Brozinni Pizzeria

Very good. Our waitress was excellent! 6 out of 7 of our party had never been there. She brought us all knuckles to try… yum! Also have gluten free pizza. They don’t make there own crust but it passed my sons inspection. (They brought box out for him to read ingred.) 2 had calzones, 1 gluten free and 4 had the regular crust pizza. Would recommend this restaurant.

Was told this was the place for New York Style pizza and was not disappointed. This place has the small NY feel and the food was everything I was told to expect and maybe more.
Many choices of pizza toppings and choices of homemade sauces. We went with a ½ and ½ of the sunrise with chicken bacon and spinach but switched to Ranch as the sauce and the Canal which is similar to a supreme. A small is a large 16″ with generous toppings and an excellent hand tossed crust.
A must to start is the Garlic Knuckles. We mentioned it was our 1^st visit so they gave us an order on the house.
One of the best parts of the experience was the energy and cheerfulness of our waiter Riley who seemed eggar to help us on decision by telling us about the different pizza options and descriptions.

We got a take out order from here on Wednesday. The Gramma Pie Park Ave style, order of cheesy bread, and garlic knots. The pizza was good and the cheesy bread was good. My garlic knots, that I really looked forward too, were doughy and not in a good way. I pulled it apart and hoped maybe they started stuffing them with Mozzarella cheese that’s how raw the dough was. I’m not sure how that even happens, but I was extremely disappointed didn’t call and complain because I will never be back.

I would like to submit Brozinnis to the list of best pizza places in Marion county (just barely north of county line). I would place it above Bazbeaux, Jiacamos, Pizzology etc. This place is great.
Let’s start with the pizza. New York-​style with an incredible fluffy yeasty crust. Perfectly seasoned. Tons of signature pizzas, and all are great. My favorite is the 34^th street. Ricotta cheese, basil, and garlic on their incredible crust. And the leftovers are great too.
Next, appetizers. The «knuckles» are super addicting and incredible… Basically they are little garlicky breadsticks that are just perfect. You could probably make a meal just out of these… So have some self control and save room. Next, their salad selection is good, and they have several great dressings that are made in house. I like their Italian dressing but to each their own here.
They have a pretty good beer selection too. Several local breweries on tap (oaken barrel, sun king, fountain square etc) and more.
The owners/​managers are super friendly, and the air staff is great too!
So take a drive down to the south side, head to Brozinnis, and enjoy some of the best pizza in town!

If u like New York style pizza than this is your place!!! Came here as soon as I landed and the hospitality was AWESOME. They walked us through the menu and for being a first time customer got some free garlic knuckles which were the best I’ve ever had. I had chicken Alfredo 2 slices of pizza and the knuckles too much food but enough food for later. If you ever visit Indy the reviews are accurate! Awesome Food! Awesome service for a reasonable price! BBQ chicken pizza and knuckles must try!!! Calzones will put u too sleep by the sheer size.

Awesome. Stayed in Greenwood for work and saw it was nearby. Being originally from New York, I have never appreciated a Chicago style pizza. Glad to have a huge New York style any time. Yummy, sweet, and delicately complex sauce. Fresh mushrooms. So good. My only complaint is that I could only eat three of the eight slices before I grew comatose. The service was very pleasant on the phone and when I picked it up, even though they were closing. Would definitely have again.

This is a review on take-​out.
—
LOVE that they have whole other counter for pick-​ups. Called in and my pizza was piping hot and ready to go once I go there. Great selection of pizzas. If you are in the mood for a NY style pizza, great place to go. Desserts were a miss for me but the salads were decent so that made up for it I guess.
Food: ⁴⁄₅
Service: ³⁄₅
Place: ³⁄₅

This place is fantastic! We have tried several of the pizzas so far and while their dining area is a great experience their carry out is just as lovely. We ordered a pizza and breadsticks last night. They always open the box and show you the pizza before you leave. Just to make sure you’re satisfied (it looked like a pizza made by gods) and then even gave me paper plates and napkins. I have had fast and exceptionally friendly service every time that I go and can easily say that this is my favorite pizza place. Thanks to their staff for doing things right!!!

