Pie Five Pizza

The first time I went there it was really good. The owners were making the pizza and did a good job. I went there recently and the employees didn’t put enough ingredients on the pizza. The honeymoon is over at this location.

Gave this another chance: Major improvements in customer service. I’m glad they took swift actions to improve their business.

I’ve eaten here twice. The pizzas are fair to good. The Olathe location is so small it’s hard to find a place to sit during busy times. I also think this place is dirty. I never saw anyone cleaning tables, or cleaning up the drink station. I will go back because my kids love it but but it’s a little expensive so it won’t be a frequent stop for our family of five.

First time I ate here I wasn’t impressed, but now I eat there once a week. Additional toppings are not extra (at least for me). Be aware there is no call in for carryout.

I frequent Pie Five often & extended beyond my usual & ordered the Jack Stax pulled pork. They slathered sweet BBQ sauce on, cheese, BBQ smothered piled pork, & standard topping of pickles. I added banana peppers & jalapeños. After the oven tour it was sprinkled with «magic dust» & red peppers. This won’t be ordered by me again — too sweet of sauce & pork. The pizza didn’t seem to «marry» together very well. I will continue to go back to the idea of a delicious hot pizza I can order or create.

I’ve visited this new store 6 – 7 times over the last 3 months. Quality has consistently dropped. My daughter likes it and it is convenient, so we do go there. But, the value, quality and consistency are simply not there. I like the idea of the quick pizza and salad. When it opened, the staff was much more friendly and generous on toppings and attention to detail. Probably corp staff or owners involved up front. Now, it has dropped off significantly. The area around this location is prime and there are too many better choices for the money. The point that forced me to write a review was the side salad ($ 3) addl that was very poor. I asked for some fresher spinach, as it was at the bottom and the guy looked at me like «what for man, this is ok.». I declined the half made salad. Then told the manager and he mildly apologized instead of looking for some way to improve the situation. He should have recognized the situation and gone out of the way to save the sale. The worst part is I gave my pts card and he saw that i had many points so I was a good customer. Spin Pizza is about 1.5 miles away and for the same price, you get much higher quality and better service. I’ll make the drive from now on. Also, many other premium sit down eateries are close and discounting heavily. One other item. I always carry out, as the seating is uncomfortable, cold environment and engineered for efficiency. This is not a mass, «hose out the place», location. I predict Pie Five will be a flash in the pan. They will start to go broke due to quality, customer service and value issues. Too many choices and too much competition.

This place has the best Gluten-​Free pizza I’ve ever had. Seriously, try the BBQ Chicken on gluten free bread. I prefer it over regular dough.

Fast service, pizza is yummy. They’ve always put plenty of toppings on mine, but you can ask for more if you think you’re not getting enough. I really like the thin crust, which comes out crispy & delish. Love the Magic Dust, and they’ve got the soda machine with the nine zillion flavor additions. Great for a quick lunch.

excellent service and food and ambience

What a cool concept. It’s fun. It’s reasonably priced. And quite honestly it’s delicious. Just really good food, & a fun experience. Very fast too, so if you’re down to try it, and you got a lunch time, try the thin crust. You get to decide everything that’s on your pizza.

Had a free pizza coupon so figured I’d try it out but it really tasted like glorified bland frozen pizza to me. Options are great but crust fell apart with toppings & wasn’t crispy as preferred. I’ll stick with Spin & Mia Mio.

Fast service. Pretty good ingredient quality. Their crust is delicious. Friendly staff!

very disappointed and pricey. I could of gotten two loaded pan meat lovers pizza’s from pizza hut. did not fill my husband up at all. won’t go again.

Chipotle style. Fast service and great price. Lots of topping choices and service is friendly. I always make my own and the pizza is cooked thoroughly. They have a really nice patio area outside, so go before it get’s too cold!

The five minute custom pizzas are convenient, and as healthy as you want them to be. The crust, sauce, and toppings options are many, and varied. I like the Farmer’s Market (veggie) pizza with added chicken on a wheat thin crust.
I found the service at this location to be fast, and friendly. The interior was clean, and new. Very nice.