Titus Tavern

Highly don’t recommend this restaurant, not a good experience at all! Where to start, first off we ordered all of our food and the waitress decided to use her memory rather than a pen and pad which proved to be a mistake. When we finally got our food 27 minutes later she had forgotten one of our meals, she had to ask us what she missed and go reorder it. That took 12 minutes to get that meal by that time most of us were already done eating. During our whole sit down there I rarely saw our waitress and when I did I would ask her for a refill and she would forget about it. When we were done eating she never came over and brought the check to the table I had to go over to the bar area and flag her down. When I got the check I was overcharged, it really was not a problem getting it fixed but it was another annoyance! So after all of this how was the food? Well honestly not good at all, none of the food is actually prepared at the tavern. The meats come from the deli next door and I believe the pizza comes from Two Ton Tony’s down the street.

Exactly what I-​town needed! A small, simple and personal bar. Great selection and decent pricing. The front deck is perfect for muggy nights and its smack dab in the middle of residential irondeqouit. I knew of John (the owner) way before he built this bar and he’s a genuine guy. He always complained of the lack of neighborhood bars; so he went and opened his own. Love the drinks, love the location and love the look! Definitely worth a drink or two :-)

Great bar, good prices and friendly bartenders.
No food, but you can order from Cooper Deli and Two Ton Tony’s.

Great place. stopped in Fathers Day for the first time. Easy parking right next to the tavern. Great front deck if you want to sit outside and the tavern is warn and cozy. Decent selection of meals and finger foods either at the bar or table. The staff were great, friendly and fast with service on a busy day. Seems like a great place and will not drive by any more !

Great new towny bar. I like the style and design, like the front porch with the modern bonfire and the beer selection. If u want food sometimes u have to stop next door at the cooper deli or most days/​hours u can order from the menu that comes from the same place. Great place to save a seat for the 4^th of July parade. Don’t like how it gets so noisy and crowded on the busy nights

Surprisingly loud for an early Tuesday, and the bar only being half full. The wait staff was friendly and attentive. Around 7:00 a live acoustic set came on and the place got so loud you couldn’t hear the person next to you talk. Cover tunes and what not were belted by a good voice. Plenty of t.v.‘s for sportish viewing.

Love this cozy new pub at the corner of Titus and Cooper in the heart of Irondequoit. The owners John and Bucky did a wonderful job finishing it out with hunter green walls and dark wood, a beautiful fireplace, and a gorgeous wood bar that is perfect height and depth for bellying up for beer and conversation with your better half or your wing man. They have a limited menu of sandwiches provided by the Cooper DelI next door. I did not try the food, but Cooper DelI has long been know for its sandwiches, and I have eaten there and enjoyed the food on several occasions. But this is a great place to watch a game or just catch up with an old friend. The walls are lined with Irondequoit memorabilia from days gone by, a lacrosse stick hangs proudly over the fireplace.
Young girlfriends sipping wine, a table of older women, and several other mixed groups were enjoying the atmosphere here on a cold Thursday night in March. They have a nice mix of local and well known drafts available including Dogfish Head, Ithaca Cascazilla (a personal favorite) and Guinness to name just a few, and reasonably priced at $ 4.50 pint. They also have a respectable wine selection, and I noticed that the red wine was served in nice oversize wine glasses which many will appreciate. Music is not too loud and allows for easy conversation. Bathrooms are clean and well maintained… it’s a great little spot that was sorely needed in Irondequoit, a nicer, more upscale alternative to the grittier neighbor Murph’s across the street. Titus Tavern has the charm and warmth that were sorely lacking in the cavernous and short lived Copper Grill around the corner.
Parking is a bit challenging with just a small lot for about 20 cars, but it is not a large place so not too much of a challenge. I will hold off one star til I’ve tried some of the food, but this place is most definitely worth a visit, especially if you’re in the Irondequoit area. And it is an easy walk for many Irondequoit residents. The owner John can usually be found on premises and is always happy to strike up a conversation. Check it out sometime.

My husband and I stopped in on a Thursday night for dinner and a drink. The room was packed, with a mix of ages. The food menu is fairly limited, but it was all prepared at Cooper Deli next door, which is always good. We ordered wraps and sandwiches, and they were very tasty and quick.
The parking lot is tiny, so you’ll probably need to park at the bank across the street. As the other reviewer said, it’s definitely noisy in there, so it’s hard to carry on much of a conversation. On the other hand, it’s nice to see a place attracting a crowd after just a short time in busy, and better to be a little noisy than silent from a lack of customers. It’s a small place inside, so it fills up fast.

This is a new bar that has opened in what is the closest approximation of a downtown area for sprawling Irondequoit, right on the corner of Cooper and Titus. The parking can be a bit of a hassle, as there is a tiny side lot that is shared with a local deli, but plenty of parking is available across the street on Cooper in the bank lot (which I am told is fine for parking after hours).
My date and I went on a Wednesday night and the place was packed. The interior is finished nicely, with a large bar dominating one side of the room and low and high tables throughout. Like all modern neighborhood bars, the blaring music makes conversation less than a shout difficult. We saw a wide range of customers, from older couples to young professionals and everyone in between. The waitstaff was friendly and attentive, though my date and I didn’t stay for more than one drink. Food is available to order in from the next door deli.
I am ashamed to say that nothing in particular stood out about my experience, other than the loud music. This is a new establishment, so I’ll probably give them at least one more try. As many of the locals told me, «It’s a good alternative to Murph’s.»