Stone Creek Pizza & Frozen Yogurt

Stone Creek Pizza and Frozen Yogurt opened up after a Dominos Pizza closed shop and left. The owners did a great job renovating the place. They use benches (like the ones in the park) instead of traditional seating to give a comfortable feel. The ceiling is lined with lit panels that are supposed to emulate the sky and it looks really cool. Lastly, there is a pond in the back with fish in it. I don’t really see the point of having a park/​nature type theme in a restaurant serving pizza and frozen yogurt (also a weird combination), but it certainly looks good.
The first time I had pizza here, I was blown away. It was really good. The second time however, the same pizza tasted different, and not in a good way. It may be that it wasn’t prepared right or they changed up the ingredients but I noticed a falling sense of quality. This, coupled with the relatively high cost for a pizza, made me reconsider ordering pizza from here.
Similar story with the frozen yogurt. I loved the salted caramel praline flavor. It is very unique and absolutely delicious. However, as I soon discovered, the taste is different each time. Sometimes it is good, other times it is bad. Don’t get me wrong, when it is good, it is great. But there has been a time when I went in and left without purchasing anything. If they can just get a grasp on quality control and maintaining a standard, I would certainly visit more often.

Such a fun and cozy place to hang with friends and family! This is exactly what Lilburn needs more of. Stay open please! Pizza and froyo are delicious. More fruit toppings would be nice ;)

I have ordered regularly from Stone Creek since moving to GA in Oct. Last 2 times I did a build your own pizza, the pizza that was delivered did not have all the items that I ordered. Happened again tonight. Ordered a 7 topping Pizza. What turned up was a cheese pizza. This time I called to complain. A very polite young lady took my order by phone and said that they would replace it. A few minutes later, the owner called me and wanted to know what the problem was. I explained. He was belligerent and I told him that I could order elsewhere. He said «f**k you» get your pizza elsewhere and hung up on me. Sorry dude, I’ll do exactly that! :-D

I live closeby and usually dine at Pizza Café or Enzo’s or Shorty’s in Tucker. Hubs out of town and wanted fresh pizza and thought I would give Stone Creek a try. SO glad I did. Especially pleased that they have an 8 inch personal pizza so I didn’t have to order more than I needed. Got the spinach and bacon. Lots of cheese, very bacon-​y and enough spinach to not make it an only-​meat pizza. FRESH. Did not taste chain-​y as in Pizza Hut or Dominos. Will definitely carry out again!

Great pizza. I have ordered from here a few times since thy opened.
Staff has been very friendly.
The dough is much better than chain pizza joints. Try the deep dish.

We are no longer going to Domino’s. Plus build your own soft serve yogurt sundaes for flat rate. Awesome!

Really good pizza. Fresh ingredients, lots of them. We ordered veggie lovers and basic pizza and they were both very tasty. Prices are fairly good.

So I’ve been ordering a gluten free pizza from Stone Creek for a while now. I ordered the same pizza again today. I was delivered a regular pizza.
I called the store to have them send me out the proper pizza and Troy was dismissive and threw the mistake back on me since I ordered on line and must have been «user error». I explained to him that I reviewed my order, as I always do before submitting. He snickered insultingly and asked «what do you expect me to do?» Really? Then I tell him again and he says he has to ask a manager and hangs up on me without any further words.
I just explained it and you’re going to dismiss me with a disrespectful tone and hang up without any further discourse.
Troy, here’s a basic math and civics lesson for you since you obviously skipped those classes… you just cost Stone Creek a household of customers at 4 – 6 pizzas a month exponentially because while after having to call back to speak to your manager Chris and he being far more polite, cordial and accommodating to correcting the order you’ve left an indelible image in my mind that a version of your disrespect may in fact accompany any further deliveries to this house. There’s good pizza everywhere, what sets one apart is their service and attitude. Well done young man. I hope you seize the lesson in all this. I have! Order elsewhere.

Great pizza and frozen yogurt! Supreme and pepperoni are good. The strawberry and coconut frozen yogurt was also good. Will be back soon :-)

Great «southern» pizza by southern i mean bland and tasteless. Sauce was way too sweet, cheese too sparse and the sausage disncontain a hint of any seasoning. I had treheat the pie with some peppers and oregano. When I asked for anchovies the kid looked at me like I came from another planet.

