Magill’s World of Ice Cream

I love the ice cream here. But more than that, we love the cakes! We have toddlers that hate cake! (I know it’s weird) So I went hunting for a place that had no cake at all in the mix and I found it! The cake was a huge hit with toddlers and adults at the party! It was wonderfully made and decorated too. It also helps that you get to pick the flavors of everything. Our encounters with the staff are always nice here as well. I highly recommend!

Great place to indulge in some tasty ice cream. Probably the best ice cream shop I’ve ever visited. I’ll be back!

Very disappointed with the lackluster texture and flavors here. Coffee had a weak and watery flavor, chocolate was dull, cookies & cream was just fine, nutella tasted like washed out chocolate, and the rum raisin tasted old. I only bought some because the staff member was friendly. :-/​My puppy loved the doggie yogurt, at least!

The location was a little difficult to find. The ice cream was great. I got a double scoop thinking it would be enough and probably could have got one with the large potion you receive.

Excellent ice cream! Excellent service. If the sign says «open» you can go in even after closing. I’ve been at least a dozen times and never get bored of the flavors. Try the Sleepless in Seattle, and sign up for the email coupons!

The slam dunk (raspberry with chocolate chips) is amazing! And the portions are generous: «one scoop» is really 3 – 4 scoops. Best of all, the staff was genuinely the nicest and most friendly I’ve ever encountered. Will be back!

There are so many great ice cream flavors, I will have to come back! The scoops are large, so I ended up taking some home for later. Their ice cream is very thick and rich, and you won’t get bored with the options. There’s quart sizes you can purchase as well. They also have doggy ice cream! The place was hopping on a Tuesday evening, so clearly its a good spot.

This was probably some of the best ice cream I have had in years! We stopped by just on a whim and boy were we glad that we did!
We both got some double chocolate fudge ice cream and it was amazing! It was also very reasonably priced for the amount that they give you.
Go give this place a shot. I was surprised that it doesn’t have better reviews!

This place was delicious. When I walked in it smelled great. The ladies that worked their were very nice, and all the customers were happy regulars. I got the Cashew Carmel Ice Cream. Flipping awesome.

Was in need of a serious ice cream fix and this was the place for it. The ice cream is homemade and they were able to make my unique sundae request with no problem. Staff was very nice and place was super clean.

Been going here since I was a kid and could ride my bike over there. Love the ice cream, it is sooo good and creamy. I like the games in the seating area too, makes it a fun family outing!

Just drove 30 minutes to pick up ice cream for my fathers birthday, and though the hours clearly posted at the entrance states that they don’t close until 10pm, we arrived at 9:20pm to see two girls counting money in plain sight and trying their very best to ignore us at the door that they prematurely locked. We knocked and they waved us off, shaking their head and muttering rudely to one another. We didn’t get a chance to taste the product or experience the service, but the least a company can do is honor their posted hours and maybe even consider coming to the door when customers arrive to see how they can help. Very disappointing!

I love this ice cream store, they have my favorite flavor, Superman! I hope this store can stick around forever so my little girl can take her children there some day

My parents used to bring me here as a kid after softball games. That was 20 years ago, and the place still looks exactly the same to me (as in… they have not redecorated). It’s small but clean, and there usually isn’t much of a line.
I traditionally get a birthday cake from them every year. I think the quality of their cakes has really gone down (they seem old) but seriously… they have the best flavored ice cream cake frosting in the world. I’m not joking… it’s awesome. I wonder if they sell it in a bucket. I would totally buy it.
I always get a scoop of Blue Moon Ice Cream. They are the only place I’ve been able to find on the west coast that serves it, and it’s totally my favorite. And they always have it!

Seeing that I know now that Unilocal filters reviews, then attempts to strong arm businesses into paying to have hidden positive reviews shown, I can’t in good judgement slam small businesses knowing Unilocal shitty tactics of hiding good reviews.
The owner wrote a extremely nice message, asking me to give his place another try. He asked nothing of me or for me to change my review. With that, and knowing they are trying their best, I should not be a picky Unilocal-​bitch like the vast majority of reviewers. Thinking back, I didn’t realize how my snarky review would float to near the top of the reviews and potentially hurts their business.
I should really give this place another shot and hope my pervious review didn’t impact their business.

Major props for the never updated old school charm and tradition. The location is an old dilapidated shopping centers filled now with little churches. (weird)
You walk into to a freezer chest FILLED with ice cream cakes and you wonder about freshness. After Halloween, there were still a ton of orange cakes. The disappointment is in their only product: ICE CREAM. Its filled with fake flavoring and spongy air injected nice cream. Its like eating a fluffy marshmallow flavored by Skittles.
Anyone over the age of 6 should stay away.

You know how I know that an ice cream shop deserves 4 star? This is how: order a single scoop, turn around to admire the clown cones, turn back again, look at your ice cream cone, and state to the employee that you only asked for a single scoop, to which she will reply that you only received a single scoop. Sure, I just got new glasses as my vision was on the decline, but I would have sworn my scoop was doubled up. Negatory good buddy. They just packed the ice cream into that sugar cone for your delight.
And delighted I was. So many flavors that you don’t get in the store or via Ben and Jerry’s. I felt like a kid going into the old 31 Flavors, only there were more flavors. Clown cones, ice cream cakes, ready-​packed quarts; they’ve got it all.
Her name may be Magill, but there’s nothing «lill» about the servings. Prost! (You can prost to ice cream, trust me.)

Locally owned business with good ice cream. Plenty of neat flavors plus ice cream cakes and other goodies, and also a sundae bar which is fun.
I think the place itself could be freshened up some — and a few of the games laying around kind of look germy and over-​used. Don’t really want to play them and then handle my cone.
But this is a good place with good ice cream and anytime we’re in the area with a hankering, we go. You should too!

2012 Review #219:
I didn’t actually eat Magill’s ice cream at their store, but at another local establishment. But, seeing as how Magill’s is a local business, I figure I should review them directly.
Seeing comments about the ice cream having large ice crystals is surprising because mine was quite smooth. Definitely had a lot of air, but it was smooth. Maybe that had to do with it being a new tub.
I tried the Guinness caramel chocolate chip and it had the distinct flavors of each ingredient. The Guinness flavor was almost like a Guinness cupcake; it had the starchy notes of alcohol in addition to the chocolate notes of the stout. If anything, there were almost too many chocolate chips, but it was pretty well distributed. The flavor could have been a bit more intense, but it certainly had more identifiable flavor than that of a *certain* local favorite.

I love locally operated ice cream joints! Magill’s is clean, thoughtful (there are tons of games for kids and family), serves ice cream cake, complimentary cones with ice cream. If you’re concerned about calories, order the kiddie size, I can’t tell that it’s much smaller than the regular size! Another steal is their greeting cards, though not Hallmark quality, can’t beat the price of $ 0.99 per card! I think I bought 10~
Last time we went it was our first time, we tried the Strawberry Cheesecake flavor and Gingerbread flavor, one in a dish, one in a sugar cone, both were very yummy! We’ll definitely go back again in the summer!