Pizza Suprema

Was and am always impressed. One of the best you can get in this area without a doubt. I highly recommend them and would tell you from fat guy pizza eater, that you will not regret the choice to swing in and grab a slice!

Discovered this place after moving back in October. Best crust I’ve had on a pizza ever. The staff are friendly and welcoming. The pizza is good fresh of left over! Oh and don’t miss out on trying their cannoli they’re fabulous!
Delivery tends to be a little slow, but it’s to be expected when you consider it’s not a chain, but a family run operation and they get a lot of business!

These boys from Sheepshead Bay know their pie!
Ordered a large mushroom pizza, white pizza and eggplant parm hero.
The pizza has the right sauce to cheese ratio and the crust is fluffy around the edges yet crisp on the bottom.
Eggplant parm hero is a two person size with plenty of flavor.
Full menu is offered including great dinner specials.

Their Unilocal caption states that their secret is in the fresh ingredients. I just got my pie home to discover that it was covered in canned mushrooms. Absolutely disgusting! I feel the need to tell everyone as they don’t disclose this when you place an order.
Do yourself a favor and go to Marchello’s. Much better pizza and fresh shrooms.

If you like ice-​cold pizza that’s hard as a brick give this place a try. Paid with a credit card and they added the tip I agreed upon for delivery. Little did I know it would take one and a half hours to get it. The pizza was totally cold and horrible. Not worth the price paid or the tip left. Never again.

After moving up to Pasco one of the first things I had to do was find a good pizza place and after seeing the reviews I gave it a try and wasn’t disappointed. I’ve been back like four or five times and it’s still just as great as the first time.
You know it’s good pizza when it’s still tastes good warmed up the next day!

Best slice we have found in a while. It’s a family business and usually grandma is sitting at a table out front. They have great red gravy and fast service.

One of the BEST Italian subs and Margherita pizzas I’ve ever had!
And everyone there is genuinely friendly… great service. Wish they were in Orlando were I live.

Very good pizza, with good lunch specials. Never had an issue with service and have been there at least 20 times.

When Pizza Suprema first opened their shop next to the dry cleaners on Collier Parkway near SR-​54 they put out a superior pizza. It was fantastic in aroma and taste. Tonight we purchased two large pizzas and garlic knots. The pizza was not completely cooked and tasted horrible. It was like cardboard with a slight coating of chewy plastic as a topping. Disappointed to say the least.

Pizza supreme straight out of new york cannot be beat. Not only is the pizza the best in Tampa the service is friendly. No one comes close.

My wife’s coworkers recommended this pizza and even though we live 20 min away I wanted to see what they called «the best» pizza around. I’m a pizza guy and I got to say… wow!!! This place is amazing, the pizza is fresh, full of fresh ingredients and the right amount of sauce! I told the guy it was my first time there and he even gave us dessert for free! It was just what I needed, I do not mind the driving just to eat it again! Loved the doughnuts too!!!

I wish I could give them a 2 ½ the pizza was good. Not great I would order it more often if they delivered. Going to pick the pizza up was a real turn off.
The owner was very loud and rude. Down right nasty and disrespectful to the employee’s. That is the biggest reason we don’t go back.

Stopped in today and picked up some calzones to go for dinner. They were great! I’ve been a Pizza Suprema customer since 2004. I prefer the calzones over the pizza, as occasionally the bottom of the pizza is a little darker (overcooked) than I like. Also, the calzones are huge. Perfect size to share.

I have my friends had recently moved to Lutz. We happen to come across this pizza place to grab some dinner after moving. We’re very picky about our pizza but we were starving. From the moment we walked in we felt welcomed and appreciated as a customer. The girl behind the counter was awesome. .funny.customer oriented. .and just a great sense of humor. The food was simply amazing some of the best pizza I have had in a long time and their antipasto salad. delish! We will definitely be back

Delicious, quality all around.
At first I was a little intimidated by the price (not saying it’s outrageous but I’m a college student) but my boyfriend and I quickly decided we’d rather eat less pizza in favor of eating better pizza when we do.
I love the flavor and the crust, which is soft, chewy and crispy all at once.
When we need pizza and beer night this is the place for us!

Great NY style Pizza and even better service!
Driving up to this place it doesn’t look like much. The outside isn’t very inviting and it is tiny pizza kitchen with 6 tables and a counter. BUT if you are eating from any other pizza place in the Wesley Chapel area, its because you haven’t tried this one yet.
This pizza place reminds me of sitting in the kitchen with my Italian Grandparents. Don’t be surprised if you catch the family running this place speaking Italian. Always expect a warm greeting and a feeling like you are part of the family.
The lunch special is 2 super sized slices (any kind) and a drink for $ 6.00! Can’t beat the deal. Although they will heat your slices, If I have someone to share a pie with I prefer to order one freshly made with extra sauce because the sauce here is the kind of homemade sauce that again, make you miss your Italian Grandma’s kitchen. All alone on yesterday’s lunch break visit, I ordered to go, a slice of pepperoni and a slice of tomato basil (aka margarita). Again, the sauce on the pepperoni is worth every calorie you gain from pizza. The tomato basil slice is sauce free but has fresh diced tomatoes, fresh diced basil (not dried) and fresh diced garlic (not powdered) so it will require an after meal tictac but it is very good and had everyone in the work office trying to find where the amazing smells were coming from (my desk!). If I try hard, I can only think of two places that could possibly be improved and they are not serious enough to remove any stars, 1. Import water or use bottled water, anything other than Florida water, so that the dough stays crispy instead of getting chewy as it cools. 2. find some boxes for to go order slices. My to go order came on a paper plate put sideways into a paper bag. The sideways bag doesn’t keep the pizza warm and not ideal for car travel.
BONUS: Yesterday I learned that if you visit on a Friday you are not only greeted with a smile but with a freshly made Zeppole! Hot Fried Dough deliciousness!

We love this pizza place. The reason for the 4 stars is because of the long times given if we want the pies delivered. Therefore, We always pick and most of the staff is VERY welcoming and helpful.

I just moved to the area, and I’m a self-​proclaimed pizza snob. I wondered if there would be a place nearby that would satisfy my constant need for a decent pie. Well, it looks like I’ve found it, thanks to Unilocal!
My boyfriend and I have driven by Pizza Suprema plenty of times, but never thought to stop in. After my boyfriend insisted a few weeks ago that we order pizza from a chain I really, really dislike (it rhymes with «pizza butt») I knew we’d have to do better.
We ordered two stromboli (inside-​out pizza, basically, if you didn’t know!) — pepperoni, sausage, ham, and salami, a meatlover’s absolute dream. We asked for the sauce to be inside, but you can request it on the side if you’d prefer. When we arrived at Pizza Suprema to pick up our order roughly 30 minutes later, we were greeted by the friendliest staff. A promise was made to us: we were going to enjoy our stromboli. After paying and making the short trip back to our apartment, the cook was right. The stomboli were perfect! He even included extra sauce on the side, a small but appreciated gesture.
We are sure to be back, and soon! Pizza is the best.

Whenever I go home to visit my family I request Pizza from Pizza Suprema! It’s really my favorite pizza in the area and the best part is that I can order it by the slice!
They have a very small dining area for customers who choose to dine in, but this is definitely a location for carry-​out. Call ahead and order whatever you’d like. It will usually take about 40 minutes for an entire pizza, but slices are a bit quicker. I have even called them while I am on my way and they heat a slice of their white pizza up for me so that it is crispy and delicious when I arrive!
They have good lunch deals and the workers are really quick at taking orders and being efficient. I can’t wait to go home next week and grab a slice!