Sweet Tooth Bakery

I set foot into the store and the lady was too busy taking a wedding cake order. It was clear that point that I had to scram from the store ASAP. Our wedding cakes get us more moolah as compared to folks who come here to redeem their coupons.
Poor selection and moreover poor quality of the cake itself. The chocolate leaves a bad after taste. The frosting is no better. The second one was only slightly better.
Never has the task of finishing 4 more cupcakes seemed as daunting! I guess that speaks for itself!

Mmm… had the most delicious cupcakes from here for Valentine’s Day! Red velvet dipped in chocolate with cream cheese icing. They were divine! A little pricey at $ 2.50 a cupcake, but worth it for a special treat!
The interior of the bakery isn’t very impressive. I definitely think they could make better use of the space and do more to give it a greater appeal to passersby. However, the service was friendly and the cupcakes were very tasty so no complaints from me! :)

I had a big family event that I wanted to buy cupcakes for so I stopped in Sweet Tooth Bakery a few days prior to my dinner and asked how I should go about making sure I could have the large quantity I wanted on the day I needed them. I was told to stop by the afternoon of my event (and we discussed specifically which day that was), after 2:00, to get the best variety. I did just that and they were closed. Stated hours indicated they should be open. Business owner was called and she said it was slow day due to holiday season so she closed early… and was very unpleasant about it. I counted on them, did what they told me to do and had no dessert for my dinner. I will NEVER go to this establishment again… not a good way to run a business!!!

I came here and used my living social coupon. I must have had bad timing because the woman I spoke with said they had been so busy they were out of most everything and were having to bake up more cupcakes. My problem was that I couldn’t come back later so had to choose from what was available. My favorite cupcakes are always the filled but she was out of those. Instead I had the red velvet, snickerdoodle, butter cake, and I think the last one was a crème brûlée? The butter cake was my favorite hands down. It was the most moist and had great frosting. The crème brûlée was a little dry although also had good frosting. The red velvet was ho-​hum. The snickerdoodle surprised me that it tasted exactly like the cookie.
I would probably return to try a different set of cupcakes but as others have said, wouldn’t stay to eat them due to the lacking ambiance and tables but would take them home to enjoy.

I had an if-​y time here. I was lead to believe they opened at 9am on a Saturday and apparently they open at 10, so I was 30 mins early. No biggie, I just took a cruise down Mass Ave to do a little shopping while I waited. When I returned 40 mins later, nothing looked any different. No lights and no open sign. A cupcake ghost town inside. I tried the door anyway and I guess this is just the ambiance they are going for b/​c the door was unlocked. I must have disrupted the woman’s computer time b/​c she seemed less than pleased that I was there, offering no «Hello» or anything upon my arrival. I initiated conversation and received barely anything in return. I wasn’t expecting an in depth convo about each cupcake on display. When I mentioned that I was getting some for my sister’s birthday and she liked chocolate, I thought perhaps I would get some suggestions. «These chocolate, chocolate chip are great» or «I really like the red velvet.» Something. Anything. Sell me some freakin cupcakes! My sister said they are really good, but I don’t know about coming back when I know of 2 other cupcake locations with friendly enthusiastic employees and/​or owners.

I first visited this Bakery after purchasing a $ 30.00 LivingSocial voucher for $ 15.00.
When I first walked in, I was taken slightly aback. The atmosphere is slightly dark and uninviting, with hardly any seating.
However, the cupcakes are very delicious — and sized much more appropriately than the other cupcake shop on Mass Ave. Each cupcake is traditionally sized — not monster sized — perfect for calorie-​minded Hoosiers.
I have had the Snicker doodle cupcake, the Red Velvet cupcake, Raspberry cupcake, and the Double Chocolate, to name a few. The Red Velvet was the standout — fluffy and delicious cupcake, dipped in chocolate, and topped with a sweet cream cheese frosting. The chocolate dip makes this cupcake stand out from the pack and is a unique twist on a cupacke.
Not to be missed are Sweet Tooth’s cookie sandwiches. The double-​chocolate sandwich cookie filled with peanut butter buttercream frosting and dipped in chocolate chips was absolutely heavenly — it is so rich that I would recommend splitting it with a friend. The chocolate chip cookie sandwich filled with traditional buttercream was just as delicious, but not quite as sweet or filling as the chocolate peanut butter variety.
They have a cupcake happy hour on Thursday afternoons — I would highly recommend checking this out for delicious $ 1.00 cupcakes.
While it isn’t as cute as a shop as «the other» cupcake eatery on Mass Ave, the people are friendly, the cupcakes are affordable and reasonably sized, and the delicious cookies offer an interesting and different variety of sweet. If not for the somewhat lackluster ambiance and decorations, they would have earned 5 stars.

Yummy cupcakes. I had the lemon with buttercream and a vanilla with oreo cupcakes. My husband had a butterfinger and a snickerdoodle cupcake. All were great. I think they made a smart move being open on Sundays when the other cupcake shop on Mass is not.
My only (minor) complaint is a lack of tables. There is one. I’m sure it’s a good place to pick up and take home some yummy cupcakes, but my husband and I were looking to kill a few minutes between plays. It would have been nice to sit and do so. I know it’s a small place, but maybe a couple of small tables instead of the one large might be a good idea.