New York 2 Chicago Pizzeria – NY2C

Today was our first visit here. We wish we’d been here sooner! Very good Chicago style deep dish pizza. Pizza here makes you realize how inferior other pizza shop pizzas are! We’ll be regulars here for sure! Good job!!!

This place really is fantastic!
The thin crust «NY Style» is crisp all the way through the crust. Most places seem to not be able to do this and end up with a soggy middle.
The buffalo chicken (with blue cheese) is a great option as well!
I just wish I lived closer!

My boyfriend and I came in and got a calzone. We both love calzones so when the menu said it feeds 4 we thought we could eat it with no problems. We ended up eating only half of it between us because it’s huge! The crust was amazing and the sauce was top notch. The cheese was super gooey and I’m a huge fan of ricotta in calzones so I was very happy about that (I do wish there was a bit more but that’s an uncommon preference).
I’ll be coming back to get the pizza, those looked great too.

Horrible. The pizza had absolutely no resemblance to a New York style pizza and I’m a born and raised New Yorker. The crust was more like a crisp flat bread, and was pretty tasteless; none of the chew a real NY pizza would have. Everything else about it was mediocre at best. And the Greek salad was pretty tasteless too.
And they don’t have a liquor license.
I’ll never be back.

Have been hearing rave reviews for NY2C Pizza in Kent for weeks and finally had to try it for myself.
I called ahead to see what time they closed, and was asked what time I wanted to come in… Was immediately taken back because you’d be hard press to find a business that literally asks YOU when you’d like to come in! [FIRST POINT EARNED] I said around 9pm-​ish, which was fine.
The inside atmosphere is a perfect combination of New York and Chicago with an open kitchen where you can see the pizza’s coming out of the oven. Love the Ma&Pa feel from employees. The staff is genuine, straight out of a Godfather movie and delighted to have your business.
Unfamiliar with their menu, only that they did different style of pizza. I ordered one New York and one Chicago (our household has a split pizza preference). This is a no nonsense place. Simple menu; Pick a pizza style, add some toppings and you’ve got OUTSTANDING pizza
This Pizza is STUPID GOOD… AMAZING. Sauce taste like it’s stewed on a stove for hours. It has a perfect amount of acidity and spice that is sure to give me heartburn, (all tomato based things do) but frankly I do not care because every bite is worth it. Crust in baked to golden brown perfection on both styles. All around amazing texture and taste on this Pizza!
New York style is my favorite, and their pizza was legit. Thin crust you can fold, perfect sauce cheese ratio along with the right amount of topping, then finished with a blend of seasonings that ties everything together. Now I’m not partial to Chicago, that’s the fiances favorite, but even I can appreciate how good NY2C’s Chicago style was. Deep (not thick) crust filled with sauce, toppings, Parmesan cheese and those seasonings…
Being one of the last customers that evening and the pizza’s being as good as there were says something for this establishment. I see others have had issues with wait time, but that’s to be expected with any pizza shop that you’re getting authentic made to order from scratch food. It’s either taste or time and I’d wait for the taste of this pizza!!!