Coutts Ice Cream

Really great homemade ice cream, really love the closeness to the lake and Good service.

The best home made ice cream that I have ever had! I love that they keep trying new flavors on top of the long list of excellent options that they already have. It’s also wonderful that you can take home a quart of ice cream (which I do often!). Their flavors are unique and interesting, but don’t overlook the old favorites! Their chocolate and strawberry flavors are out of this world! Lake Wallenpaupack is lucky to have this family-​owned business that offers delicious ice cream made with quality ingredients and friendly customer service!

Unique Ice Creams abound here and there is nothing better than their maple bacon. It has a salty sweet thing that is just amazing (though the last batch didn’t have nearly enough bacon). They try all sorts of things. Some hit, some miss… but at least it isn’t your everyday chocolate and vanilla. Kudos for trying baked bean ice cream. It was amusing… and um … even horrible perhaps but hey … they’re trying to do unique stuff and I love that. Keep up the new inventions this year!

If you’re looking for ice cream, this is the place! It’s good, homemade ice cream. Portions are huge so be conservative on ordering two or three scoops. I had the Chocolate Brownie that was really wonderful. The rest of the party had other flavors that were just as well received. My next sample will be their Joyous Almond, possibly a flavor to my beloved Peter Paul Almond Joy Bar… It’s great ice cream at a very affordable price.

Awesome place. A local at a boat shop recommended it and I’m glad we went. It’s pretty cute, they sell jam and soaps as souvenirs, but the best part is the ice cream. Portions are insane, one waffle cone with three scoops of blueberry, coffee, and salty caramel were bigger than my head and fairly cheap. They have a bunch of flavors and the staff is very friendly. They also have an outdoor seating area which is nice because it takes a while to eat that much ice cream.

We love to stop here for delicious ice cream and the other finds we’ve made too! They have wonderful gourmet-​style local cheeses, homemade fudge and of course the delicious jams, jellies and other farm goodies mentioned by others.
One additional bonus is their delicious ready-​made ice cream cakes. Our daughter remembered seeing them in the freezer when we were there one time, so we swung by to pick one up for a neighborhood barbeque… it was a hit!
Recommend adding this place to your list of places to frequent in the Like Wallenpaupack area. Its all good and offers a couple of special staples we keep in our freezer/​fridge/​cupboard too.
Also their homeade goods are GREAT local area gifts to give for special host/​hostess or teacher gifts, etc!

Stopped at this farm market for the advertised ice cream. The market did not have any fresh fruit but offered jams of all varieties, cheeses, fudges/​chocolates, drinks and ICE CREAM. The ice cream is made at the creamery nearby. I had the «Buckhorn» and the chocolate fudge brownie. The servings are huge. The ice cream was smooth and creamy. Lots of creative flavors, for example buckhorn was vanilla ice cream with M &M and rasberry swirl.

YUMMY YUMMY in my Tummy!!!
I sampled about 6 or so flavors and they were all good. What I love is that they have some crazy flavors like maple bacon and nutella. I settled with salted caramel and almond joy… So good and creamy. They give you a good amount for a good price. Come in and try some of their interesting flavors!

If you want awesome, creative, delicious ice cream, come by Coutt’s! A family favorite. I’ve been coming up to Lake Wallenpaupack since I was an infant and since Coutt’s has opened their store and their ice cream is a WINNER. I’d say they are the key contributor to a good 4 pounds I gained while at the lake, but I’d eat it all over again.

The Red velvet cake ice dream is rich and delicious. Of course if you want blueberries they have plenty of them too. I bought the blueberry jam and its wonderful. Lake Wallenpaupacks best ice cream.