Being from NY, I was excited to try this place. I am happy to say it was pretty good. There were misses but over all I really enjoyed it and will be back.
Here are the details. We ordered take out but the interior was a cute pizza joint. Nothing fancy but well done. I really liked the vintage NY pics on the wall and even their pen holder had a NY theme. While checking out I did notice a great local beer selection on tap!
We ordered a calzone, a slice, house salad and a meatball. Our bill was $ 20.
The food: the flavor was good. Tastes like they use quality, fresh ingredients. The calzone was big enough for two. The inside was slightly under cooked and there were sections that were raw dough. That was a bummer but I have to tell you, it was so tasty and big — I didn’t mind too much. The salad was super fresh and full of leafy greens. No plastic bag salad mix here! The bite I had of the slice was delicious. Great garlic flavor. Nice amount of cheese and great crust. The meatball was a little salty for me but good.
The staff was friendly and helpful. She went through my entire order showing me each piece before I left. I really appreciate that kind of effort for a take our order.
It’s a quick and easy drive down 65 south for me so I know I will be back and soon! Check them out when you are in the mood for some stellar flavored pizzeria eats!

Love the pizza here! The box is huge, the toppings plentiful and the crust so soft. Usually not a huge fan of the crust on pizza, but this is good. The garlic Knuckles are also amazing. I wish it was closer for us, but worth a trip for the knuckles alone. I wish the food truck would be out around town more.

Love this place! It has a very Italian-​y feel inside. (Yes thats a word look it up… hahah i cant believe you looked it up, its totally not a word) Anyways, its great, they have ton of pizzas (creative ones too) that are being cooked all the time. From there you can just buy by the (HUGE) slice.
Once you order you can go sit down and they bring the food to you, very cool.
If you are in the Greenwood area this place is a MUST Try! Im from Chicago so I know pizza, Im also very humble that’s another great quality of mine.

My huge issue with this place is it’s way way too far from my house! Maybe that is a good thing though because I am obsessed with the Garlic knuckles. They are sooooo good, I dare say the best I have had in my entire life. They are yeasty and soft and they melt in your mouth. They have garlic butter and fresh garlic on them and for $ 5 you get a huge box of 8. On our last trip down I got an extra box and we kept them in the fridge for 2 nights. I reheated them in the oven and they were perfect. To go orders get a dish of the butter and garlic so they weren’t soggy. I first had them at the Monon Center’s adult only night at the water park.
We got the 20′ Canal Street and it was huge. The box is just massive. It was wall to wall toppings of sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, black olives, onion & green peppers. There were 4 adults and we ate all but one piece.
we’ve also had the calzones on our first trip and they are really good too.
I hope we see the truck out and about. I did notice that this summer they put it’s location on the FB page where last year I didn’t see that. I know I would try to visit it when it’s on the north-​side.

They have a food truck! I ordered a cheese slice — it was really good, NY style!

Not a huge pizza fan but I enjoyed it here. Their slice is huge so I’d say 1 slice (around $ 3.5) should be good enough for lunch. If it’s your first time, they give you their popular appetizer and that’s really good too.

My sister and I stopped in here in our way home from shopping for the first time today. We were greeted with smiles and free garlic knuckles (yay!) our waitress was very friendly and helpful about the menu. I love that they have pizza by the slice we wanted to try them all. I settled on the canal and the Brooklyn-​Queens and my sister had the 34^th street. The kids had pepperoni. The slices are HUGE. The toppings are pretty good. We had lots of pizza left over to take home. We both got the cannoli for dessert. Scrumptious!
Overall this is a great place for pizza. I know everyone is crazy about the knuckles but for me there was just way too much butter and I’m a butter lover. They were still good though. We will definitely go back.
On a side note I LOVE the music they play. It was all 80’s on our Sunday afternoon visit. They also have TV’s for the guys.

