Mr Bill’s Cheesecakes

Another place I want to keep to myself. I’ve been a customer for over 25yrs. Yes OVER 25 yrs, and don’t try to guess my age Dag nab it! Just know that this place is the real deal!
Cheesecake is big in NY. Everyone raves about Juniors & Lindys but I must say Mr Bills is right there with them.
This is a home grown independent shop that offers many delicious flavors. They will even make anything u want with a few days notice. My favorite is the Peach! It’s soooo good, but you have to special order it.
But they have an awesome array of staple flavors such as Plain Classic, Oreo, Chocolate Swirl, Amaretto & my 2^nd favorite Chambord. They even offer a variety of sizes, from 4 in mini to a 10 in which is 4.5 lbs of creamy goodness!
And don’t forget the toppings. They have many to choose from. My favorites are Pineapple & Blueberry, but they have Cherry & others too.
They even offer Sugar Free Cakes, fresh baked Rugelach. I think they even have knishes, although I’ve never tried them here. I come strictly for the cheesecake & Rugelach because both are superb!
So come through, it’s worth the drive even if you don’t live nearby.
2-​5-​2016

Been going here for over 15 years and Mr. Bills makes the absolute best cheesecakes by far. Even better than Juniors in my opinion. Lots of flavor choices and the staff is friendly and helpful. Highly recommended if you’re looking for a great cheesecake!

All these reviews cant be wrong. This little storefront turns out some of the smoothest best tasting cheesecake around… Usually with this stuff you can only eat a slice but I found myself still cutting after the first slice. most any flavor I tried was great but if you stick with the CLASSIC (plain)you wont be selling yourself short… I just wish they made the ITALIAN RICOTTA style.

Everyone I know can attest that my sweet tooth is pretty strong, definitely a force to be reckoned with. But for some reason, I never really liked cheesecake.
Until, I found Mr. Bill’s Cheesecakes. I have been converted. And my dad was thrilled with his cheesecake on father’s day.
Although I’m happy that this place is located so close to me, I don’t know if my waistline will be in a few months…

Best cheesecake in town! I’ve been ordering cakes from Mr. Bill’s for years – for office birthdays and holidays at home. My favorites are the classic, chambord, caramel, and Oreo. I recently tried the cannoli and it was also very good. The sugar-​free cheesecakes taste excellent and are a good option for low-​carbers.

So yum. Good selection of sugar free. Call ahead for a special. I’m picking up a banana cheesecake sugar free for new years eve chill. Check their website for possible flavors. And the people that work there are super cool and helpful. Cookies are yummy too.

Excellent! They have an extensive selection of cheesecake flavors, including sugar-​free which I’ve never tried. I’ve had the chambord & classic, and both are delicious! I am looking forward to trying many more flavors. They do have a few bakery items on premises (cookies, rugelach, etc). I don’t live close by, so I’ve always called ahead to make sure they have the flavor & size that I want before making the trip, just in case.

Went there mid-​afternoon on a Friday, and were very limited on their mini selection flavors. So get there early. I got the regular classic and the popular oreo … Out of this world.

He is the best! Really good, creamy cheesecakes. I usually get the classic with cherries on top… never disappoints! Also very nice people who run the place. Definitely worth a visit!

This is the best cheesecake I ever had! I took one of Mr. Bill’s cheesecake to work for a potluck and everyone loved it! My coworker drove from queens just to get one, yup is that good!

I stumbled into this place while I was waiting on Spanish food from next door. I got a mini cherry cheesecake and a mini Oreo cheesecake. I have eaten a lot of cheesecake in my time and I have to say this is one of the best! The menu is also HUGE! I am looking forward to ordering more from here in the future!

I’ve lived around the corner from Mr. Bill’s for years and would prefer it over anywhere else! Puts Cheesecake Factory to shame! Everything is made with love. It’d probably be cheaper to get a cheesecake from a grocery store, but will never come close to Mr. Bill’s! The place used to seem a bit run down in side but in the past few years, it had an incredible upgrade inside. They offer a free small sample size.
Advice: Get the Oreo cheesecake!