Pizzaiolo’s

Pizza didn’t live up to the hype. I had heard lots of good things about this pizza and the place was packed but we didn’t think it was great. Crust was average, and it didn’t taste bad just not life changing. Plus kinda expensive. $ 40 for carry-​out for our family of 4. Won’t be going back any time soon.

Nice addition to Magnolia. Service was good, atmosphere was good, restrooms clean, and food was great. I had the calzone and thoroughly enjoyed it. We also ordered mini cannoli’s for dessert. The cannoli was excellent. My family and I will be returning soon.

The pizza was amazing! Buttery, cooked to perfection. Have you ever had a slice of pizza that makes you question all the other pizza slices you have every had in your life? This place will do that! Not only do they have the pizzas on lock they also serve sandwiches, pasta, salads and great desert cakes! The lunch specials are well worth it. Nice quick 8″ pizza with a salad for $ 8! Not too shabby at all! The staff is super friendly, when I walked up and ordered they greeted me like we were old friends. The good kind of friend, not the kind you run into at Walmart. You know the kind you wish they stub their big toe every morning. When I was putting in my order I noticed they had beer and wine nice added touch. Also there is a playground where I can send my nephews and nieces to play while the grown family can drink a few beers and some wine. Absolutely love it here will be back!

Been there twice. Once last week and it was great, good food and good service. Went back this week, orders were wrong, people in the lobby complaining about the service, food was mediocre at best. I don’t know, I guess it depends on when you go. When you pay $ 40 for 2 large pizzas, you hope for better than what we got.

I went here for the FIRST time to go to the drive thru to try their «Pizza by the slice» I bought me 1 cheese slice and 1 meat slice. it came close to 8 dollars! (i figured… Ok well it does say «gourmet pizza» so it should be top of the line pizza. I was wrong. The slices i was served Looked old, They tasted terrible. The texture and sauce and meats of the pizza tasted old and moldy AND they were burned! I am originally from new jersey where we have some of the best pizza by the slices places. But the pizza slices YOU guys make is not made with passion or love like food is supposed to be made. 8 dollars for 2 slices of pizza that tasted like old frozen dough with old meats is a rip off. I will never EVER set foot in this place again. IF you are going to call it «gourmet pizza» AT least make the slices look just as good as the ones i see in your picture Or learn to use better quality ingredients. 8 dollars is just so wrong for 2 slices that tasted like old moldy dough. I am disappointed as i have been looking forever for a good place that sells GOOD pizza slices. I wish i can have my 8 bucks refunded! Taco bell pizza tastes better than this and that is not a good comment! If you want to make good slices. Travel to elizabeth NJ and hit up Elizabeth pizzeria on Elizabeth ave. Their slices are 2.00 each and guess what! They are made by italians that KNOW how to make a good slice because its made with passion and awesome ingredients.

Was looking for a quick bite after church. Tired of same old stuff (Rancho Grande) so decided to try this place out. Always leery of being first to try something out (in case it sucks). There was only one review on here and they gave it good marks, so I figured I’d try it also.
I’m really glad I tried it out, as I enjoyed the food and the wonderful service, plus the prices are very reasonable. Two adults and a child each had a personal pizza, a side salad and drink for under $ 25.
All of us had the pepperoni (surprised that the kids meal has same sized pizza as regular personal pizza) which was cut nice and thick. Dough was soft, nice amount of cheese and good tasting sauce. I reserve 5 star ratings, for something that totally blows me away, as in «best pizza I’ve ever had!» and it wasn’t quite at that level. However, very glad they are now in the picture, actually like them more than Locatelli’s and definitely more than the big box pizza places.
Glad to have some more dining options in «old Magnolia.» Best of luck to them and hope they stick around, as I definitely will be back.

Best pizza in Magnolia! Excellent crust, great flavors and good price. We came in on a Tuesday night and there was no line. We were able to our food in a very timely manner and it was fresh and hot. Service was very friendly and we look forward to going back. They also mentioned they have delivery which takes less than an hour, we will also try delivery. Keep up the good work!