Dominick’s

Charged me for the wrong thing and got my order wrong so I had to wait twice as long… gave me a free drink but forgot my coleslaw. Chicken sandwich looks good and a lot of hot fries.

I ordered a salad and wings from here on a Wednesday night via Eat24 at 6:37pm… got my order at 7:50pm. Over an hour wait for just salad and wings? I was at work on the same road not even 2 miles from this place so I was very disappointed about the wait time. I was hoping that my $ 8.50 salad would be well worth the wait… I was wrong. The salad was very generic, the romaine lettuce was full of clunks rather than leaves and some leaves that were red and brown (aka Not fresh) so I ended up only being able to really enjoy just half a salad… I went on to the wings hoping they’d make this meal better… also generic. Nothing special about them. A bit overcooked for my liking and although I ordered them with mild sauce, only half of them really had sauce on them. I tried pouring the sauce from the bottom of the foil onto the wings… the sauce didn’t quite tickle my fancy. I was better off eating them plain. All in all… this is a pizza joint, I am aware. Maybe their pizza is better but the salad and wings were disappointing. Not horrid but not spectacular.

Four stars for really yummy deep dish pizza! Standout chewy, thick yummy crust with oregano– spiked sauce and and real tangy mozzarella cheese. Now. Thin crust pizza– just OK. Same with subs– nothing bad, nothing great. But sides… Fries, onion rings, coleslaw… Bad! Really bad! Never crispy, really greasy or overly sweet… Tartar sauce that reads «keep refrigerated» arrived piping hot in its little plastic serve pack; coleslaw warm; fried things cold and soggy. Delivery is very slow too, min 45 minutes … May be why food temp is off! All in all– unless you really want deep dish, and don’t mind wait, go elsewhere!

(11/​21/​2015) Someone brought 2 Dominick’s pizza to a potluck (a plain cheese and a mushroom and onion). Dough was thin, rolled flat to the edge, no significant crust, sauce pretty sweet, but otherwise bland. Mushrooms were canned, onions were red and sliced in thin half moons. Sufficient cheese. Overall, underwhelming.

I have visited Dominick’s 3 times now.
The cheesesteak sub is awesome. Get it fully loaded with the hot pepper spread and fried onions. The steak is usually super fresh and juicy and the bread perfectly toasted and buttered. The super sub special for 7.99 is a steal and comes with fries and a can of soda. Can’t beat that. It’s the best streak and cheese I’ve had in Baltimore.
I also tried the pizza on 2 occasions. I had it half cheese half pep and it’s a tasty pie; New York style, greasy, cheesy and delicious.
I have recommended this spot to several people and they have agreed with me on the sub.
They lost one star because on one specific occasion the steak did not taste fresh and juicy; actually it was dry and tasted heated up. Also this same time the pizza was not as cheesy as before. So a star lost for not being consistent.

Disappointed with delivery! We’ve gotten pizza here a few times, always good. Last night, I called and ordered 1 pizza and a cheesy bread, which is a small pizza with only cheese. I thought is was different, but must be thinking of another place. Ordered delivery since my husband was an hour away, and I wasn’t up for going out to get it. After 35 minutes, I called to check on status, and was told any minute, delivery was on it’s way. I only live 3 – 4 mins away. I called back 10 minutes later, after 45 mins to be told again, any minute. Then my husband came home, so he beat the pizza. The pizza showed up 1 hour and 4 minutes after ordering and it was cold. That was my kids dinner and they were so hungry, so we were all very annoyed. I’m more disappointed after my phone calls that I didn’t get an apology. A pizza on a Monday night should not take that long. Not happy about that.

Pizza is like beer or coffee. People have their preferences. After my first time visiting, I found Dominick’s pizza to be shy of sauce and missing character. We found the need to add seasoning which is unusual for us. Personally, I think it missed the mark but I know some people will still love it (which is understandable!). Great option for the happy hour giving a free large cheese. We ordered fries — tough to screw them up. But we also ordered buffalo shrimp. It would have been better to simply walk to the neighboring grocer and order popcorn shrimp and a bottle of hot sauce. We expected shrimp — like fan-​tail shrimp, not penny-​sized corn-​breaded stuff. Major disappointment there — enough to negate returning.
Three stars means «A-​OK» which could apply to the pizza. But the shrimp experience writes them down a notch.

Honestly, I’ve heard people say alright things about this place. Though, every time I have ordered food from here they mess it up. The food tastes alright if they do it right but half the time they just load it with sauce or cheese and thats all it tastes like. I wouldnt waste mine or your money on this place with so many other pizza and sub joints around the area.

As a Philly native in the Baltimore area, it has been a serious task trying to find good pizza. Dominick’s has totally delivered for me in this way. Seriously really good pizza, best in the area as far as I know. I only have 2 complaints: first, the staff is made up of a lot of high school students with few manners and poor attention. They never get my toppings. I don’t get charged for toppings, which is nice, but when I ask for toppings, it’s because I actually want them! And I only ever get 1 or 2 toppings so it’s not like it’s complicated, but I have yet to actually get more than a plain pizza here. I’ve been there several times when I guess they were the only people working, so they decided to blast music over the shop speakers, which was just really loud and annoying. Now when I go I just try to order ahead so I don’t have to be in there long. Second, I always get sick after eating this pizza. I have no idea why… it’s not super greasy, the sauce is good, the dough is good. For some reason, I just get really bad stomachaches after eating. I still eat here more than anywhere else in spite of this though — that’s how good it is haha

Delicious pizza! The crust is chewy and flavorful, and the pizza is not at all greasy. Good onion rings too. Staff is really nice, and our food is always ready very quickly. Welcome to the neighborhood, Dominick’s…we’re glad to have you!

I’ve ordered in the past from Dominick’s in Lutherville and each time I went to pick up my food the employees had such great attitudes and their pizza is always delicious so today I tried one of the sandwiches. When I received my sandwich I had a little issue with it so I called and spoke to the manager Eric and the way he handled everything was really awesome. He was professional and made sure that I was satisfied with my order. He made me another sandwich and even had it delivered to me.
I didn’t expect him to do that and I’m grateful that he did because he is the reason why I’m writing this review and why I will continue to be a customer at Dominick’s Lutherville.
P. S. The pizza is really De-​lish ;-)

We have enjoyed their pizza since they’ve been on Harford Road. We were excited that they opened a Lutherville-​Timonium location. The pizzas are terrific — thin, chewy crust. Toppings are good and plentiful. The salads are iceberg based and fresh and crispy. The wings are pretty decent and come with blue cheese dressing. Prices on wings are good. Go for the pizza!