Amish Creamery

DELICIOUS! Anytime I see Amish-​made anything, I always think quality… this was no acceptation. Some of the best homemade ice cream we’ve ever had! I had blueberry cheesecake, husband had a scoop of banana & a scoop of chocolate, daughter had chocolate. The smooth texture and creaminess made this ice cream down right fantastic! No seating inside — therefore no bathrooms available. Not too much of a big deal, but would be a nicety especially if you have children in tow.

Was not impressed at all. Tried three samples of ice cream, all which tasted bland and the place did not seem very clean to me. I opted to not get anything and to go to another shoppe down the road for my dessert. Not recommended.

Best ice cream ever. Get a cone or take it home in a container! I love their butter and bacon.

best ice cream everrrr!!!
Very creamy and tasty. The staff is always so kind and helps you choose. The heavenly bars are amazing.

Owner is a surly, nasty, greedy «little» man. He actually screamed at my wife for daring to ask for a few samples before purchasing a *second* order of ice cream. He already KNEW she was a paying customer, but demanded «evidence» of a second customer. Then he proceeded to throw her change at her, across the counter. Seriously, do yourself a favor and go elsewhere, there are only about 1,000 other options in the area.
NOTE: You will find some other reviews from people with similar experiences where the owner claims the review was for his «competitor»; don’t believe the hype, it most certainly is THIS guy, Mr. «Amish Creamery Company».

Yum. Lots of flavors of hand-​dipped ice cream and they also have soft-​serve ice cream and yogurt If that is your preference.

Extremely fresh ice cream. Flavors are not all that inventive. And the mix-​ins are too skimpy. Like for example, if you get cookies and cream ice cream here, the Oreos are few and far between. They skimp on ingredients.
Another disappointing Florida ice cream joint.

We had a fun morning at the beach followed by an awful lunch at a so-​called steak house. We were looking for something that was guaranteed to be delicious to heal our wounds before heading home. That was when I remembered that I had bookmarked the Amish Creamery. It wasn’t really close to where we were, but we decided to make the drive anyhow. I was so happy that we did.
Delicious homemade ice cream in fun flavors, jars of jellys and jams. Baked goods lining the counter. Refrigerators full of more pints and gallons of ice creams. Yes… this was a very good call.
I ordered half Peanut Butter Cup and half Strawberry Cheesecake ice cream and my Husband ordered his treat (I was so distracted by mine that I am not even sure what he had). Then, we browsed the little shop while we ate our dessert. The Peanut Butter Cup was the best that I have ever had. It was packed full of tiny peanut butter cups and had a nice, rich flavor. However, the Strawberry Cheesecake was my absolute favorite. It had chunks of strawberries and chunks of actual cheesecake in it. The strawberries tasted fresh and weren’t hard and frozen like fruit sometimes gets in ice cream. It was perfect.
We also picked up a jar of homemade apple butter and peanut butter marshmallow spread while we were here… Yes. PEANUT BUTTER MARSHMALLOW SPREAD. Amazing.
The next time a beach restaurant lets me down, I know exactly where to go. We may even skip the food next time and head straight to the Amish Creamery.

This place is unbelievably overpriced. The ice cream is good, but not at all worth what they are trying to gouge you for.

My family’s new favorite Ice Cream place! Clint the owner and operator is a great guy!

What a great place! Don’t be turned off by the exterior of the building or the really long red light we had to wait at. The ice cream was so good, but the best part was the super friendly man who served us! He was the best! Definitely stop by if you are near Madeira Beach!

We had a delightful experience at Amish creamery. My parents and my children went here for ice cream after dinner. I first called to see how late they were open and the person on the phone concluded our conversation with ‘have a fantastic night.’ The establishment is clean and both workers were so friendly. The ice cream is delicious with many selections. Planation praline, strawberry cheesecake and cookie dough were all wonderful. I would recommend it and will return again.

My family and I came here for the first time tonight. I’d been waiting to try it for a long time and I am so glad we decided to stop in. They offer an assortment of homemade ice creams along with frozen yogurt and other baked goods. Some of their ice cream selections are packaged for you to take home.
My sister and I tried the peanut butter chocolate ice cream and my grandmother tried the pistachio. They were both creamy and flavorful. The peanut butter chocolate had actual peanut butter cups in it.
The owners were extremely friendly and welcoming. Prices weren’t bad for getting ice cream near the beach. If you’re in the area, don’t miss this place!

Yes. Please. And thank you.
Get the two pound butter log. The Rum Raisin ice cream. And the Peanut Butter Chocolate ice cream.

Believe the hype — this place has the BEST ice cream. The guy behind the counter was more than helpful and have my family of 4 all the samples we could want, and did it cheerfully.
We ended up leaving with a mix of chocolate, birthday cake, almond joy, mudslide, and plantation praline cups… and a half gallon of praline… and homemade oatmeal raisin cookies. Everything was amazing, and we’ll go back before the end of the trip.

The best! Plantation Praline is the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Can’t wait to go back!

Simply fantastic! Great assortment of homemade ice cream, reasonable prices, and the friendliest staff. I would recommend the Italian ice, trash can, or coconut almond and kahlua crunch side by side. We were on vacation and soooo glad to come across this gem. Please do yourself a favor and stop in if you’re in the area!

It was late on a Saturday afternoon, and a thick fog had rolled into Madeira Beach. My family and I were making our way to the car after a fun day of browsing local businesses when I noticed Amish Creamery. As I’ve heard it, anything Amish is usually known for being higher quality, so I figured we should at least take a look at the store.
Amish Creamery is mostly known as an ice cream shop, but when you walk in you’ll see an array of goodies. I honestly saw at least five things I wanted to walk out of the store with that day, but I restrained myself. They had a wall lined with jams, rows of popcorn and pasta, and cold cases of pies and cheeses (the cheddar bacon cheese looked especially tempting). I made a mental note of everything I’d like to pick up on the next trip, then headed over to the ice cream.
They had flavors I’d seen before and flavors I hadn’t, including one called Trashcan (a mash up of flavors that was as far from trash as you could get). My 6 year old and I were going to split a scoop, so I wanted to pick something we’d both like. When I brought up the birthday cake flavor Bobby enthusiastically agreed.
It looked just like other birthday cake ice creams I’d had before, with an off-​white hue and flecks of color from the flat sprinkles. I honestly wasn’t expecting much, but when we both took our first bite our facial expressions must have been hilarious. Bobby and I both were visibly excited.
«This tastes just like birthday cake, mommy!» I heard him say with high-​pitched surprise before diving in for another bite. And he was right. The ice cream was luxuriously creamy, with a subtle crunch from the sprinkles and the taste of fresh birthday cake. I felt like it was my birthday without the gloom of turning a year older. Wonderful!
I would make the trip to Madeira just for a stop at Amish Creamery. I can’t wait to come back for more ice cream and other tongue-​wagging goodies.

A small ice cream shop and general store across the street from the beach. This place has awesome homemade ice cream — be sure to sample a few flavors before you decide! I personally love the Kahlua Krunch and Plantation Praline. The store side of the establishment has an assortment of treats from fudge to jams to cheese. Some really unique items and flavors. Definitely stop in here if you find yourself in the area.

Delicious Ice Cream!
The Amish Creamery is a cool little shop! We tried the Butter Pecan and it was delicious! Very creamy, buttery and oh so flavorful!
We also enjoyed browsing the shelves of specialty foods and ended up selecting split pretzels and pickled okra. The pretzels were amazing, so much better than typical grocery store pretzels.
The owner was very nice and engaged us in a long conversation about his products, business and the Amish Community in Florida.
The experience was delightful and we would definitely come here again!