Paesano Pizzeria

New owner. Awful pizza that arrived more than an hour after promised cold with a hard crust, scant cheese and no flavor. When I spoke to the owner he was nasty and condescending: apparently the business has changed hands recently. I miss the kind former owner who made the most delicious grandma pies. I will be ordering elsewhere. What a loss!

Paisanos has great pizza and food can’t complain plus the new owner now is so nice and friendly the prices are fair I would go back again

Great to know that the new owner of this establishment is a crook. Stay away from a business like this and don’t feed the pockets of a thief did some work for this man at his home and changed the agreement last minute in order to avoid paying thousands of dollars

The owner actually came on the phone to make sure I was happy with my order! The pizza was great!

Watch out for new menu and new prices. Mario has sold the business. The new owner told me he couldn’t afford to maintain the same prices that Mario offered, especially his nightly specials. (The food wasn’t as good either!)

I’m giving Paesanos 2 stars mostly because of consistency… Idk even know what I give for taste. I have gotten the same dish here 3 times. Only got it because I LOVED it… literally had it once a week from J&J’s.but Paesanos is not J&J’s!!! Maybe it’s a family member or something… the dish I received tonight was something that would NEVER leave the kitchen at J&J’s. Nearly inedible. Also — my boyfriend ordered a chicken with prosciutto… it came with regular deli ham… EW!!! And our orders were supposed to come with salad and did not this time.
Like I said this is the 3^rd time I got it…1^st was very close to J&J’s (it was from the menu there) 2^nd… meh…3^rd inedible bare gross chicken. I’m so bummed bc I was so excited when I saw this dish (chicken bolognese) on the menu just like j*j’s…
pizza is good though

Came in here tonight after the gym to pick up one slice of pizza and ended up walking out with four! Ugh. Their specialty slices all looked so good I had to try 4 of them. It was a slow Sunday so all of the staff was hanging out on the dining room floor and they all happened to be super friendly and patient with me. Overall every slice of pizza I got was amazing, I can’t wait to go back and try the food!

Absolutely love Paesano’s… food is wonderful and a great value, and the owners Mario and Marie are genuinely great people. We have been going for several years and always leave happy and satisfied. Portions are generous and everything is made with care. I love the spaghetti with Garlic & Oil with Broccoli, but it’s hard to pick a favorite!

Only go here if you are prepared to go again and again and again. Way too addictive! Everything is great, but the grandmas’ pies should be illegal! My kids love the chicken parm dinner. If this man retires in 20 years, I will stalk him.

This place is great. I see that the negative reviews are from people far away from Huntington. This place is right up there with the top places in Huntington for pizza with Southdown Pizza and Little Vincents

I order two pies for my uncle and his crew of guys working on my house. One pie regular and one pie broccoli with extra cheese and the broccoli had water running on it. It was gross, I wouldn’t recomend to anyone.

Good pizza in Greenlawn is tough to find. This is an honest slice. Light airy, just the right amount of crisp. Not like the sloppy slices you find in the area that can’t support the weight of the cheese and sauce on top. It’s clear they put a little love in the product they put there name on, that’s all you can ask. I’d give 3.5 stars if i could, but they are nice to my kids when we come in, so bumping them to 4.

Best pizzas and salads in the Northport area. Excellent for pick ups and for having a nice family dinner. Sometimes very busy and loud but food is great. They use fresh ingredients.

if you were unlucky enough to miss this little place in a set back strip mall on the north side of main street, next to a funky cool pet store, it would be a shame. the pie is an excellent slice with a very nice sauce like you would get if you were in someone’s home. the owner is super friendly, so going there is like visiting, and it just has a very cool feel to it. stop in and stay or take it to go, this place is a must try.

Haven’t tried everything on the menu. Mostly just pizza. The regular slice is just okay, but the specialty slices are where this place excels. The stuffed buffalo chicken slice is great and usually nice and spicy (the way I like it). I think its called a stuffed paradise slice (or something like that), its like a hamburger but stuffed pizza style, its pretty awesome. The buffalo wings are good, crispy and fresh. Fresh stuffed canolis for $ 1!!! The place always seems clean, and the counter staff is real friendly.

As for their slices they are very crisp, medium thin and well sauced with good flavor. As for their food I have had take out from them about 5 – 6 times and for the most part everything I ordered was rather good. Their rigatoni Bologonese was different than what I’m used to but it was very good, with the exception of needing a little salt for my taste. As well on believe on Monday-​T-​W nights they have a $ 12 pasta special that comes with of course a main pasta, soup, salad and a fresh piece of bread! Score for a easy night in… Overall a good and easy spot to catch some good take out, or as well they have a small area to eat with about 6 booths.
And something that should be noted from a previous review…
” I can say that the owner was cool enough one night to make me a rice ball after they had run out, it was made fresh right that moment and was piping hot and full of goodness! Defiantly a place that will be in my regular repertoire of my weekly pizza fix.”