Jeppy’s Pizzeria 2

Was going back and forth between 3 – 4 stars. If there was a 3.5 choice jeppys would be that. Very friendly and personable on the phone when i placed my order for delivery. Meals were good not great. Had the cheesesteak and penne vodka. Next time would try the pizza since it is a pizza place. Will let you know how it goes…

Hole in the wall pizza place that makes the best tomato pies in all of trenton. Good prices, quick service and friendly atmosphere. Have the tomato pie, you won’t regret it.

Loved this pizza, nice and greasy like a proper pizza should be. I got the onions, sausage, and peppers as toppings. The sausage was in chunks, not slices or shredded, which I definitely prefer. The delivery guy was late, but he gave us a 2 liter bottle of soda. Too bad I don’t really drink soda, but it was a nice gesture.

Stopped in at 10:45pm for a quick slice while working on an ambulance. He turned me away saying they’re not serving anymore. Why say you’re open to 11 then? Never going back.

We came here a couple of times and the food is really great. I always order a buffalo chicken cheese steak and it is amazing :) my husband gets a regular chicken cheese steak with fried onions and he loves it. The food is always hot and delicious. Great!

Just got a brooklyn pie from here, brought it home and enjoyed the flavor. Great crust, perfect amount of crushed tomatoes and mozzarella. Only 2 tables and a few seats at the counter. Luckily I live close enough to pick it up and get home while it is still hot.
Will go back and try another type of pie, or maybe even sandwiches or dinners… Great food… it’s small inside, but the pie was awesome. If you like Trenton style pizza/​tomato pie, go there!!!

Cattycorner from Pete’s Steakhouse Tavern, Jeppy’s is as small as Pete’s is big.
It is primarily a take out joint with only a couple of tables in the closet sized space for guys like me who work near by, but don’t want to eat at their desks. I met the owner/​manager who was friendly and had no problem fixing me up after 3:00 with their 2 Slice and a Drink Special at $ 4.95.
The pie was okay, but could have been more if it had spent enough time back in the oven to totally reheat the triangles to the original temperature, rather than removing them when only lukewarm. The flavor was right, but the crust texture was soft and doughy from failure to bring the crust to the near molten state required to make it firm and crunchy. As this seems to be endemic to many places, it may be my job to ask for a «well done» slice so they are left to burn a bit longer.
Otherwise, Jeppy’s is a cool little place. Much like the Little Engine That Could, Jeppy’s sits across from Big Boy Pete’s and with all its glare and attitude, repeating over and over, «I think I can. I think I can…»
Until it becomes, «I know I can. I know I can…»

This is the go-​to delivery place for our family, and is especially helpful when we have friends over as there is something for everybody.
Great pizza, good cheese steaks and excellent sides and appetizers (ask for the steak fries). They’ve gone the extra mile from us on more than one occasion and have always given us the correct order even when it’s complicated.
We have a lot of choice in our location for good delivery of this kind of food, and the price to value match at Jeppy’s makes it our most frequent spot.

The other reviewers must be friends of Jeppy’s or something. I ordered from this place once and it was terrible. There’s a lot of places around to get pizza and wings. Thought I’d give the new guy a try. Soggy, wet pie and wings thrown in a bag. Over all sloppy and not tasty.