Creamery Ice Cream

Good food and good service. The chilie cheese fries are great on a cold day, the hot dogs are a deal on wienie Wednesday.

Best ice cream ever. Summer is coming, and so is the ice cream in my belly. Keep doing it creamery.

This place doesn’t even deserve a «meh» rating. I ordered a large Oreo shake which costed $ 3.99 and then extra for the Oreos. The whole thing ended up costing me about $ 4.75. It’s kind of expensive for a shake but I wouldn’t have minded so much if it were actually any good.
The shake was made with soft serve ice cream. They got the ice part right but somehow forgot the cream. The shake was extremely gritty and was probably 75% ice crystals. It tasted like it too — the only flavor was the Oreos and maybe a very slight hint of vanilla from the so-​called ice cream.
The menu is mounted up above the front desk and is easy to read once you tilt your head up far enough for the cashiers to inspect the inside of your nose. It’s actually up really high and it’s annoying.
I really don’t plan on returning and that’s too bad — I wanted to like them. I guess they are still in business because they’re the only ice cream shop in Manhattan and one of only 2 fast food restaurants.