All Star Bagel

They have the most delicious bagels! The staff is wonderful, they are very helpful and kind! I love going here!

I just discovered this place and am absolutely hooked. I went 3 times this week and would eat this everyday if I knew I wouldn’t get fat haha. The base hit is my favorite. Mouth watering deliciousness! Plus, their prices are incredibly low, which I’d amazing. I’m going to be a regular for sure, and I highly recommend this shop to start your work day off right!

All around great experience… friendly people and staff, great sandwiches, homemade cream cheese!

I stopped here on a whim because I needed coffee and figured they might have some. I got a whole lot more than I bargained for. I also ordered a «Home Run» bagel with pork roll, a hash brown, cheese, and maybe egg? I don’t know everything that was on it but it was delicious. The coffee was pretty good but kind of watered down. It still got the job done, though. If I’m ever in the vicinity I’ll stop in again, but not on a whim.

Just moved to the area, this place is right by my house. Service was quick and the staff is pretty cool and really friendly.
Ordered the standard pork roll, egg & cheese sandwich, it didn’t come toasted, so I’ll have to ask next time. That being said, the bagel was super light and soft. Very yummy!
They have a nice variety of flavors, including French Toast, which you don’t see everywhere.
All in all a nice little joint, worth giving it a shot!

my mom moved to south jersey and we haven’t been able to find good bagels in toms river where she lives. We stopped here on our way to the outlets and were pleasantly surprised– remind of us the bagels up north!

They’re back to being the best bagels in central jersey. They are good sized and delicious. The place sells out on the weekends. Get there early. Several of my friends from south jersey ask me to bring them some all the time. The egg sandwiches are awesome.

First time here, I’m from north jersey and have been to great bagel places! This place had great service and the bagels were fantastic… Oh and try the crumb cake !! OMG

Decent bagel, but kinda limited selection. Service with a smile.

Customer Service is the «iceberg» that sinks this new business. I have eaten here at least twice a month since it opened. I am generally satisfied with the food, but by 9AM, the selection of bagels are slim and not as fresh as when they first opened. Coffee canisters have been found empty many times, seemingly unchecked with up to five employees behind the counter looking at each other.
My LAST visit I walked in to order a bagel sandwich at 12:45 PM on a Saturday. They close at 1:00 PM and I was turned away after being told the grill was off for the day. The is a customer service FAIL! You clean all the burners, leaving one on until closing, you check the coffee canisters every 10 minutes… I shouldn’t have to tell them how to run their business.
I took my family and my money to another location on Rt 70. that cooks until they’re actually closed. I will never return and although my $ 20 purchase a week will only put a little dent in their business… I hope they take this review and steer clear of the iceberg that is dead ahead. I will not be returning to this business when there are several better choices available that are interested in my business.

Best bagel I’ve had in a month of bagel eating in New Jersey! We found them on a trip from Toms River to Philly and I don’t think I’ll ever go to Philly again without stopping at All Star on the way!
This is the kind of place that makes you want to go out of your way to write a good review so you can make sure they exist forever!
Simple bagel shop. Nice people. Fast service. Good Coffee. Boars Head.
GREAT BAGELS!!!
The kind of bagels that take you back to the good old days when good bagels were something you took for granted in Jersey.
Thank you All Star!!!
I’m already planning my next trip back.