Rustique Pizzeria + Lounge

What a super cute pizza place! Love the wood fired grill! Never had a bad meal here. I do wish it wasn’t so echoey in the dining room but other than that enjoy this place thoroughly and love taking people who have never been here.

I have been here several times and it’s always fabulous! Yes the place is small and on a weekend you will wait so I’d make a reservation if you can. But it’s so much better than the usual bar and grill places you’ll find everywhere. Everything tastes fresh and the Rustique punch is great. We love to bring out of town guests here especially in the summer to sit on the patio. Definitely a more unique place for people looking for something different.

My favorite pizza in Green Bay with many fun and creative options! I am a big fan of anything drizzled in a balsamic glaze, including some of their pizzas and the amazing pesto fries.
I like the old church atmosphere, just wish it was a bit larger. Seating can be a bit cramped at times and the wait can be long. Hope it expands soon… still highly recommend this place!

Amazing food! Great atmosphere! Love the homemade chips and salsa and the pesto fries!

This place is a Pizza Gem outside of Green Bay. This place has thin crust but it really is some of the best damn pizza I have ever had. A bit on the pricey side but it well worth the price. The Pesto Fries are amazing as an appetizer and then we ended up getting a 4 cheese pizza and San Mateo pizza which has pesto on it. Normally I HATE pesto but this pizza was amazing. We are definitely going again. The wait time on Friday was roughly an hour but the service was fast and great. That is my only negative was the wait time. And you can’t make reservations unless you have a group of 6 or more. Oh and this place is an old church! Amazing venue.

Just tried their Friday Fish Fry and it met my expectations. There aren’t too many «great» fish fry places I’ve found on the north side of GB but this one is pretty good. Along with the rest of their menu, Rustique is sure to please everyone in your group. Overall still a great stop.

You must have the Pesto Fries. The pizza is good. Best to visit in the summer when the patio is open.

Went for lunch on a Sunday its beautiful place the outside deck is good, food is amazing ordered two appetizer n we were full before the pizza came. We ordered the cheese pizza n it was wow we loved it the appetizer were amazing as well.

Loved this place, sat out on the patio under the lights. Kids enjoyed the swingset. Ordered the Cuban sandwich and loved every bite. Great food and the ambiance is very relaxed.

I had a really hard time picking a star rating because there were parts that I really loved and parts that I really disliked.
The restaurant itself was great. It was once a chapel and still has a lot of its original features. We sat on the deck which is built around a huge shade tree. They also had really cute strings of light on the patio. The seating itself was really awkward. There were five of us and they put us at a table for four. It wouldn’t of been so bad if the chairs weren’t so huge.
They have a swing set outside that kept our children busy while we waited for our meal. That was pretty awesome.
The service was insanely slow. Our food took so long to come out that it was clear mine and my husbands sandwiches spent several minutes under a heat lamp. We ordered the Cuban sandwiches. We had to ask for extra sauce because they were so dry we could barely swallow them. I was disappointed the waitress didn’t check in to see if that helped because it didn’t. The sandwiches came with a side of fries. The fries were amazing! They give you the option of upgrading to pesto fries which I read were really awesome. I am usually not a fan of pesto so I asked the waitress for just a drop on a spoon so we could try it. She told me ‘we don’t do that here’. It’s funny to think that they turned down $ 4 over a small drop of pesto.
We had three petite children with us who all wanted cheese pizza. The pizzas were huge and they could have easily shared one. The pizza was delicious but if I were the waitress I would think it was ridiculous for three young children to each have such a large pizza. I disliked how wasteful it was.
We are normally huge tippers but it was painful giving her the obligatory 18%. (I tipped her based on service — not food)
I don’t think I’d go back again. I can’t fathom spending that much money on food and being so disappointed.

Food is awesome! Service is always good. The standard menu are all hits. The specials can be hit or miss but that’s dependent upon personal taste of course. We take anyone from out of town here and have never been disappointed.

