Carlo’s Pizza

The BBQ chicken pizza is very good. I always seem to enjoy the rounds and the cheese sticks. A little greasy however not anything over the top. A nice change from Jets or Little Caesars.

Ordered a pizza a few months ago for delivery. Waited an hour and called to see where if it was. The guy who answered said it will be just a little longer. Waited another hour and called again and was told the pizza was on the way. It never showed up! Shitty pizza and even shittier employees and management. Carlos is dead to me. Can’t wait for the next pizza place to open when Carlos goes out of business. Should be soon.

Very good pizza. Some of us at work get the lunch special which is 2 decent size pizza slices and a pop for about $ 4.95. The pizza is always hot, crispy, and smells delicious… ask for the garlic butter to be added because it’s sooo good! The 2 workers were nice and had good customer service and asked if I needed help taking the lunch orders to the car. I’ll be back again, thanks!

Wow!!! Amazing pizza!!! Their round is the best I have ever had… outside of a coal oven. So happy to have them as our local pizza shop. We just moved here and only had a hungry howie’s before. This is how pizza should be!

I love their Meat-​Lovers deep dish square pizza. It hits the spot every time, including tonight.
Easy parking, Warm, bright and clean inside, friendly staff.
No inside seating, actually, no outside seating either.

The best crispy crust on their square pizzas, the BBQ chicken pizza is one I recommend to newbies.
Their brownies are awesome too.

I’ve had the square deep dish pizzas (small and large) and they’re very crunchy. I like crunchy crusts and only this place and jets fit the bill. The antipasto salad had green and black olives on it which was very cool. A large supreme pizza (like jets super special) is $ 15.74 plus tax. Very expensive pizza. Small salads are huge!

Was late 3:30 pm Sunday afternoon & needed 1 slice to take the edge off, I doubted that they sold slices on a Sunday… but they DID!
CARLO’S Pizza was well staffed with super friendly young men, who welcomed me, assured me they had slices & even tricked it out with Butter/​Parmesan .
I personally love the BITE their Sauce has.

Carlos of South River definitely ain’t what it used to be…
Once upon a time, you could get a great pie at Carlos. Heck, you could get a great chicken & rib dinner too. I would brag to my family and friends about the great pizza joint I had local. Now I dont mention the name because thats all I hear about is people mad that I referred them there and they were so disappointed my pizza recommendations have no credibility anymore :(
Unfortunately, something changed the past few years which has forced me to give up on them — and I love pizza — in fact, I get pizza at least once weekly. Im a pizza snob too, no «hot n’ ready» for this boy. I need the real thing.
Their version of a ‘supreme’ pizza turned into a cheese pizza with just a hint of what kinds of toppings you should be getting. In other words, they are very very skimpy on toppings now and even after complaining, they still havent changed a thing. The last time I ordered the chicken and potato wedges, I commented that I could’ve (and should’ve) just went to Kroger and got a $ 5 rotisserie chicken and a bag of potato wedeges out of the freezer section. It would’ve been cheaper and tasted a heck of a lot better!
I cannot comment on any other Carlos, as the one on Shook/​Jefferson wont deliver to my house only Carlos of South River will, bummer.

The slices are great and one dollar. Actually, their slices are better than their pizzas. It is perfect if you want a quick bite.