Even though I’m a born and bred Chicagoan I’ve never bought into the whole thick crust pizza thing even when it was booming in the 70’s. Nah give me NY style pie any day of the week, thin crust, slightly charred on the bottom, loaded with animal carcass and cheese. Fuggedaboutit. So it was that I decided to stop into Brozinni pizzeria with the 2 yutes I had with me.
Got in around 1 and the place was not overly busy, pizza by the slice from 11 – 4, my kind of joint. Passed on the free knuckles cuz after all it’s bread, sorry if I’m eating carbs it’s gotta be the pie.
We all ordered different slices since I wanted to try all 3, the broadway, canal st, and 34^th st. Yowza, this cat knows what he’s doing. Most authentic NY style pie I’ve had since Little Italy. Girls ate some, Dad wound up eating the rest, I think I ate enough carbs for 3 days now.
Owner is on premise and feels you out, nice guy, attentive to his craft, not necessarily cheap by the slice but the pie really is first class. Will get a whole pizza next time after I come out of my carb coma, grazie tante Brozinni!

Brozzini’s has good pizza and side items on the menu. The garlic knuckles/​knots are decent, and the salads are decent too. My son enjoyed his chicken Parmesan.
The pizza is impressively presented at your table in grand style on a pedestal. You get quite a bit pizza for the money which is always a good thing.
The crust, sauce and other ingredients/​toppings are fresh and of a good quality.
I think it is some of the better pizza offered on the south side. I think pound for pound, it competes with Jockamo’s, but I still think Jockamos edges Brozzini’s out.
The restaurant has a bare bones atmosphere,…but that’s OK, because you are there for the pizza. ;o).
It can tend to get loud in there, but that is primarily due to the fact that the place is very popular and always packed with people — especially on the weekends.
The service was adequate and friendly.

This was my second visit to Brozinni’s and it definitely won’t be my last. The garlic knuckles are delicious and the pizza is too. I would consider ordering just garlic knuckles if it weren’t for how good the pizza tasted.
The garlic knuckles are delicious and have just the right amount of chewiness to them, cooked to perfection. The knuckles sit in a bath of butter, garlic, and parmesan cheese. And it’s difficult to limit yourself to the number of knuckles you eat, but you have to save room for the pizza!
The pizza, if you order the largest size, is very large! I would even say that a single slice of pizza on the largest size is about the size of two pieces of Papa John’s pizza smashed together. One of the things I like best about Brozinni’s pizza is that the crust under the sauce and toppings is relatively thin, but the crust around the edge is nice and fluffy.
The restaurant had New York style theming and a typical pizzeria feel. We sat near the kitchen and could hear the hustle and bustle of the kitchen, but it was still relatively quiet. Our waitress was friendly and checked in on us throughout our dining experience. Overall, it was a great experience and I can’t wait to go back and enjoy more of their pizza.

I was fortunate enough to recently have some pizza and knots from here recently.
While I can’t speak for the location, as I haven’t been there… The pizza was delicious.
Ok, I can’t lie, the knots were great too.
I’ll probably have more to say once I’ve been to the place… I will say it’s more likely to happen sooner than it would have had I not been blessed with a lunch from here.

This place would get more stars if allowed!!! I saw them on the local television station and decided to give them a try. The nice thing about this place is it’s a nice homey feel type of place. Your first time there you tell them it’s your first time and you get garlic knots for free an order of 4. The garlic knots are amazing! I am yet to find any that can measure up to these delightful things. The are baked to perfection then olive oil garlic and Parmesan cheese top them. My mouth is watering just thinking about them! The pizza is fresh tasting and some of the best ive had, the chicken Alfredo is creamy and flavorful and a must try. The staff is friendly and attentive which goes a long way with me. Every time i visit Indy Its a must stop.