Their gas is of decent quality. I use Gas Cubby to monitor my gas mileage and their gas seem close to BP after years of testing both. The store always seems clean and friendly staff. Pizza review: For a gas station, their pizza I’d rate 4⁄5. Ordered 4 – 5 times so far, every pizza tasted the same and was ready in 20 – 25 minutes for carry out. The crust is thick, but not deep dish style. The crust has has a slight hint of yeast flavor, which I like. The crust is flavorful and distinctive from any other pizza I’ve had. The sauce is tasty and they don’t skimp on it either. Cheese is decent quality as well as the toppings and don’t skimp on them either. Reheating the pizza the next day, well it taste like it was made today. Best reheated pizza I’ve had so far. One thing that sets Casey’s aside from all other gas stations is you can fill your tires for FREE! Every other gas station wants a buck to fill your tires!
Kelly B.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Shelby, IN
Casey’s is a pretty good gas station. They have a decent selection of snacks(not much for vegans tho) & offer a pretty popular pizza. It’s relatively clean in here and the staff is quite friendly. The gas is about the same price as other local stations– no surprises there.