Vinatellis Italian Cafe

We stopped in while traveling because we were starving, in the middle of nowhere, and fast food did not sound appetizing. Man, did this place hit the spot! We ordered a pizza sub, and Italian deli sub, and the kids split the spaghetti. We also ordered some garlic knots.
The garlic knots came out first. They were fantastic! They come with a garlic butter dipping sauce, and a half order gets you about a dozen. Not a bad deal for a couple bucks. They were all different sizes so you know they didn’t just dump these things out of a pre packed frozen bag. The garlic was front and center, yet not overpowering. Soft, chewy, deliciousness. I could have been happy with just a big bowl of those.
The kid’s pasta was actually perfectly al-​dente, and the sauce was perfect for them. Not too bold or sweet. It tasted like every real Italian home cooked pasta meal. It also came with two giant breadsticks which I did not get a chance to try.
My wife adored the pizza sub. I had the Italian which had generous amounts of pepperoni, salami, etc, fresh tomatoes, and good quality lettuce. The meat and bun were perfectly toasted, and the amount of dressing was just right. The food did not fly out of the kitchen and now I see why: Great care was put into this sandwich!
Overall: great prices, great service, I’d definitely return the next time I’m making a boring trek up I-​69!

Second visit. Food was great both times.
Both times we stopped it was while we were traveling.
Today, my husband had the Deluxe Calzone. My son had the Chicken Parmesan and I had the Baked Penne. All the entrees were good.

I just had a lovely meal here. Wow, real food near an Interstate freeway exit. Will come again when in the area. I didn’t try the pizza but the potato soup, fresh breadsticks and the very fresh and tasty house salad with their house Italian dressing were all very good.

Bad customer service. Does not care about customers at all.

Doug the owner is not a nice guy, nor is the manager. The food is not quality and far to greasy and the location is too inconvenient to make it worth visiting. Overall, it is a lose lose situation getting food from here. Plus I did not find the cleanliness to be up to par.

Very Very Good… The quintessential small town, in the middle of nowhere, Italian pizzeria. House made pizza dough, and garlic knots. I would defiantly stop here again, since it’s conveniently located right off the main highway.

Good pizza!!! Hometown gem!!! Definitely worth trying. Staff was friendly pizza was good!!! Tried the taco and deluxe pizzas.

Ate here on a road trip, great find! Did was awesome & affordable!