Old Town Bakery

The brioche breakfast sandwich is amazing! Chocolate croissant is equally good. Beautiful, quaint little place. Pleasant staff. Highly recommended!

Been in key west a week and some change and I have been here every other day to either get their awesome Croissants, danish or Breakfast Sandwich. Favorite danish they make fresh is the peach cobbler danish, it is so buttery but not super sweet… right up my alley!

If every morning could start with a croissant or Danish from Old Town Bakery, I would be there. The croissants are some of the most flakey, crispy and delicate that I have had to date. The almost on croissant is my most favorite. Small location that is quaint and cute. The people who work their and craft these delicious treats are very kind and welcoming and provide excellent service. The breakfast sandwiches on fresh brioche are also an excellent choice for a delicious breakfast. High on my priority list each time I am in key west. — Dagby Approved!

Very friendly. A pick up & go place no inside sitting so walked to waterfront but food still piping hot. Tasty breakfast brioche w 2 eggs $ 5.50 enough for 2 unless you are massively obese. Great value.

After walking around the Key West for about 4 hours, I knew I needed a few slices of Key Lime Pie to make the trip worth it. I’ve tasted the bites along the main streets and decided to continue my foodie-​ness in looking for a local, non-​descript spot. On our way back to the parking structure, we passed by Old Town Bakery and I hopped in to see if they had some pie left. Of course they did and I bought two slices. This was the most amazing Key Lime Pie I’ve ever had — I love sour and sweet combinations and this pie was legit! The sourness of the key limes definitely was a hit to the taste buds and then the whipped cream toned it down. it was a perfect balance and a great treat after a hot and humid day. Then i checked Unilocal after my food adventure and was relieved to see that people knew about this place and that it has great ratings! Thanks for a great taste of the Key West!

Delicious and amazing baguettes! I was told to be careful, the bread is hot and will burn my hand, an issue I love to have with fresh baked bread!

Iced chai and frozen mocha were just what we needed during our walk. Yum! Sandwiches on the board looked really good, as did baked items under the shelf.

I was only here for five minutes but this place is admirable. Yummy bread and cheese. Hot hot coffee! Very nice staff.

We went here for breakfast and had danishes and coffee. The service was good and the danishes were outstanding! OTB had a great selection, and its atmosphere was warm and genuine.

Fantastic variety of fresh baked goods and a surprisingly wide variety of cheese.
I tried the brownie (fudgy deliciousness) and the ginger white chocolate cookie (refreshing).
These girls make a great iced latte, too! I only wish they had a larger size!
Lunch sandwiches look and smell amazing, but I did not get a chance to try any of them on this trip. Maybe next time!

Stopped here on our way out of town. Their breakfast sandwiches and chocolate chip cookies were delicious!

Always a must to stop here on every visit to Key West!
Best Bakery love the French Baquette, Brownie with Walnuts is like fudge very rich and the OMG brownie is a whole other experience of wonderful.

My egg brioche sandwich was excellent. Both types of their brownies taste great! I didn’t like their choco chip cookie, but the bakery takes pride in their natural, simple ingredients and I happen to prefer the usual choco chip cookie flavor (which may be artificial). I did not like the curry chicken salad sandwich-​but the quality and taste were there (it might be better described as ‘not the usual chicken salad sandwich’ on the menu so you won’t be so surprised). Although they weren’t extraordinarily ‘key west Friendly’– And there
Was one young lady that just didn’t seem to be nice at all – *They were consistent and their prices are great and the food is. Excellent food-​I would have eaten there for breakfast, lunch, and dinner if my family would’ve let me. ;-PP!

Delicious key lime pie! Tart key lime flavor with mildly smooth home made whipped cream.
One of the best!

This place was near our hotel so decided to check it out for breakfast. Very small but great customer service and on both occasions I saw familiar patrons that were regulars.
I had the breakfast sandwich with ham and my boyfriend had the one with bacon. I loved the bread aa it was not the typical bagel or crossaint that comes with breakfast sandwiches. The only thing I wasn’t too fond of were the eggs, they seemed unseasoned to me.
I also tried the almond crossaint which was SO good. Def will be stopping by again next time im in town!

Almond Croissant TO DIE FOR!!!
On my first morning in Key West I stopped in at the Eaton Street location for a icy Frozen Latte to cool me down, but once I got a whiff of the pastries I knew that I had to come back when I hadn’t already eaten.
I went back the next day and had a wonderful sticky bun that had a light crisp to the outside, but was buttery and light.
Finally, on my last day I snagged the last almond croissant at the end of the day for a snack later that night. It was absolutely, perfectly mouthwateringly delicious. I meant to just have a bite or two, but I ended up scarfing the entire thing down in no time flat. It was wonderfully crispy, and loaded with perfect almond filling. I have NEVER had an almond croissant that good in my life.
Each time I was there, the service was as great as their carefully made products were. Also, taking into account their high quality, I thought the prices were perfectly reasonable. It was too bad that there was no seating, but I’d go back there in a heartbeat anyway!

Happened on this place after eating at Bien Caribbean (across the street).
I had the Raspberry cheese Danish. OMG Awesome. Lightly crispy on edges, the cheese was tangy, the dough was soft. My wife had a chocolate croissant, and loved that also — plenty of chocolate in a really light flaky dough. We so wanted to go back and get more.
I would highly recommend you stop here. (especially if you have just finished eating at the wonderful Bien Caribbean.)

I came to Key West for a wedding in June, and happened to find this spot with my friends. Great find! They make everything there, and it’s reasonably priced.
What I ordered & verdict:
Key lime pie: fave on the island so far! Tart and perfect personal size
Portobello wrap: fresh and delicious. Goat cheese with homemade herb mix, sprouts and portobello. I’m not a vegetarian but it’s a savory yet refreshing meal.
All in all, a big thumbs up.

They sell day old stale pastries — buyer beware. And the coffee isn’t that good either. Walk a little further to the Cuban Coffee Queen — you’ll be happier.
Hey guy that posted a nasty note back to me — the pastry I bought today was STALE and OLD. Perhaps tell your employees not to sell them when they go bad if you don’t want a bad review.
And insulting me on Unilocal doesn’t make you look good. It proves my point :). Thanks!
I’ve posted good reviews too — Island Dogs Bar for one. :)

Service was friendly enough and they seemed to want to be there, which is always a good sign. They had a small variety of pastries, but I also enjoyed their selection of meats, cheeses, and crackers if you wanted a more «substantial» snack than a pastry.
The danish I had was good, but not great. The cheese and salami we ordered came with some nice crostini, which is a nice touch. All were pretty good, but again not great.
While I am a tourist, I typically put things on my «must do when I return» list. This really isn’t on the list. I enjoyed what I had, but I will seek out something else to try just because nothing about this place wowed me. It’s cute, quaint and all, but didn’t really deliver in the special-​department when it came to the nuts and bolts — flavor.

Preise etwas höher. Gebäck etwas fetter und schon fahren die Leute darauf ab. Nein, der Laden ist ok aber besonders fande ich es nicht. Das Gebäck war lecker aber keine Überraschung. Der Espresso wurde zu heiß zubereitet, was so viel bitternote erzeugte das man ihn nicht genießen konnte. Für key west sicherlich nett aber mehr auch nicht.

Sehr nette kleine Bäckerei.
Gutes Brot und klasse Croissants.
Einfach nur zu empfehlen

5* bakery — the best one. The Croissants were better than in Europe!