Topper’s Pizza

Toppers on Regent: Thank you! Always a wonderful treat to go in and enjoy the pizza and the wonderful employees. A special thanks to Chris and Donovan

Here on business and ordered a carry out Vegetable hand tossed. Better than Pizza Hut and not nearly as much grease. Was going to save some for the next day but couldnt.

This review isn’t about Topper’s pizza, it’s about one of their drivers. I was crossing the street right in front of Topper’s at a walk signal last night when a delivery driver came speeding as fast as he could around the corner. He came about a foot from running my boyfriend and I over. The driver had the nerve to scream at US out the window. This intersection has a lot of campus pedestrian traffic and this guy was driving incredibly dangerously. My boyfriend went into Topper’s to tell them about what had just happened in front of their store but I don’t know what’ll come of it. I just hope that this driver didn’t hit anyone on the rest of his delivery route.

Couldn’t be more happy with the service at this location. Had placed an order with a different location and about an hour later, found out that our order was not placed due to location. Called this location and they gave us our pizza for FREE! Awesome customer service. Will faithfully go to this location. Michael is a great Manager!

I mean, it’s cool when you’re drunk and hungry and pizza is there but I’m just not that into it

If you haven’t had Topperstix before you are really missing out. Consistently delicious! It’s always ready within 15 minutes. The California pizza is one of my favorite pizzas. My family has consistently ordered from there for years and will continue to.

They consistently screw up my order. Like every time I go — they either forget to add the drizzled sauce or they make it with the wrong crust or whatever.
I don’t care because the staff is usually super awesome about it and the food is heavenly. True story — I was drunk one night and me and a few buddies decided that Toppers is literally the best restaurant in the world. Okay — maybe not, but for a twenty something like me — I pretty much survive off Toppers. I also haven’t done much world traveling.
Maybe once I graduate from college and go travel the world to experience real pizza — I’ll start to turn against my old standby — but it’s going to be really hard to beat their buffalo chicken pizza.
Thanks Toppers. You’re awesome. Even when you do consistently **** my order up!

Ordered a specialty tater tot pizza with chicken added along with an order of bread sticks. Holy cow was the pizza good! It was nice to get something a little different. It came loaded with ranch dressing, tater tots, green onions, bacon and cheese sauce. We added chicken as well. The cheese sticks were what you would expect. They did put in 3 packets of dipping sauce so you wouldn’t run out.
Our delivery was on time and the food was hot when we dug in. No complaints here!

I’m clueless as to why there is so much hype for this place. Maybe I should have ordered one of their specialty pizzas, but I opted for a cheese pizza instead. And it’s bad.
Wish I would have opened up the box when I picked it up; there is only a small amount of cheese on the pizza, and it has clearly been sitting there for awhile. On top of very little cheese, I got jipped on sauce. It was only luke warm, and it is hard to choke down another piece.
Next time I’m craving pizza, I’ll stock up on some frozen pizzas or walk down the street to Rocky Rococo’s.

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. I’m visiting from LA, we have some awesome pizza out there too. But this is the best pizza I’ve had in all of Wisconsin. Make sure to get your pizza on the tall boy crust! Toppers, you guys rock!!!

I ordered a triple order of Topper’s Sticks at 2am. It is currently 4:30am and they aren’t here. Topper’s turned their phone off at 3:30am so it looks like I’m not getting my food. This is really poor customer service. There is a debit on my checking account, and no missed calls on my phone.

I’ve ordered take out a bunch of times, and they’ve always had my order ready by the time I got back from shopping at the 7eleven kitty corner to the location. The thin crust pizza is on par with all the other major chains. My only issue is with their pepperoni, which are fairly narrow slices that curl up and pool the grease as the pizza cooks. I usually do a pat down with a paper towel. The staff are friendly and seemingly efficient.

My friends and I ordered 1 Large pizza and 1 Triple Order Original Toppers sticks through their website at 5:45p. The estimated delivery time was 6:37p. Not too bad… However, the delivery guy didn’t show up until 7:15p. To me, that is not good service. especially for only two pizzas. Delivery guy only said, «sorry about that» and when we called at 7:15p to make sure that the order went through, they guy just said, «It’s on its way.» I think it could have been handled much better!