I came here with my friends to celebrate being home and I loved it!
Overall the prices were very reasonable (compared to California). I ordered a Moscow Mule for only $ 6. It wasn’t great and definitely tasted pretty basic, but it was only $ 6.
For dinner I got the pesto fries and the «Fun Guy» pizza to split between three of us. The portions are HUGE. The pesto fries were amazing. Probably some of the best fries I’ve ever had. The pizza had FOUR different types of mushrooms. It was really good! I liked that the crust wasn’t too thick, since I’m a fan of thin crust.
The service was a little slow and the reason I’m not giving this place five stars. I understand that it was Friday but we had 9 people in our party and made a reservation a day in advance. We still had to wait for a table and then we were sat outside.
My friend has a brand new baby so I felt bad, she was clearly cold. Also they don’t have heat lamps which are necessary in my opinion. Our server was great but they are clearly understaffed because she had so many tables. So it took her awhile to keep coming back to us. But she did split our checks and split our pizza three ways. We really appreciated that!

Go to the new zoo in your in town and then come to this little old church. Patio seating is great or view the open kitchen in the dining room. We shared the burger a Cesar salad bruschetta dip and some wings. Nice smores cheesecake too. Service friendly and observant.

We found this restaurant by searching on Unilocal — it was one of the highest rated restaurants in the area. We headed over without a reservation & while the outside patio was packed — it was August — the inside bar was empty. We enjoyed watching the very friendly bartender make all the mojitos & mixed drinks. We ordered the supreme pizza — pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms. We split a side salad to start & the balsamic dressing was good. Unfortunately the pizza was bland — no seasoning or flavor at all. We give this one 3 stars for the great service but the pizza needs some serious updating to get us back.

Love this place. First time we came I had the perch basket and the batter was perfect, flaky and not super greasy. Had pizza the next time and it was awesome. They have a good variety of food and they offer some out of the normal toppings for pizza along with classics. The pesto fries are a must!!! I can’t say that enough. They are amazing.

My husband and I recently moved to town and decided to try some local fare last night. Goodness, are we happy we did! This place was was wonderful from start to finish.
Arriving on a busy Saturday night we expected there to be a wait and there was. We hung out on the patio and bar area that seemed lively and inviting. We were able to get seated in the bar a bit early with their first come first serve tables. It had a vibrant atmosphere that seemed fitting for a local pizza establishment. When we looked at the menu we were pleasantly surprised with the variety and selection.
Our meal starred with the fried plantains, AMAZING! They were crispy enough and the sauce was delicious. I was blown away by the fried pulled pork however, it added a nice flavor to the dish.
We couldn’t decide on one pizza so we ordered two (there were 4 of us eating). My husband decided on the Goucho. I decided on on the San Mateo. Both pizzas were delicious. The crust was flavorful and not too doughy. We joked the our pizzas were so loaded with toppings it would be hard to pick up. No complaints on that one as the toppings were to die for. Each lent a unique flavor to the pizza and complemented the others.
I’ve been to many pizza places in my life and I appreciate a well prepared meal. This places is among the best… and to think it is in Suamico! We will be repeat customers and cannot wait until the next time we indulge our palettes!

I would love to give this place five stars but the tiny space and lack of service I have experienced knocked it down to a four.
As many other reviews have stated the pesto fries are to DIE for. This place may cause you to drive a bit to get there but it is worth it. Their Friday fish fry and pizza’s are always excellent.

We love this place !!! The burger is fantastic !! (get it with bacon and egg) my fav pizza is San Mateo ! Fish fry is best in town !!

This is my favorite place today when I’m home. We typically get here early for a good spot. Service here is always excellent. We had Andrew as a server, who did everything he could to be hospitable.
This time, we ordered the special pizza. It was a buffalo mozzarella pie with sausage and caramelized onions. Yum! The kitchen had an error with our 3^rd pizza and corrected the error immediately.
The place is casual, beautifully decorated, and cozy. When we left, there was a huge wait to get seated. Rustique may have to make an addition. I don’t think this place is a fad. It’s not going anywhere and will likely get even busier.
Prices are fair. Not too expensive and not cheap. For the quality of food you’re getting I am ok with paying 19 for a pizza.
Parking is a little tight, but you can always park on the road coming in.

If you’re looking for excellent food and atmosphere look no further.
This little pizzeria is a must stop if you find yourself. In the Green Bay area.
Unique and traditional hand thrown pizza offerings are just the beginning.
Make sure you try the balsamic and pesto fries as well as the homemade clam chowder.
Always busy I recommend making a reservation.
Now I’m going to eat my Drunken Meatball pizza
Happy Eats