Sushi One

Unfortunately Sushi One is nothing special. Given their proximity to two other sushi restaurants one would think they would up their game a bit. The rolls I ordered fell apart when I picked them up and the tea was lukewarm at best. Service also was a disappointment.
If you are looking for a sushi night out, make the short trek into Lancaster.

This place, #SUSHIONE is a hidden treasure! I saw the «open sign» flashing & my stomach said yes please however here is the kicker. It was 10:30 PM and they close at 10:00 PM. I thought someone forgot to turn off the light but just in case I’m going to call. I’m so glad I did. They do close at 10:00 (11:00 AM-10:00 PM Sunday-​Thursday & 11:00 am-10:30PM Friday-​Saturday) however customers had a party tonight and since some of the guest were still there they stayed open for other customers (like me, lol). Most places close the doors at said closing time and start the closing clean up while working around patrons. Not them, they stay open. After he took my order, I turned around & drove back to pick up my order. If you like sushi and have not been here yet, you do not know what you’ve been missing out on! The owners & employees are really nice & genuine! Make sure you come try this place out & pass this hidden gem on to family & friends they will thank you for it. Walk in or reservations. B.Y.O.B. Great sushi, great environment & great employees can’t ask for more than that! If you chose to you have a party at Sushi One give them a call to make reservations. (Parties get 10% off the total of your bill). They chose to remain open and it got my attention. They stayed open, got more business have gained a new customer! Shout out to my 2 Italians guys that walked me to the door, thank you. Also for letting 1 of the owners know I was your cousin so he’d give me a discount, every penny saved counts! They told me «5 years living here and I haven’t ate sushi at any other place & I never will!» Lancaster county has a lot of places to jump around & eat at. 2 guys eating at the same place for 5 years… I think that speaks magnitudes about SUSHI ONE! The food, atmosphere & employees! Next time I will be sure to show up before closing and I’ll be dining in with my hubby! *** I referred to it as a hidden gem because It is kinda hard to see from the road (Fruitville Pike). I’ve never noticed it before & I am sure there are others as well. It’s across the street from Kmart in the little strip shopping mall. (Little Ceasers Pizza, used book store are what I can remember seeing).

I have eaten at a lot of sushi restaurants over the years and this one is definitely one of the best! I have never had a bad meal. The sushi is fresh and served in nice sized pieces. They offer creative yummy new sushi rolls as specials. The presentation on sushi boats is always nice with a fresh flower and other decorative touches. Staff is friendly and accommodating. BYOB.

Still the best place for sushi. For the price, you get a lot if you go for their combo deals. The AYCE isn’t bad either. The fish to rice ratio is good. The owner is very friendly and nice. Gave us some edema as it was a wait to get our food.

Currently sitting at sushi one, ordered 35 minutes ago, it’s not that busy, but no sushi yet. 5 more minutes and I’m walking out.
Update– got my first round of AYCE sushi at 38 minutes after ordering. Everyone (not that «everyone is a lot of people by any means) that didn’t have an AYCE menu got their food in about 10 minutes or less (even ones that ordered after me). Seems like a scam to keep AYCE profits at the highest.
Plus the sushi was like 80% rice. The fish to rice ratio sucks.
Not returning.

I’m from California where sushi is the best.
I can def. say this place is up there.
Quality Rolls

We were kind of new to Sashima and Sushi when we encountered Sushi One on Fruitville Pike in Manheim Township, PA. It is now our favorite restaurant of any kind. Once every two weeks, we grab a bottle of dry Reisling and head over. The Clipper Magazine usually has coupons for $ 5 off, but we would be eating there regardless. Our favorites are the Jersey Roll, and anything which includes shrimp tempura. Our friends who still do not indulge in Sushi spoke highly of the Chinese style entrees. The service is quick and non intrusive unless they are very crowded, then, of course, everything slows down. Don’t miss the best Sushi in Lancaster County, PA.

A nice place but expensive. They don’t help you understand what you are ordering. They just want to have you order and be done. If you want a soda they give you a can, which cost over $ 1. The location is hidden. There was only 2 other people there which was around 2pm on a sunday.

The food was great, atmosphere nice. The main problem was the service. We ordered the love boat and asked what could be on it. We were told specialty rolls were okay. So we ordered some.
Once we finished, it was more expensive than it should be. When we asked why, apparently specialty rolls were not included in the price. The staff did not apologize for the confusion, just basically said they thought they explained it. When they did not. They only explained to us AFTER the bill came. Poor communication skills, poor service in general.
Food is great like previously stated, but if the staff can’t even communicate what’s in an entrée, then it’s not worth going unless you have a really fat wallet.

This place has went down a notch for me. It is still good but the sushi chef seems sick the last 3 times I have been there and it is a huge turnoff.

Have been there twice. First time was excellent. Second time was a huge disappointment.
Went in on a Sat night and it was reasonably crowded. After ordering we proceeded to wait and wait and wait. We saw people come in, get seated, order, eat, and leave and we still had nothing. When we asked about our order we were told it would be right out. Another 20 mins went by and nothing. So we up and left.
Anybody who goes out knows that orders get lost in the shuffle but we found HUGELY disppointing is essentially being lied to — told our order would be right out but clearly wasn’t even submitted.
A restaurant that is more committed to customers would have acknowledged they made a mistake and offered to bring a complimentary appetizer or two while we waited.
Neither happened…

There’s not too many combinations better than excellent all-​you-​can-​eat sushi, late night dinning, and a BYOB. The speciality rolls are excellent but if you could only try one — go for Bruce’s Roll. Make sure you ask for the all-​you-​can eat menu (you won’t be disappointed) and bring a great bottle of wine.

One of my favorite restaurants in Lancaster. Prompt friendly service and good fresh food.

We tried the AYCE on two occasions. Both times the fish to rice ratio was way off. After a few pieces, I was full and finished eating. Stuffed from the ridiculously excessive amount of rice. Spending $ 20+ bucks on a couple pieces of sushi is a joke. It’s a bummer, because everything tasted great. We gave this place two tries — we won’t be returning.

Very good selection & nice lunch specials. Got a sushi boat for 4 people and it was delicious.

I stopped in for lunch and had the maki combo. The rolls were great. They were nice and cool. (I don’t like when they are warm or room temp.) the service was great and it was very reasonably priced.

Place was better than the last time I was there. Sat down at the sushi bar and had the New York roll which is good the spicy tuna which I get all the time because it’s like pizza very hard to fuck up. And then the ell and great I’m a sucker for those slippery bastards. Also it’s a BYOB or sake which I due and please drink it warm!!!

I waited 45 minutes for 2 sushi rolls when the restaurant was essentially empty.
Service is unfriendly. Not worth the wait and not worth the money. My advice — check out a few other places closer to or in the city.

Hands down, my favorite sushi place in town. Each bite is bursting in flavor and you can count on each roll to be delicious. I also usually order the pineapple fries rice which is perfectly seasoned. Definitely worth checking out, they are top quality and know what they’re doing.

You could have a great time here for a good price if you bring your own wine or beer. The all you can eat deal is a good one if you can eat about 4 rolls. Be careful with your ordering though or they will charge you for being wasteful!
The Tokyo roll was my favorite.