Barton’s Pizzeria

Living in Chicago this is my go to for pizza when visiting the region. We always get a sausage pizza and it never disappoints, it’s so good I can’t bring myself to try anything else. Even reheated my taste buds tingle with excitement. My husband who is from Michigan thinks it’s the best he’s had since moving to Chicago 20 years ago. My only complaint is they don’t deliver to Chicago. haha.

Great tasting pizza, and in my experience, great service.

Had a pizza from the highland store worst pizza i have EVER had ordered family w/​pineapple sausage and cheese what i got was a greasy half ass pizza with pepperoni and sausage. Called to inform them of there mistake and the girl on the other end acted like it was my fault that they messed up my pie and would not fix it STAY AWAY IF YOU DO NOT LIKE SHIT PIZZA

Have not had a pizza here in YEARS, as i live 2 hours south, but i was thinking about it and will have it again soon!
Loved it when it was served at the GRAPEVINE Lounge in Calumet City

If this review were only about the quality of the pizza, I would give 4 starts. Barton’s pizza is very good. My favorite topping here is ground beef with extra cheese. The beef is baked under the cheese and makes for a very meaty, cheesy pizza that tastes very good and filling, although a bit greasy and sloppy. It is possible to get a gigantic pizza here that will quite comfortably feed 4 large hungry people, and 5 – 6 mortals.
The downside with Barton’s is the delivery. It takes a long time, and although I hate to say negative things about a person, in my latest experience the delivery driver presented absolutely the worst appearance imaginable for a person’s appetite… and I’m not usually squeamish or shallow. I do not wish to judge, so I will leave it at that. Next time I want a Barton’s pizza I will go pick it up.

Very good pizza! Great customer service!