Ned’s Pizza

NY Pizzeria is truly life changing, but if you don’t want to go al the way to Trumansburg, Neds is the best pizza in Ithaca, by far. Tastes the most like a real NY slice. Decent middle eastern bites as well. Only thing wrong with Neds is that when they get too busy they simply don’t pick up the phone. Maybe get an answering machine — just out of politeness — that says «we’re not taking orders at the moment, sorry for the inconvenience!»

Love the neighborhood vibe, full of local families. The pizza is really variable, sometimes it is 4 star and sometimes it is 2 stars. I feel like it is a pizza lottery.

Ned’s is fantastic. Very clean, fine quality of food, quick service. Ned has a great team of workers who keep the food flying out.
I work next door to Ned’s and have become well acquainted; I eat there at least twice a week every week. They’re totally consistent! I am totally hooked on the crust! When I have my grandson with me, they cut the pizza into little pieces for him.
Love it!

We ordered food from here when we were staying at a hotel nearby. We originally wanted to get delivery, but had to opt for pick-​up. Here is why. Although they say they deliver, when we called (from very close by), they said they didn’t deliver on Sundays, then they implied that they only deliver to Cornell. However, when pressed because we were even closer to them than Cornell, the person who answered the phone said that the owner does the deliveries and when the owner decides not to come in, there are no deliveries. We got the impression this happens randomly, likely every week. I find this a tad bit lazy (just hire a delivery driver!) and also misleading. If your website says you deliver, you should deliver! This is why they get three stars and not higher.
The food, however (once we picked it up), was really good! We got a pizza with extra cheese, a side salad, and chicken tenders. Everything was cooked well. The pizza cheese, sauce, and crust were so delicious. The chicken tenders had a light breading, and the chicken was not overcooked (a problem I’ve had at other places). The salad was fresh but nothing amazing.
Overall, I might order from here again if we were close by, but not if we wanted delivery.

This is one of my most fav pizza house so far in Ithaca, I feel like, I lived here long time but just discovered this place by accident. But very impressed in the end.
I like their pizza, they are really paid attention to make pizza, you can see and tell from the ingredient and how well their prepared.
I like all kind of pizza, sphaghetti, chicken wings and gyoros are what I recommended.
All staffs are very nice, cool and friendly. So far I went back and recommended to everyone.
I try to ordered for take out one time, but they did not do take out, then we had to droved to pick up instead, but we’re fine with that. Yummie!

Excellent NY style thin crust pizza, especially for the price. Tasty thin crust and juicy wings. Great place!

Ned seems like a pretty cool guy – he answered the phone and took our order for take-​out. We got there about six minutes after the time he quoted us. «You’re late!» he teased… or maybe he wasn’t teasing? It was dead-​pan, but we took it well.
Since we took it to go, I can’t comment much on anything else but the pizza itself: damn good NYC style pizza that left us wishing we had ordered a second pie, just so we could taste more of it. We got a basic cheese and it was absolutely perfect.
Just, y’know, don’t keep Ned waiting. The food’s worth burning the roof of your mouth on scalding hot cheese for.

I agree with other reviewers — you’ll love the atmosphere and staff. Ned is extremely friendly and everyone works really hard. The pizza is good and I would recommend trying the buffalo chicken salad or a chicken Caesar salad — both are excellent and healthy!

Just walking into Ned’s will make you smile when the owner greets you. The pizzas are very fresh and delicious. The place is very clean and bright. Enjoy the dialog the owner has taking orders over the phone as well as with walk ins — it could be a sitcom episode. Nice spot for a pizza!

Just stopped in at Neds for the first time. We kept it simple and tried a half cheese and pepperoni pie and it was very good! It’s in a nice little area and the employee at the counter was very nice! We will def be back!

Very good! The pizza is tasty with a great crust and fresh toppings. We tried a margarita pizza and it was very well made with fresh cheeses and sliced tomato. We also tried the hot wings, and I thought they were quite good. They are a little dry but I thought they went well with the celery and dipping sauce. They were probably mild-​to-​medium, not hot, even though I ordered the hottest available.
I really dug the owner. He’s quite friendly and interesting to talk to if he’s not too busy. I did takeout for my order but I saw two delivery vehicles in the parking lot, so that should be an option if you don’t want to deal with the Hanshaw construction nightmare.

Closest thing to NYC pizza in Ithaca. It’s a cute place for lunch, w great hot subs and specials.

This is my favorite pizza place. The pizza selection is large for walk-​in orders. Slices are reheated in the oven and develop a nice crunchy crust as a result. Even if you get the last slice of a pizza that has been out for a while it tastes really great. Of course super fresh slices are a lot better. Price is not bad. 2 cheese slices and a drink is $ 4.50 and 2 specialty slices and a drink is $ 5.50. There is seating for those that want to eat-​in. Tables are always clean and there are a decent number of them. As far as the pizza goes, the fresh taste paired with the crisp crust make Ned’s my favorite pizza place. The owner is also a super charismatic man that makes your whole experience a little bit brighter!

As far as pizza goes, in my opinion, Ned’s is the best in town. I especially like the Lebanese Cheese, its a nice change from regular orders like pepperoni. I will not comment on their chicken wings, however, as I have really high standards in that department.

I stopped in after seeing Ned’s on Unilocal.I can imagine that Ned’s has the best pizza in Ithica, but if you are not from Ithica, you might want a little more. I will concur with others that it was cheap and convenient. I had a slice of pizza, a soda, and some wings for only $ 11. The pizza might have been slightly old, but it was what I expected. The wings were on the drier side, but I thought they were better than I expected.

The pizza is great. Thin crispy crust and a large variety of toppings for the walk-​in by-​the-​slice customer. My favorite pizza in town.

I am a pizza kind of guy. Love pizza. I have even had pizza in Naples Italy!
Ned’s Pizza is the best tasting pizza in Ithaca. I have tried just about all other places. Great crust, wide selection and reasonable pricing.

The pizza is very good, it has a nicely charred thin crust and the toppings are quite fresh. They also have many good deals all day long, including, 2 cheese slices 6 wings and a soda for $ 7, make them gourmet slices for $ 8, or ditch the wings for $ 5. I would highly recommend them for lunch but for dinner their slices get kind of stale. Their wings are also not very good, dry and tough as far as wings are concerned.
A lot of my lady friends go here after they get their hair done at the salon next door. I guess nothing goes with a classy hairdo like a slice of greasy pizza and a coke ;). What a day of indulgence right, forget the spa go to Ned’s.

Ned’s Pizza is one of my favorite restaurants in Ithaca. Their lunch specials are AMAZING (2 slices and a drink for $ 5!). I love their eggplant parmigiana pizza with the slices of fluffy fresh mozzarella on it. Their pizzas are exceptional and you can tell that they put a lot of love into making pizza.