Fitz’s On The Lake

went there for dinner tonight. had not been there since it changed hands.
got the trio special (along w two other friends, one who got the trio and one to got the steak special). first we had to wait so long for our dinner and there were not all that many people there. in fact there was only one other table filled in the lower dining room when we put our orders in. when we finally got our meals, mine was missing part of the chicken. I asked and waitress said, it would be right out. well, I waited and waited and then when a dif person came back I asked again, then she brought out a pc of chicken that was cold and soggy w oil.
I had tasted the ribs and they were tough and had a funny flavor. I asked if I could have another chic. breast instead and was told «no!»… she said the ribs had curry in them.
sorry but when I order bbq ribs I expect bbq ribs not curry ribs! so, that went in the trash.
same thing w my friends. she thought it was awful as well.
the steak my other friend go was mostly fat! out of a pc of what looked like a large steak, turned out to have about a 4×4 pc of actual meat in it.
won’t be going back there again!

Wow breakfast as fit’z is 5 star!!! I went on Memorial Day for their breakfast and had the omelet. It was huge and delicious! The new patio brick work is a great addition! Can’t wait to go back!

The best fish fry around. Always good service. I nice family friendly restaurant. We like to sit outside by the water in the summer.

Under new ownership and it is 100 times better. Food was amazing. Definitely an improvement.

Great food with decent service. Fitz’s is probably the premier bar/​restaurant on Lake Wisconsin. Much better food and service than Lucky’s across the street.

This used to be, hands down, the best spot to eat on the Lake. No longer.
Broasted Chicken, great burger, blackened prime rib, great salad bar, decent old fashioned, fun and friendly staff.
Howie and Asta did it right.
New guys… not so much.
Took away all of the above. Terribly limited menu and unfortunately now pretty crappy drinks. No salad bar offered with the very overpriced special of the day, because it comes with a vegetable. What?
NO BROASTED CHICKEN!!! Come on, just deep fried with no seasoning?
What is with all the crap in the corner of the dining room? Looks awful.
The new chairs that match nothing were not the best way to spend some money, maybe fix the tile in the bathroom with a tile, not duct tape.
Serving staff, obviously tired of explaining above poorly thought out changes to disappointed patrons, were polite, but short.
Used to be a frequent customer, won’t be back.

I have seen alot of very positive reviews of this place. So we stopped on our way home called ahead to put our name on the list so the wait was not as long. We had the haddock fried too dry and crust was to hard since it was all you could eat one of us tried it again much better. We also liked the coleslaw and the augratin potatoes. We let our server know about our experience she did nothing about the bill. I would have expected more.

On a recent Thursday night, my wife and I ordered steaks. They were done just right. The salad bar was good and the ingredients were fresh. The service was good and waitress was friendly. Quaint location on the Lake.

1^st time here. Popular spot on a beautiful summer evening. 2 hour wait that ended up only being 1 hour. Really quite good «All You Can Eat» Fish Fry. Good sevice. Great atmosphere! Fish has a nice crisp twang to it! As Arnold would say…“I’ll be back”!!

How can you go from one extreme to the other. Was there on a Friday night with 8 people at the table, all were very happy with service and food. I even got something I did not order but kept it and it was really good. Went back the next morning 8 people and we all had an awful breakfast eggs done different on the same plate French toast that I think they forgot to put an egg in it. Eggs Benedict no one liked. They just might need a new Breakfast cook. AWFUL

Great atmosphere. Services wasn’t the greatest and the Sunday buffet was overpriced and nothing great. The Bloody Mary was a big disappointment

Good lakeside experience. Big bar serving all the standards. Someone in our group had a Bloody Mary and said that it was hood. Everybody liked their food. Good burger, good Rueben, standard salad bar. I’ll be back.

I’ve only been here for the fish fry. It was excellent. The staff is very capable and handles the crowd really good. Very pretty location. Can’t wait to come back.

Had the fish fry and it was delicious. When we got there the whole place was packed. Were told that the wait would be about an hour but got seated pretty quickly considering how busy the restaurant was when we got there. The best part of the meal was the staff they were very very very very very friendly.

Great view of the lake, from the deck & from inside. Very hospitable & the salad bar + soup option for $ 8.95 was a great deal. We might come back for the Wed nite BBQ ribs special.

I live 3 hours away and I would drive that distance just for the fish fry. The food is phenomenal and I am jealous of everyone who lives nearby and is able to go whenever they want!

I am from Chicago and always make Fitz’s On the Lake a stop on my trips to Wisconsin. The fish fry on Fridays is amazing. Out of all the places I have eaten in my lifetime, Fitz’s is in my top 2. There is a reason why a Chicago Blackhawks Stanley Cup winner would travel to WISCONSIN to share the cup. Fitz’s is simply a place you can’t pass up.

After a long day of skiing, me and my cohorts were famished. Fitz’s nourished us back to health so that we could continue our long journey home. This is a very relaxed local bar type of place. The service was good and so was the fish fry. I tried the haddock and I wasn’t disappointed. I was disappointed in the fried lobster bits, but I shoulda known that might happen. It was a high risk/​high reward situation. Don’t drop the $ 11 on making this a luxurious side item.
Other than the lobster, I have no complaints and I’d like to try some of the fish they have to offer. The salad bar that is included with all entrees is a nice touch, as it was nice to eat some leafy G’s before engorging myself with fried food. If I’m out at Devil’s Head again, I’m sure I’ll be back.

I eat at Fitz’s on the Lake often.
Most recently, I was there on a Tuesday. As I usually do when I’m there on Tuesday I ordered the beer battered Haddock special. Which was very good.
They also serve the beer battered Haddock during their Friday fish fry. On other nights they have Blue Gill, Perch, and grilled Salmon.
My favorite soup is the roasted red pepper tomato soup.
I’m occassionally in there for lunch on Saturday afternoons. My favorite lunch special is the barbequed pork sandwich, which is cubed pork rather than pulled pork. I like both actually, but I like Fitz’s version the best.
I’ve only been in there once in recent years for the Friday fish fry. They get BUSY so take that into account in your planning. Fitz’s has a nice little bar, but it’s LITTLE so it’s hard to find a place to sit unless you go during the week and maybe not then.

Always a great place, to go the food is excellent along with the personable and down to earth people that work here, I have to say this place hasn’t changed much except for maybe the owners ??? I use to live directly across the lake from here, anyway the breakfasts are always good I never had a bad lunch, and the dinners are great I cant say enough unfortunately I only get to this neck of the woods once or twice a year now so I always make sure that I stop in for a meal