Mulligan’s Tavern

Been there 10 times since my crappy review. Staff has done a 180. Mistakes are a minimum, fast service. Menu still needs shaking more often-​but i am nitpicking. Credit to the night manager who checks orders against receipt. Guys keep it up.

Fantastic food. Good prices. Very cozy atmosphere. A great neighborhood pub that will surely become a regular stop. The wings are out of this world!

Not too happy about this place tonight. Usually the service is good but tonight they were exceptionally busy. Reserved tables were everywhere empty or with one or two people. Nowhere to sit down so me and my teenage son sit down at the bar and wait. Fifteen minutes later a barmaid comes up and says we can’t sit here. Not even nice about it, sorry your day sucks too, you are in the service industry and if you want to continue being busy you better treat your customers better. Even the future ones

Second time into this place, second time with bad service and long wait for food. Food is nothing to rave about, most likely all frozen food. «All day specials» are only during the Browns game, obviously (refer to picture). Will never recommend this place, and won’t return.

Service was very slow. The place was empty. They had a board written with specials stating «During Game» and «All Day» I ordered a cheese pizza. Which should have been one of the specials being a two topping pizza. They charged me three dollars extra. And said that it was not part of the specials. That the specials were only for during the game. When I pointed at the sign that said clearly my cheese pizza should have been a special, being a «2topping pizza». The waitress argued with me, and denied the $ 3 price difference. See my picture of the specials board for example…

popped in for a nightcap. Nothing special about the place. Bar service was friendly. Older crowd.

Mulligans is overrated, with so-​so food and an impatient wait staff. I don’t know why locals hype it up so much, or waste their time here aside from the convenience of it’s location. I’ve heard enough bad stories to scare me away from this place for good.

So, let me just preface this review by saying apart from today I have never not tipped a waitress in my life. I know how undervalued wait staff are at any restaurant and am always aware of this when I tip. Today, was the only exception.
My fiancé and I came into Mulligan’s just to grab a couple of drinks; today was his birthday. I’ve been here on several occasions, both with family and friends and have had a decent-​ish time. Food and drinks are so-​so and atmosphere is typically alright.
Tonight from the moment we walked in our waitress seemed uninterested. The bar was basically empty apart from about five older men. We initially asked for waters before we checked out their drink menu only to be told (pretty rudely) that the kitchen is closed (we figured, it’s 11 at night.) She then carded us, so I assume she thought we were underage and just looking to get some food.
We didn’t really care, we were not really looking to chat with our waitress and even though I was a little annoyed with her attitude that she at least brought our drinks.
When it was time to leave we paid for the bill and decided not to tip. Tips intended to indicate that you enjoyed your service, and in this case we were so uncomfortable that we didn’t. We had initially planned on buying a couple more drinks but this sour waitress really made us feel unwelcome. We paid our $ 10.00 tab and went outside for a minute before we began to drive off.
Now, for the big kicker.
We had been outside maybe 30 seconds, we tried to hold the door open for the manager (I presume) who was holding a few patio chairs before we got our car. The waitress then opened the bar door and says rather loudly – she must not have assumed we were standing there:
«THOSE RAT ASS KIDS DIDN’T EVEN TIP!»
We stood in shock for a moment, expecting that the manager would call her out on it. She did not. How can you have so little respect for your customers? I shouted out to the manager saying «We are those rat ass kids then, I guess?»
I misheard the waitress initially. I only know this because the manger corrected her. «She said brat ass not rat ass.» then sat down to smoke and chat on her cellphone like nothing had happened.
I never thought I’d feel relieved for not tipping someone. To be that rude over what would typically be about a $ 2.00 tip, can you imagine what they’d be like if we had actually been doing something wrong?
This whole establishment needs an attitude change. We, along with our family and friends will definitely not be coming back. I’d suggest anyone on the fence about coming in to save your money and go to an establishment where they value customers.

