Uncommon Pizza

Went for first time today and definitely will be going back. Great food, good prices and wonderful service.

Awesome drink and food specials every day. Fantastic food and bartenders. Love the garlic knots and pizza. Located in Kissel Hill Commons Lititz (Manheim Township). Plenty of TVs for sports fans.

Decent food, decent beer selection and wonderful owner/​staff at a reasonable price. It helps I can walk here too!

Location was great and service was nice. Quality of the food was… well…common.

We’ve been going here for about two years now and it’s consistently hot and fresh when it comes to our door. We’re fans of the pizza (duh), the wings and the nachos. I like that they are a small business and the quality matters to them. This is now the only place in Lancaster we get pizza from when I’m not making it from scratch at home.

UnCommon is truly UnCommon. I went on Saturday night with friends. The wings were standard wings but the Buffalo Chicken Pizza was to die for. Excellent, quick service was a plus. ¹¹⁄₁₀ would go again!

Hard to find, if we weren’t lost trying a short cut to the movies we would never have found this place. Food is good, nothing too crazy but still good. Beer was reasonable with a far amount to pick from. Would like to see them add a little more selection that isn’t bud lite. Inside seating is a little cramped, but you can see that they have a big patio seating area for in the summer.

Our neighborhood go to for a quick & good sandwich, beer, & or salad. Pizzas are always good & made fresh to order. Great weekday specials too!

Got delivery. Which is cool, there are many pizza places in Lititz — but rare to get delivery. I had pasta and wings. The wings were extra crispy. I ordered hot wings — there was no sauce on them. The pasta with meatballs and fresh mushrooms did not have enough sauce. Also, not enough pasta for the price. First and last time for me.

We tried the taco pizza with extra meat and cheese. It was superb! The staff was friendly and we got good service. They are casual. It’s a casual place. Don’t expect 5-​star wait staff or fine-​dining attributes. But they do what they do very well.
Forget two $ 10 pizzas from Pizza Hut. This taco pizza must have weighed 20 pounds and I had leftovers for lunch the next day.
I’ll go back again anytime and try anything on their menu.

Very nice location, where friendly staff greeted us as soon as we walked in to place an order for carry-​out. I appreciated the free Mr. Pibb while we waited for our food to be prepared. Since this was our first time, we decided to sample some different things. The spicy bbq wings were excellent; meaty, cooked to perfection, and flavorful. We got a large pizza that was very good; half mushroom and sausage, and half bacon and onion. Crust wasn’t too thick or too thin. The Philly Cheesesteak was ok, but I probably won’t get it there again. It was almost as if the meat, cheese, green pepper and onion were cooked and pureed together. I thought the consistency was too mushy, and the flavor was lacking. Finally, the fried mushrooms and pickles were nothing special. Portions on those were small for the price. I will go back to this place, probably for one of the wing specials we saw in the menu, and next time we’ll dine in and maybe catch a ballgame on one of the three TVs; seemed like a nice atmosphere in there.

Lancaster has an over abundance of restaurants, banks & mattress stores.
Although this is a small restaurant, Uncommon Pizza has separated itself from the pack by:
#1 Food Quality (There isn’t a thing on the menu I haven’t liked)
#2 Food is Consistent (example, the Buffalo Chicken pizza is the BEST around AND tastes the SAME every time we order it), and
#3 Service (friendly & attentive (empty glasses are filled without flagging down a server)
The atmosphere is warm, welcoming & casual. You will see customers of all ages here. There are 3 TVs, wifi, regular customers and servers who remember you. Uncommon Pizza is doing things right and it shows. Keep up the good work!

Cool little hidden pizza spot. To call it just a pizza place is not exactly accurate. The menu has some great sandwiches and appetizers. The fried pickle spears are awesome. I didnt have any of the specialty pizzas but the ones I saw come out of the kitchen looked tasty. Not your typical Lancaster county pizza crust. I ordered the 10 inch calzone and it was a large enough size to call for a to-​go box. You can pick up too three toppings to add and at 6.99 it was a great buy. Small bar to sit at with 4 taps. 2 domestic and 2 craft brews. Troegs and Victory when we were there. A small selection of bottles that didnt do anything for me. Also a full liquor and wine selection. Overall just a great little spot to check out. And very kid friendly too!

Pizza was average, not a fan of the crust or sauce. There are better pizza joints in Lancaster, but they do have some unique varieties if that’s your fancy.

Excellent pizza and courteous service. Try their cheese fries or their Philly cheese steak pizza, you won’t be disappointed. And they support the local Landis Valley Village & Farm Museum.

These guys are great. …and we don’t even have our pizza yet. They added a coupon to our massive take out order and gave us free sodas. We’ll be back.
Update: The pizzas, fries, nachos, and Philly Cheesesteak were all excellent. We ended up doing takeout for about 14 of us and these guys rocked our night. Praise God for your food. Thanks guys.

Without a doubt, my go to place for pizza, subs, and Philly-​style Cheese Steaks (I’m from the Philly suburbs originally, and yeah, I know a good steak).
Their pizza is made with fresh ingredients, it’s consistently good, and it’s always hot when delivered. Never in three years have I had a complaint about anything with them. The people are friendly, courteous, and the food is simply great.
There just isn’t a better place to get pizza and subs. Two other places are almost as good, but Uncommon edges them out because of the consistent quality control of their food. Prices are also reasonable.
Five stars from a very picky customer!

Uncommon pizza is our go to carry out food. Their Hawaiian pizza is out of this world and their buffalo wings are delicious. They also run great dine-​in specials during the week.

Great little spot. Good pizza and service with a smile!