O’Reilly’s Irish Bar & Restaurant

The wait staff were too busy with their phone, friends and television to seat us, bring us drinks, or even take our order. We should have followed our instinct and left after our initial experience because the food was a serious letdown. The portions were small and the flavor was rivaled by a Banquet TV dinner. Would not recommend this to anyone.

Ate here twice for lunch. Both times had the buffalo wrap (could use more chicken in it) very good. Lunch specials are good sized and priced well! $ 7 and some change includes soda. Clean (it is new though) so far nice servers and nice looking set up.

Went here for breakfast on Sunday and was not impressed with the food. Eggs were cold and amount small for saying it was three eggs. Bacon was spicy and very over done. Rye toast had powdered sugar because they thought it was to be french toast and hash browns were lukewarm and mushy. We have been here for lunch and had shepherds pie and the fish and chips which were good. The bread pudding was also very tasty. Would not go here for breakfast again.

Food was good and drink prices are in line, atmosphere was very nice and not so loud. Tv’s everywhere!
The waitress was rushing us even though there was empty tables. We bought not only a full meals but 6 drinks and we still felt rushed. I’m not holding my rating against the pub. Employee problem not pub.
The manager and or owner was helping out on the floor and he was very good with service making sure everybody was having a good time. We will be back!

Dave, the late night bartender is awesome. He is very intuitive in regards to your service needs. His best quality is that he anticipates your next move. He doesn’t miss a beat. If you are ready for your check he has you ready. One of the best bartenders on the south side.

After seeing this new bar pop up I had to try it. It did not disappoint. The actual building and décor is awesome. The place seems clean, the staff was very attentive and pleasant, actually played some Irish themed music etc.
The menu was not exactly Irish style specific, but it has a nice variety of things like the Fish & Chips. (Check photos for pics of menus!)
Lots of TVs, and the bar has lots of cool seating. I’ll back here for sure!
–Torrey
**Check out my pics of the menu**

Well have to start out that the food was amazing! Waitress was wonderful thanks Melissa! BUT When my son starting eating the buffalo dip which was an appetizer (he was still hunger after his dinner) there was a BOLT in his chips!!!
A freaking tool part! A BOLT! We had already paid our bill so our waitress asked if we wanted some on the house desserts which we did take but seriously!!! A bolt in our appetizer… They said it was from all the construction which I guess is understandable but if that is the case don’t serve food if that is a possibility. I might go back again to play Russian Roulette.

We stopped for a late Saturday lunch. At last, a place that seems like a neighborhood bar. I can’t put my finger on why, but maybe it was the layout, or the décor, the bar itself or the people. Anyway, there was a decent size crowd for Saturday at 2pm. There is also a family area, completely separated from the bar with one pool table, some games and individual TVs in each booth. Yay! Not that I don’t like families but one should be able to enjoy a bar atmosphere without distractions. Lots of TVs. All at least 50 inches and in both areas. We sat at the bar and were served by a friendly David. My only complaint is that the bar had a bar top rail, which makes it hard to get to your food. Many bars have this and I wish they didn’t. It’s awkward. Of course, we could have sat at a table, but we prefer the bar. I had a Guinness and the Veggie Burger with Slaw. The burger was great and I spiced up the slaw with a little hot sauce. My wife had a huge Tenderloin with Fries, which she liked. The prices were reasonable. They were building a patio while we were there. We will definitely return.

We had an absolute blast here.
While the wait staff is still learning the menu, the food and atmosphere made it a perfect addition to the South side.
We ordered off the beer menu only to notice upon delivery that most of the beers listed are bottled. So not a big deal, but be advised.
We started off with a huge plate of Irish Nachos. The corned beef was unexplainable but seriously delicious. Even my boyfriend, the healthiest of healthiest wanted a taste and approved!
I ordered the Salmon Bacon Avocado Ranch sandwich. It came on a soft Hawiian bun that was a perfect compliment. The salmon was slightly overdone, but still flakey and the bacon added the perfect hint of flavor and texture.
Around the table, it was noted the burger and Reuben were also quite good.
We happened to be there when there was whiskey tasting and they hit our table twice. Again we had an absolute blast and will surely be going back when we are on the south side next!

Great new addition to the Southside. Pub Food, and full bar in a cozy setting on one side and family dining and games on the other. The staff is new but you would never know it. Friendly and knowledgable just like their downtown location.

Have eaten lunch and dinner there this week. The restaurant is very well-​appointed and a great atmosphere. The staff is friendly and the manager visits tables to welcome new customers. We live very close to this new location and will definitely be back often.

Nice addition to the area. My wife and I went recently. She enjoyed the shepherds pie. I liked the beef stew, but a little less enthusiastically. My wife had an ice tea which she rated 2 tea stars. I could picture a catfish poking his head through the murky tea water. I enjoyed the Jameson special of the night. It was weak, but what do you expect for a $ 3 drink. We’ll go back again if for no other reason than the convenience

Glad to have a new watering hole on the southside. O’Reilly’s is perfect for a local pub with quality Irish & American bar fare. The pulled, bbq chicken egg roll is an excellent app that I will be getting again. The salmon sandwich was cooked perfectly with great flavors and textures. Didn’t fall apart and had a lovely pretzel bun. The steamed veggies were flawless. The salads look huge, possibly too big for one hungry soul. Although I did not have the fish and chips they looked to be a big massive mound of fried deliciousness. They have the same common beers on tap that you see in the majority of bars/​restaurants around Indy. My only complaint would be to have a printed list of the actual name of the beers instead of just «scarlet lane rotator, mashcraft rotator» Overall it’s a solid addition to the area and I will be sure to go back soon. A nice little bar crawl could develop between O’Reilly’s, Mashcraft Brewing, and Hops & Fire. Cheers!

This pace was awesome will come back shepherds pie is excellent plenty of beer choices and the tai shrimp is very good for an app. The place is child friendly also