Dominic’s Pizza

I like their pizza its good, closer to NY style which we like. A bit pricey though, reason for just 4 stars.

Delicious pizza that’s good even when cold or room temperature.
Tips/​Suggestions for the business:
–X-​Large Pizza Price different on Homepage and Order Page;
–Please do not require me to select a topping, when I select your $ 19.99 X-​Large 1-​Topping Pizza Deal. Your order page makes selecting a topping mandatory. This is outside of typical business practice for pizza restaurants;

Really great pizza! The are very prompt in their delivery and every time I pick up my order the staff is always very friendly

Best pizza place around! We love their Super Special. My only complaint is the attitude of the high school kids that work there but it’s totally worth it for delicious pizza. We order from here 2 or 3 times a month and their pizza never disappoints.

I’m originally from Hempstead Long Island New York and consider myself an expert on Pizza. I have ordered at least 20 times now and have never had an issue.
I live in the sticks (Milliken) and they get the Pizza to me quick and they are competitive with the Big chains on price. I mean 2 Large Pizzas delivered and even with tip it came to under 20 bucks?
The pizza’s taste good and that is all that counts with me. The only place up here in my opinion with better pizza is Old Chicago’s and have you priced out 2 large pizza’s there? Ill give you a hint, its not cheap. Angelo’s Brooklyn/​Italian Deli had good Pizza also but Angelo passed away and they closed so… Ill take Dominics any day of the week out here versus the other Big Pizza Chains.
Someone gave these guys a bad review because they wont drive somewhere besides your home to meet you? Really?
Good job Dominics. 330 S in Milliken:)

We enjoyed Dominic’s pizza for several years, but as of tonight have decided never to order again. We apparently live ONE mile outside of their delivery zone — at first they would deliver since we said we enjoyed their pizza and would be repeat customers (which we have been). Then, we had to start driving to a location within their delivery area to meet a driver.
As of tonight, a «Co-​Manager» told us they could no longer meet anywhere other than someone’s residence. Even after I said they’d be losing a good customer, he pretty much said, «sorry».
Even Pizza Hut from GREELEY delivers to our location, which is a lot further. Furthermore, other restaurants in Johnstown — Domino’s or Huang Garden — ALWAYS agree to meet us at a location within their delivery area that’s closer to us.
Their sandwiches are HORRIBLE. Only the pizza was worth it. Never again though.

**Note** I lived in NY for many years, so I’m already pizza biased
That being said, this is up there on pizza places I have had in CO, glad its in my neighborhood. Pizzas are solid, nothing spectacular, however I think their wings are great. They are very large and meaty, perfect complement for the pizza. Have had both take out and delivery with success.

One of the best pizza places ever. I don’t like pizza that much and I love this place. The attitude of the staff could be better, but worth the aggravation for the pie!

We have been Johnstown residents for 7 years… Used to love Dominic’s. Within the last year, the pizza quality and taste has significantly declined. The last time we ordered (about a week ago) will be the last time we order from them, period. The staff was rude and made me feel like an inconvenience. The pizza was over cooked (for the third time in a row) and not prepared as we ordered. I hate to turn to the local chain in the neighborhood, but I have no choice. I try to support local business, but my stomach just can’t take it anymore.

My family moved to Johnstown about a year ago and have tried to sample all of the local offerings. We’ve been to Dominic’s three times, giving it a fair shot, and decided that we probably don’t need to go back now.
The first experience was a delivered pizza. The staff on the phone was curt bordering on rude, and the pizza arrived cold and long after promised.
The second and third experiences were take-​out. The pizza itself was good — I’d call it above average. However, it was pretty pricey for what you got and it was again a bit slow.
I like supporting local businesses, but not really when they don’t deserve support.

*drool!* I love this place! I grew up in Johnstown and have been eating this pizza since the early 90’s. My friends an I used to walk down here and pitch on a pizza when we were hanging out. I used to come here for lunch in high school. When I house sit /​dog sit for my parents, this is what I order when I’m staying in. There is nothing like Dominic’s! The sauce is zesty & garlicy, the cheese is perfectly stringy and deliciously gooey and it’s a home town favorite. I can’t wait for my next slice!