First time visiting Stonecreek. Went to the yogurt shop and two of their machines are completely down, third one is partially down. Honestly, employees acted as if they couldn’t have cared any less.
Live close by so will probably come back to give it another shot, but tonight was kind of ridiculous.

I’ve been here a few times and I really like the pizza. It’s a little more expensive than you typical pizza hut or papa johns but it’s worth it. The only complaint I have about the pizza is the menu. I wish the pricing were a little clearer.
Yesterday, we went there for frozen yogurt and this is the best frozen yogurt place I have been to. They had a really good selection of flavors and toppings. Plus, their price was lower than most others. Three food sized yogurts with toppings for about $ 12.
Highly recommended

5 stars! Great food. Fantastic service! This place should be on a tv show. Where else can you get fresh pizza for breakfast at 630 in the morning, and for 3.99 no less! And the frozen yogurt? Excellent! Ill be returning soon!

The Frozen yogurt is amazing! Great price and Great selection! My family loves Stone Creek!

Great price and this is awesome frozen yogurt. It would be good for a meal too since they also have pizza. Definitely coming back to try that

I’ve tried their pizza and frozen yogurt a while back. I wouldn’t say it’s the best thing around, but it’s alright if it’s the closest thing to you.
PIZZA:
I ordered a personal sized pizza with chicken and pineapple. It’s extra charge for toppings which, I don’t like and there wasnt a lot of it on my pizza either for the amount I paid for. There weren’t any specialties, or deals that caught my eye. The personal pizza was a good size for one person, but the pizza did not satisfy my pizza cravings. The crust was thin. It’s not like the fluffy regular kinds at pizza hut or the bigger pizza chains. The cheese and sauce were okay, pineapple did the rest of my taste buds. Dough was chewy but thin. I wasn’t too thrilled after eating my personal pizza. You can tell the chicken I had was from frozen and not «authentic». I havent gotten another pizza ever since then.
FROZEN YOGURT:
This is a different story. I could give them 4 stars, but I have a different liking to frozen yogurts. I like my frozen yogurt to be a bit tart like Pinkberry’s. The frozen yogurt here is sweet/​similar to soft serve ice cream. They have good flavors such as different variations of chocolate, cookies and cream, fruit selections. They also have a lot of toppings for your yogurt. However, price per ounce was a bit high for what kind of yogurt they had. Still okay to try. I’ve been here for their frozen yogurt abiut twice.
The store is basically 2 stores combined into one. The staff would manage both sides so you’ll most likely see the same person serve you your pizza while also checking you out at the cash register in the frozen yogurt side. I thought pizza and frozen yogurt was a weird mix for me, but I havent ordered both at the same time. The frozen yogurt side is definitely bigger, as it has seating and the pizza side is very small where you only have space to stand and order. You would have to eat your pizza in the frozen yogurt side if you want to eat there. Ambiance is okay. The frozen yogurt side has a water fountain in the back, but it seems out of place. It’s a bit dim also.
Overall, it’s definitely not a wow factor place and I haven’t been there in weeks. But it’s okay to try out if you’re feeling adventurous.

Great pizza! I have not eaten in the restaurant yet, but have done delivery and take out, and I have to say the pizza is pretty tasty, including their gluten free pizza! I do know that this business also gives back to the community and it is a true local business — let’s make sure we keep them here!!! Go check them out!

Ordered my first pizza from this restaurant and it was pretty darn decent. They had a good selection of toppings and even a gluten free crust, which is fabulous as so many friends now need that option. They delivered promptly and I particularly liked the flavor of their sauce and feta. Will order from them again.

We Love Love the Pizza here, Great taste and great price. The restaurant also have yogurt, very tasty. The kids really enjoyed the different flavors, and the many toppings. Would recommend anyone to try this place out, especially my family from up north. My family find it very hard to locate a Pizza place that taste just as good as New York style Pizza.

Ordered the supreme pizza tonight for delivery. I asked to sub tomato for the sausage. Pizza was delivered in 35 mins which is fine. I was expecting a great pizza based on their website touting fresh ingredients, etc. Papa Johns and Pizza Hut make better pizza. The crust was chewy and not in a good way. They put sundried tomato instead of fresh tomato. I like sundried tomato but not on pizza. Overall I was disappointed and wished I had ordered from Pizza Café instead.