastries and a cupcake for about $ 12, which I think is a fantastic deal. I’ll be stopping at Batter Up Cakes any time that my day needs some added sweetness.

You will run into this place, for the cupcakes. And will enjoy them and will want to indulge and run off the extra cupcakes or other goodies that you will want to sample. The store offers a cozy atmosphere and cupcakes are embedded in the décor.

I loved this shop so much! I really wish we had a place that was inviting & unique as this shop in Chicago.
I stopped in because my friend & I picked up her daughter’s birthday cake there the day before and since I had the morning to myself, I wanted to check it out further since I really enjoyed the cupcake I had the day we got the cake. I hung out, had a yummy scone & great green tea. So I decided to visit the next day before I had to catch the shuttle to the airport. I carried my hunk of luggage to the elevator & popped in before they opened it turns out. Jerri was very kind & made sure I was well taken care of. She asked how my visit went and made sure I had a ride to the airport because she didn’t want to see me walking down the highway alone. She went out of her way to make me feel cared for & I appreciated that so much. I wish I could have thanked her in person but she was on the phone when I had to head out. Thanks Jerri for being so kind!
I so wish I could hang out at this bakery weekly with my friends from the area. I will definitely be back during my next visit to Colorado!

Jerri was fabulous! She was such a delight to work with. She truly cares about her brides and is willing to go the extra mile.
The best thing? She helped make my three layer cake dream come true with our modest budget!
Actually, the BETTER thing? The cake was freaking delicious! There was hardly any left and many people took multiple pieces to try the different flavors.
What a gem I found in Batter Up Cakes!

Batter Up cakes provided the wedding cake for my daughter’s wedding. The cake was fantastic! Everyone raved about how good it was. But that is only part of the story.
We looked at a lot of different bakeries, but Batter Up Cakes really stood out from the crowd. Jerri is an amazing, caring, and talented professional who took the time to ensure that we were going to get exactly what we wanted. She met us for two cake-​tasting sessions and walked us through the options, highlighting opportunities for us to save money. She made us feel at ease and gave us more cake, of different varieties, than any of the other businesses we met with. She personally delivered and set-​up the cake and made sure that everything was perfect. And her price was lower than the competition. I *love* Batter Up Cakes!
Batter Up Cakes also created an amazing Groom’s Cake that incorporated unique facets of the Groom’s personality and interests in an extremely creative way. It was a huge hit!
I highly recommend Batter Up Cakes, and I will use their services at every opportunity. Great cake. Great people. A great business!

So, the good: the stuffed croissant with minced olive and tomato… amazing. Truly it was delicious. The quiche looked pretty awesome too.
The bad: the place has amazing stain glass windows and an old hardwood floor. The problem though, aside from the buildings own beautiful features is that there are trinkets kind of strewn around and décor that just makes it feel cheap. Greeley’s town center has so much potential and again and again every place that I go to seems to fall short of harnessing that potential.
This place would be a hotspot for all of the college students to study and get coffee if it had some tlc put into it and if they sold lattes!
I understand it’s a cake shop at its core, but business could be booming!

Hidden away downstairs… Don’t be afraid! Plenty of seating when we went mid-​day. Wide selection of cupcakes for a reasonable price (having paid $ 4 per cupcake at other shops). The cake flavors were excellent and just the right amount of frosting. We tried a half dozen and all were delicious — both the basic cakes and the fancier flavors. Great variety from simple vanilla and chocolate to almond poppy, filled raspberry, german chocolate, etc. They have cupcake appropriate inserts for the boxes so they wont slide around if you take them home:). the regular cakes looked good too.
We will be back!