On 11−23−13 I ordered a large pizza and triple topperstix for delivery at approx. 10:45 PM via online ordering from the Regent St. location. My email confirmation gave me an estimated delivery time of 11:31 PM. At 11:45 PM I called the store to inquire as to the status of my order, and after being placed on hold for well over 10 minutes, I finally reached a Toppers employee. I asked about my order, and I was told that it had left the store for delivery. I asked if the employee could give me an estimated time of arrival, and he told me it would be to me in approx. 10 – 15 minutes. 30 minutes later, at 12:30 AM, I had still not received my order, and finally called again to cancel my order entirely. I never received my order.
I am very disappointing with the service I was provided. This is not the first time I have waited several hours for a delivery from this location, but it will be the last. It is very disturbing that this location would allow a customer to be quoted a 45 minute initial delivery time, have that customer call the store after an hour only to be left on an extended hold, be quoted another 10 – 15 minutes, and then finally cancel their order 30 minutes later after a grand total of an hour and 45 minutes of waiting for their meal. There are many other choices for pizza in my area, and after this incident with this store I will no longer be doing business with them.

So toppers is fantastic… Bacon Toppers Sticks and fantastic delicious pizza… End of story. Bad things? they take WAY too long sometimes to get an order ready however I will say they are generally always busy. Especially this particular location because they are so close to downtown, students are hitting this place up all day. Also at the end of the night on a friday and saturday night it becomes packed to the gills right around 2:30am. Mainly students who work there but they are always really nice and do their best to get you your order ASAP. This location is great but they could get an order done a tad faster.

Easily the worst pizza you’ll ever consume.
I’m not sure how you can possibly produce so greasy and tasteless, but my hat goes off to Toppers.
To those that read the reviews that think, «Well, maybe the Topper’s sticks aren’t terrible» they are just the same grotesquely greasy pizza, cut into ‘stick’ shape pieces. Then, you take these spongy, grease-​soaked, inedibly rancid sticks and dip them in Ranch or your favorite vomit-​inducing sauce and eat them.

You have to completely and utterly tanked to enjoy Toppers. Period. There is no other reason any reasonable person would ever want to put this shit into their body. This is the result of Ronald McDonald and the Noid conceiving a demon baby in a pit of flaming grease. I have personally witnessed the reinforced cardboard pizza box fall apart under the pressure of that seeping acid they call oil. You will have burning diarrhea for days. There is good cheese everywhere in Wisconsin; the pudding-​like goop they put on top of their pizza is not an excuse to do this to yourself.
Combine this with the fact that they have the most arrogant, inattentive customer service in the history of restaurants, and it makes for the shittiest dining experience possible. It takes no less than an hour to get a pizza from here, but it leans more towards 2 – 3 hours when it’s late and the drunk idiots with no taste barrage the place with orders. I am pretty sure that eating at Toppers is forbidden in the Old Testament. For the sake of yourself, everyone in smelling distance of you, and the children with birth defects you may father/​mother if you continue to eat here, just put down the phone.
Upped to 2 stars because I enjoyed it in a drunken, shameful moment of weakness. May or may not have cried afterwards.

Open late hours, delivery, SOOOO cheesy! The cheesy Toppersticks are de-​freaking-​licious. So buttery. So greasy. Soooooo delightful. Costs a bit more, but it’s a distinctive cheesybread. :)

I really like the triple order of cheese sticks at Toppers. Their pizza really sucks, but the cheese sticks are pretty awesome. I’m not exactly the most adventurous eater all the time, but i decided to try the mac and cheese pizza.
Obviously they were copying Ian’s in that department, but I figured since I like the Ian’s pizza, i would try Toppers.
Big mistake.
OMFG, the first bite was awful. I knew there was something off right away. I lifted up the noodle cheese crust thing, and I realized that the whole crust was covered in some sort of orange glue. Seriously, the pizza was covered in some imitation cheese-​wiz. I say imitation because cheese-​wiz is better that the orange shit that was on my pizza. And I ordered a large! I actually threw the rest of the pizza away, because I wouldn’t feed that shit to a dog.

Oh you gotta be fucking kidding me.
If you live in a dorm, topper’s is like your idea of heaven. There’s something about being that age that makes you want to order cheese covered bread that’s so greasy that it soaks through the box and then dip it in ranch dressing.
You know what that something is called?
It’s called weed.