The New York Pizza Company

This place is now in my top 3 pizza places! Huge pies, awesome sauce and super cheesy. My family and I are here on vacation and drove about 15 miles from our hotel to eat here on a whim. By far one of the best decisions we could have made for a place to eat. I highly recommend coming here. And if you have to wait, it’s worth it. Not to mention the friendly staff who talked with respect and have what it takes to make great pies! Try this place and give them the 5 star review they deserve!

1^st time here I love the atmosphere defiantly new York style. I had the p hilly cheeses teak and wife had the wings and a slice all superb and service was great

Pizza slices are huge and at a great price! If your looking for a quick lunch this is the place. Add l they also have good lunch deals

Best pies in the area. Closest to my pizza from the Bronx I have found !!! Big pies thinish crust, wonderful fresher ingredients and a great tomato sauce to Finnish. Don’t believe they use cheap cheese as there is very little oil run off.
If you really don’t care for this pizza… Head over to Hungry Howies. You’ll like it better. Or better yet the frozen pizza section at Bravo!

Always great pizza slices and cheap lunch specials! Quick and great service as usual as well. Had my first baked ziti today… so cheesy and delicious, made fresh! Added a slice of pizza and a drink for my little one for all under $ 10. They were nice enough to cut my little one’s slice into bite size pieces without my having to ask! 5 stars all the way!

Best pizza I’ve had since living up north, great thin crust and authentic. Definitely will be returning, the staff is friendly and you can’t beat the prices!

Good pizza ! Nice people ! Shame customers trash the outside. It’s just area ! Restaurant is clean and food is always good and hot. Thx, Pizza critic !

Pizza was really good but the place is a filth box. Extremely dirty. Not sure I would eat there again.

I don’t live too far from this place. They don’t deliver and that’s ok. Anyhow, we order an XL pizza with large stromboli and 20 wings. They had some special for that what I was going to order. Anyhow, I’m orginally from the Tristate area, this place is good. For claiming to be the real NY pizza, it’s awfully doughy, not thin like REAL NY pizza. The sauce that came with the stromboli was AMAZING! The stromboli was good, that was more for my boyfriend. The sauce is what made it. Anyhow, the wings were overdone and dry, not much hot sauce. I was really looking forward to the wings and I was really disappointed… 3.5

The pizza was really good. My children are really picky and they ate it up. The staff was awesome as well. Would definitely return and recommend this place.

Delicious pies and tasty gyros. Even the fries were perfectly golden and crisp — great to dip in homemade marinara sauce. Alex and the staff were friendly as can be with travel tips and friendly conversation — do yourself a favor and stop by for a real slice of NY right here in Florida.

Super bland, acidic sauce. Garlic knots tasted like stale old dry bread. This place use to be really good. Consistency is key! Will never go back.

Went in there got stale pizza for the 3^rd time use to be fresh also gave me a calzone when I asked for a Stromboli which also tasted uncooked

Great pizza, big slices, nice staff. This is my go to pizza shop for lunch when I am at work. It is always a treat. The sauce is good, the crust is thin and slightly crispy. They have a nice lunch special menu. I always get a #1 which is two cheese slices and a fountain drink for $ 3.99. not a bad deal and they never disappoint

Really good pizza at a good price. I really liked the sausage. It had a very nice flavor.

I reviewed the Unilocal in the parking lot as I was waiting for my order. I had high hopes.
Small shop, go to the back to place the order. Waited in line. You could see them making the pizza behind the counter. Had 1980’s music playing, but the good vibe feelings were not there.
Counter service: alright — too the point — not happy (I long for at least a happy
greeting)-nothing to brag about
Wait time: 15 – 20 minutes — we checked out the cute lil shops around the store
(Cupcakes, Beauty supply, Aquariums…)
Food: Quantity and not quality was how I would describe it. They have some combo’s and I chose the XL Pizza with 1 topping, 6 garlic knots and 10 wings for $ 19.99 .
Nice that they included sauce for both the garlic knots and the wings.
The pizza was hard and dry on the bottom, no flavor to the crust, except for cardboard tasting. Decent amount of cheese. It really was not good. Truly an XL size, we got to take some home and eat off of it 2 more times.
The wings were anemic looking and dry. They were supposed to be mild with a side of hot sauce. They were «naked» and needing a good flavor bath!
They were sitting in some grease. I am sad to say I was about to dip it in the grease on the bottom of the container — but I didn’t want the stomach ache. Thank God for sauce on the side !
The garlic rolls were big and fluffy and flavorful. I was surprised. They were the best part of the meal. Maybe it was an «off order, an off day.»…whatever.
No plans to return. So sad.

Aye what do you want? A slice of pizza bigger than you head! Then head here.
I normally grab the lunch deal. I make my order simple 2 slices of pepperoni pizza and a coca cola. Sometimes I can only eat one slice.
This place is not gourmet, it’s that little greasy NYC Slice of Pie. You fold it in half and as you eat it you get a little drippy drip running down your arm or onto the plate if your not as messy as me.
I’m not always a food snob I treasure moments like this sometimes.
Great for a bite, kids love it. inexpensive. Busy at lunch if you can’t find a seat you can carry out.

Great pizza and wings and I love the beef patties, the staff was friendly and food came out quick

NY style pizza isn’t my favorite because I don’t like thin crust, but this did the trick in satisfying my pizza craving. They have nicely priced lunch specials. 2 pepperoni slices + a drink for $ 5. The slices are HUGE. I thought I would have to share.
We also ordered tiramisu for dessert. Unfortunately, they had just taken it out to thaw when we ordered, so by the time we were ready for it, it hadn’t fully thawed out. I would say it would have tasted much better had it been ready.
The place itself is really small. Less than 10 tables line the walls. Seems like we were lucky to score a table after waiting around for a bit.

I have been coming to New York Pizza since they opened, the place has always served me great food (I don’t know New York style pizza I just know it is good and you get your honest money’s worth) the staff is always courteous and seems to be the same since I have been coming here. Every once in a while the place is so busy you wait for food, but, the owners attitude always makes it worth while.