They seem like really nice people and it looks like it has a fun bar crowd, but our meal was just so-​so. We may have ordered poorly, but the meals were not great. My husband liked his burger, but I ordered the Pub Melt and it was really bland. My daughter ordered chicken fingers and I tried them when I didn’t like my Pub Melt and they were just average. The pretzel appetizer was good, but the cheese was kind of gross. It seemed like it had been sitting out for a while.

Good beer selection, like Harps. Good skins, bad Pastrami fried patties. Great service. Nice local Tavern though I’m from CA.

There are certain places that go unnoticed to some. Every time I have eaten here it has been a great meal. Great pub food ! The beer selection is amazing. Everything I love in a restaurant. Mulligans is tucked into a residential area and should be on everyone’s radar for tasty food and beverages.

I go to Mulligan’s on a fairly often basis, generally for lunch. It’s the best pub menu in the area, hands down. Vegetarian and kids options, too.
I tried their new boneless wings the last time and enjoyed them. They’re big and meaty and don’t give you the impression that it’s leftover or rejected meat. Sauce selection isn’t large (compared to nearby wing places like BWs or Panini’s), but certainly plenty from which to choose.
As a burger eater, though, I’d be remiss to not mention their turkey burger. Add some pepper jack cheese and it’s the best I’ve ever had. The fries are delicious, too.

Greatest grilled cheese in 10 mile radius!
Pickles and food is always fresh and delivered within a decent amount of time– clean atmosphere– and the beer is always cold! Great corner bar– beats Harry buffalo down the street in a flash!

As good a pub grub as you are going to find in the Lyndhurst, Highland Heights, Mayfield area. The food here is always well above average and doesn’t have that processed feel and taste you’ll find in chains. The chicken fingers seem to be hand cut as do the fries. Service has been an issue with others. I’ve not had that problem. The atmosphere is relaxed, the drinks are cold, the food is good. It’s what you hope the bar in your neighborhood will be.

I had one of the top 10 burgers I’ve ever eaten there last week. The Smoky Ghost Burger is AMAZING! I had to knife and fork it because it was so big. At $ 9.50 it’s a STEAL! Next time I go out to Philips for training I know where I’m going for lunch. It’s only about 2 miles from the plant in.
On an interesting side note the Mayor and some of his legal staff were there for lunch as well meeting with a contractor. They were CHEAP tippers leaving only a $ 2 tip.

You can’t beat wing night! My husband and I got out of there with a $ 17 tab including beer. Love this place!

This place has an awesome chicken club sandwich. I get it almost every time, this isn’t your deli meat kind of club. My mom loves the wings and they have a great beer list too. A good local spot.

Had dinner here last night. Service was absolutely amazing! It may have been a different person every time, but there was always someone at our table if we needed anything! Food was ok, seemed frozen/​pre-​made. Good bar for a late night snack with great service and a good beer list.

The thing I like about Mulligan’s is that it’s consistent. Service is consistently good. Food is consistently better. And I consistently find myself at this watering hole all winter. My favorite night of the week to hang out at Mulligan’s is on Tuesdays, because they have bar trivia from 8 – 10 pm. Anyone in the bar can play, and with a bit of dumb luck, you can win a certificate good for beer, food, or other goodies.
This is my go to bar in the area. It’s definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for some above average bar food and great drinks.

Mulligans tavern is on of my all time favorite local bars. As the name implies it’s a sports bar. It get’s pretty busy on game days, but usually pretty casual and friendly. They have a nice selection of domestics as well as imports. This is a sports bar, not a cocktail bar however.
The food is really something I get at least once a week. The ruebens, turkey club, and burgers are all safe bets here. They also have real onion rings. In the summer they have outdoor seating which is always nice. I’ve personally been treated nicely by all the servers here.
This place will always be on the top of my list for food, and an occasional beer. The atmosphere is fantastic. Be aware though, this is bar food– but bar food at it’s best.