Two Guys Pizza

Pizza Pizza Pizza Everyone loves Pizza — but Do not love the Pizza Server. Food here is not even that great to begin with. It is often raw from inside or burnt more after reheating the cold slice that is laid out for hours. You cannot deal with the staff there. I do not blame the working staff but management really sucks. They make the poor employees charge customers whatever they damn well please. I used to pick up single slices from here on a regular basis — cost $ 2.20 per slice No big deal — everywhere around is usually under $ 2.
Then it went up to $ 2.40 per slice — I understand — Rising costs of doing business in Long Island. Accepted. Took it in stride. But TODAY — I received a really bad reception at this pizzeria. I asked him how much for the slice — $ 2.70. I was shocked. I had brought in $ 2.50 thinking it is $ 2.40. I asked the server why? He said it is $ 2.70. I picked up the carryout menu and the price was $ 2.50 So i asked him — he said it is $ 2.50 plus tax. I said — I have been picking up pizza for the last year and I was always given one price — so now you charge tax. I stormed out of the place and will always advise local pizza lovers to be careful about the charging practices of this place. TERRIBLE. Also, note that the ONLINE MENU price on their site is $ 2.45 Per slice. So, Buyer Beware — what you pay for if it is a simple slice of pizza (most elementary) imagine what they can do for catering and other orders.
Thank You
VS

Seriously the go to place in Hicksville been here a long time and always satisfying always fresh and some of the best ingredients and most professional Pizza and pizzeri items you will get

If you are looking for a quick slice of pizza in Westbury or Hicksville, Two Guys is the only place you should go to. Their ingredients are so good and fresh compared to other pizzerias in that area and they are quick with orders. I recommend the white pizza, regular cheese slice, grandma slice, and buffalo chicken slice. Their pizzas are thin with a crispy crust, very little oil, and delicious sauce and cheese. Simply delicious!

Came into the area for the dealership nearby, traveling from Brooklyn. Went into 2 Guys for a quick bite. Honestly, I think this place is pretty darn good and I’m surprised this place has the reviews that it does. The pizza is very above average and I’m a pizza snob. Is it the best pizza that I’ve ever had, no but hell, it’s pretty good and a step above most pizza that you get. Good taste and texture of the crust, just enough thickness and a hint of crunch. Sauce, which I think makes or breaks the slice is yum, not too sweet nor too acidic. A hefty amount of cheese. Give this place a try, it’s better than the previous reviews let on. :)

I was at Two Guys the other day as I was nearby.
I was a bit disappointed when I walked in to the place, It was definitely looking a bit sad and rundown.
The pizza on display was all old and looked like it had been sitting for a while.
I asked if anything was coming out anytime soon, And was told cicilian was.
I waited the 10 minutes as there is nothing worse than reheated pizza.
The pizza was ok had a very bland taste, Definitely nothing special.
Do not think I would go there again.

Best Pizza not only in Long Island but in New York, including Manhattan. Authentic Father & Son Italians making their unique brand of Pizza with high quality ingredients and unique pizza sauce flavor. Any true lover of pizza or Foodie can take one bite of their pizza and know this is 5-​Star Pizza. Highly recommended. Their Grandma sicilian with garlic is unmatched anywhere.

I was told that I had to try this pizza because it is the best in town. I have to admit, I do not agree whatsoever. It is a very simple pizza place with not much variety when it comes to pizza options like at some other places but the best way to see how good pizza is is by trying their plain slice and even their Sicilian slice so I ordered one of each. The Sicilian slice wasn’t that great at all. I am not in love with the sauce here and I took the pizza home to heat up in my own conventional toaster oven because I like to do that so it is hot and really crispy. I almost burnt it because it just wouldn’t crisp up so it is really just a doughy slice of Sicilian. The plain slice was okay but it just wasn’t the greatest I have ever had. If I was running really late for something and starving and needed a slice just to get my through and I was literally right in this shopping center, I would get a plain slice but Two Brothers is only a few blocks down on Newbridge and is way better. I also am not a fan of Pepsi products and they only serve Pepsi products here.

The pizza here is not so bad. This is your average Joe kinda pizza. Its not great but also not so bad.

Best pizza ever… I’ve flown to NY and when driving to Long Island, it’s my first stop… and the last on the way to the airport. Outstanding… great crust and just the right amount of cheese. Cooked to perfection.

Yes, it’s pizza, typical Long Island pizza. It’s close to work, so that’s why we go

ok so i’m reviewing a lot of places in hicksville. but seriously, if you dont have to come here. you probably shouldnt. unless you like indian food cause i heard theres a lot of really good places around here that i havent gone to yet. when i do i’ll be sure to let you guys know.
but ive eaten here a few times on my lunch break from work and its really not bad. i’ll probably eat there again sometime. i mean, they always have a mets or yankees game on during the day, people that work here aren’t mean, but aren’t overly nice. just a regular pizza shop vibe. 3 stars only because it’s good pizza, but it’s just pizza. don’t drive to hicksville just for this pizza is what i’m trying to say.