New York Pizza

My family and I dined here for dinner tonight and we were pleasantly surprised. We are new to the area and so far haven’t been thrilled with the dining options. The stuffed pizza was really good, as was the calzone my daughter ordered. Our younger daughters shared a cheese pizza and ate every last bite, including the crust (this never happens). I ordered the fettuccine Alfredo but did not care for the sauce; this is probably my fault as I am a bit particular about Alfredo, but our waitress was extremely kind and understanding. This dish came with garlic knots which were good and I added a salad. The Italian dressing was so very good.
Overall we had a great experience and will be going back for the pizza and calzones.

The pizza is delicious, my favorites are the stuffed ones, so good! Oh! and you cant order in without ordering the jalapeño bites perfect mix of spicy and cheesy and always fresh out of the oven. Also, if you are not in the mood for a whole pizza their strombolis and calzones are a decent size with reasonable prices.

Loved this pizza! Crust so lightly crunchy on the outside yet soft and light on the inside. Had the veggie. Amazing eggplant on this pizza! I’ll be back!!!

Just moved here from NJ Got take out pizza for moving troops and it was devoured. Very good. Went for lunch couple days later and was satisfied once again. Will be back. Very friendly and helpful waitress.

Perfectly amazing lunch buffet.
Great selection and freshness.
Very friendly staff.
I’ll be back.

We’ve ate here 3 times in the past 6 months. One was great, one was poor, and this time it was OK.

The pizza has a very NY-​authentic taste and the staff is fast and courteous. The place is a little dated but clean, but the flavor of the pizza makes up for the ambiance.

Best pizza around entire North GA area! It really is! Try the ham pepperoni mushroom onions and extra cheese. You’ll love it!!!

Oh wow! A NY pizza place in Hartwell! This is unbelievable. They had a salad bar and pizza bar similar to Pizza Hut’s. The salad was mainly iceberg with decent toppings. They had multiple different olive oils to put on also. I used the basil and garlic. It was fresh and tasty! The pizzas were good too. I hade the meat, the covered pie and the apple cinnamon dessert pie. The covered was like a calzone. Very good! The meat had sausage pepperoni and bacon bits. Good too. And the apple cinnamon was a delish sweet treat. They had one waitress and she kept up well since it was just my coworker and i. We missed the
Lunch rush by 30 minutes. I will return to this gem.

Best pizza in Hartwell, big pie with plenty of toppings, calzone is goo too, delivery takes between 45 min to a hour.

Has to be worst pizza I have ever eaten… Chef boyardee pizza is better than this. Salad bar had old veggies and run of the mill iceberg lettuce. The only descent thing there was the dessert pizza. Oh and never got a refill the whole time we were there.

Tried this place out while visiting my sister — had the vegetarian. Very good — loved the crust. Plus it was a great value for the price. I could see this place being a regular if I lived in this part of the world. Guess I will have to wait until the next time I visit and try out something with meat.

Ate at this pizza joint with 3 family members for lunch. I couldn’t have pizza that day but they all had the lunch buffet and good lord the pizza looke and smelled amazing!
I had the salad bar! It was great! Romaine lettuce and great veggies and chick peas! Kudos to the salad bar! We all left happy! Plan to return my next visit!
Great customer service! Thanks!